Loomio

Including New Hands in meetings

mix irving PublicSeen by 71

Have observed that in some meetings a New Hand (e.g. myself and others) asking a question or offering a suggestion can get a reply of (somewhat awkward) silence from the group.

Knowing the group to an extent I presume this means that what's been said is not quite right or relevant but would take too long to address in the current setting.

I appreciate this, but would like to suggest the community needs a better way to make New Hands feel more acknowledged, included, and valued in these scenarios.

mix irving

I have an idea for possible solution, but am aware that a more successful Loomio strategy might be to pose the problem and then step back

Richard D. Bartlett

Aww man sorry if you've had an awkward experience in the meetings, thanks for raising this in a constructive light John.

IMO this goes right to the core of the Loomio challenge: how do you give everyone a say and still get stuff done? How do you do genuinely accessible open governance without the undue expense of continuously educating newcomers? How do you stay open to the input of people who bring a fresh perspective to a discussion or decision?

I think part of the solution is to be more explicit about the purpose of any meeting, so everyone knows what they're there for. It is often not very clear what kind of input is being asked of 'new hands'; it would be good to think about how this can be clarified.

I have a hunch there's no easy answer, and we'll evolve good processes over time if we stay reflexive and open to change.

Benjamin Knight

@richarddbartlett , you have said exactly what I was about to write (but much more articulately)!

Benjamin Knight

PS thanks for raising this @johnirving

Jon Lemmon

Thanks @johnirving for bringing this up. I think active communication about this stuff is really important, so I appreciate you starting this discussion. And yeah, apologies for any uncomfortable feelings you might have felt.

I'd be interested to hear any ideas you have on how to make newcomers feel valued while still providing space for the rest of the group to keep moving forward at a reasonable pace. As Richard noted, we're beginning to realize that this is a significant challenge which spans several different aspects of the project. And obviously the group hasn't totally figured it out yet. I think your input/perspective could provide some good insight into the issue.

Chloe Waretini (Loomio Helper)

As another new-comer I've been thinking a bit about this too. I haven't had any awkward silence moments yet, but there has definitely been a fair bit of stuff that has been over my head. The most helpful thing has actually been spending a decent amount of time in this Loomio group. In terms of meetings I agree that having a purpose and/or topical agenda posted with a reminder on yammer or something similar could be helpful? There is never going to be a huge number of people who have as broad an understanding of the whole as the core people, but maybe the best thing to focus on is having a particular area/s of action based on where our interest / expertise lies as well as having a clear enough picture of where that piece fits into the whole and then open access to information? Further down the track induction toolkits / workshop type things might be the most efficient way to do it, but probably not needed right now?

mix irving

good ideas @chloewaretini

I also like the suggestion of having a clear invitation around what would you are interested in input on. The difficulty is that you probably want input on everything (because of unknown unknowns).

Proposed solution could be to have a clear process that goes something like:
1) affirm contribution
2) explicitly bookmark/shelve the conversation with an invitation to explore conversationally after meeting
3) follow up on that

this might keep tempo but encourage participation.
other members should be able to challenge the person proposing the shelving at step 2 if the new hand has stumbled onto something subtle but pertinent.

mix irving

oh,
p.s. I don't feel bad, like I've said many times I feel very welcome and as you know if I don't feel something is clear I'll tend to say so :P

vivien maidaborn

It has taken me all day to pull together my thoughts here, it is a great inquiry we are having about new people joining our groups and discussions. Clearly something we want to be really good at
L, so thanks for bringing it up John.
My thoughts are about how we invite people in and both welcome them and open space for people to sense into the culture we are developing. Culture is complex and multi-layered, I think us learning how to find ways of inviting people to take time to sense into it and feel how it works is as important as being clear about the more explicit things, like agendas and what meetings are appropriate to go to. And ai also think we will never get this entirely right. Some people will get this space we are working to cocreate and for others it might not ever feel really comfortable . I guess we will even learn more about how to tell if we need to improve a process or cultural form and when a person knocking at the door decides it doesn't feel good for them

Richard D. Bartlett

I'd love to hear from other relative newbies like @simontegg, @lizwilloughbymartin and @matthewbartlett on this thread.

Liz Willoughby-Martin

I think this is a great conversation to start having!

I haven't felt the awkward-silence-thing, but I have sometimes wondered if it's right for me to be at a particular meeting, ie: if I have anything to contribute.

I think @johnirving's suggestion to this particular problem is excellent. On a wider scale, an easy way to start to looking at New Hand induction processes could be to have Old(er) Hand at each meeting who would informally chat to any New Hands before and/or after meetings to let them know more context, clarify any questions they may have, and make sure this is the right meeting for them to participate in. This could be super-brief.

Feedback from this may then give a clearer idea into what sort of New Hand processes/ toolkits/ worksheets may be needed. When there's time :) Anyway, just an idea.

Benjamin Knight

@hannahsalmon , @hannahmackintosh , @paulsmith might all have useful insights too! And I'm sure there more I've forgotten who would be awesome to hear from

Deleted account

I think everything that has been said so far has been really really constructive. As a New Hand I understand that there are some meetings it is inappropriate/unproductive for me to attend but I think it's important for New Hands to be kept abreast of exciting developments as they occur to ensure they still feel engaged in the project. I think the practice of putting meeting notes up on loomio or on yammer is a really good one, as @richarddbartlett has been doing. I also think that yammer or loomio could be a good place to discuss/clarify things bookmarked in a meeting. I think having an outlined purpose/agenda as @chloewaretini mentioned would help people who really want to contribute but feel as though they are on the periphery to find an area of loomio to engage with and attend meetings that pertain more specifically to that area.

Hannah Mackintosh

I haven't felt any awkward silences, but I am very comfortable with all the people who are in the meetings that I've attended. I think I also have the advantage of getting a weekly catch up from Rich about what is going on and what is developed.

I don't always feel like my input is entirely useful but I think that is just because I am a few steps removed from the 'old hands'.

I particularly like the tune in and tune out at the beginning and ends of meetings. I think this is a good way to include new people who are at meetings and open a space where they can express themselves.

Malcolm

Hey, brilliant conversation. Very Loomio-ish.
Not sure I've done enough to qualify as "new-comer," (only been to a couple of meetings) but this is a great conversation. I guess it illustrates the challenges of a group that is both really inclusive but also ridiculously productive and fast moving (I wish I could keep up!!).

The purpose/agenda for meetings sounds like a good idea to help figure out whether its something I could contribute to. And going round the circle to hear what everyone is up to is a great way to get started. My main challenge is not the silences (since I haven't had much to say yet) but figuring out where I can help. Being blessed/cursed with the skills/experience of a generalist is not so useful at this stage. But hey, even without a niche, I still think Loomio is such a ridiculously good thing!

Simon Tegg

Sorry for the tardy answer. I suppose I have noticed what John outlines, and appreciate John taking the effort to open this up. This also ties into simple stuff like invites to the right meetings etc.

In my own case, I haven't felt a big jarring process clash as my onboarding has been pretty close to ideal - been to 2 enspiral retreats with the loomio crew, shared in the heart circle, came to a bunch of meetings before adding value, read most things in Loomio drive yadayadah.

I'm also aware that the crew has been living in each other's pockets for a year, and strong teams (but also somewhat clique teams) form under shared adversity.