Financials and Constitution - Disbursement and Fluid Equity
How should we decide how to disburse the surplus that loomio plans on generating? A related question is how should we reward those who have put time into, and taken the risk of, building the loomio app and enterprise, and will continue to do so for some time, without or with very little pay?
I would recommend that general surplus disbursement, go into these categories
1. Social good
2. Reinvestment
3. Investor (financial and fluid equity holders) disbursement
3(a) Fluid equity holders
3(b) Financial investors
3(b)(I) Social (low interest) lenders
3(b)(II) Financial (high interest) lenders
Pragmatically, in category 3(b), people who financially invested in loomio at low interest rates (social loans) would be paid out first, followed by higher interest rate investors once the social loans are discharged.
Main question:
Should disbursement to these categories be set by a semi-fixed formula now (providing investors and workers with more certainty) , or should they be set on an annual basis (providing the loomio enterprise with more flexibility)?
As you will have noted, category 3(a) has been designated as "Fluid equity holders". Fluid equity holders have rights to a share of the enterprise's future revenue but not voting/decision-making rights. Fluid equity allows social enterprise startups to attract time-investment from workers and distribute risks and rewards. However, the details are highly configurable. In the interests of keeping this manageable general-philosophical input is encouraged but detail-oriented input should be directed to the question of general surplus disbursement.
Fluid equity scenario.
A financial value is placed on Jane's work for loomio (for simplicity, say $80k/year full-time). Jane may receive this as fluid equity and/or a salary . Let's say Jane took $40k as salary, and as fluid equity in 2013. Jane's salary would largely come from the app revenue (small) and a pool of money provided by outside investors. These investors will want their investment paid back with interest, but take the risk that loomio will fail and they won't be paid back the full amount! [the larger the fluid equity proportion taken by all workers the smaller their salaries and the outside investment needed]. Jane's fluid equity is recorded and each financial term her share of the total fluid equity issued by loomio to that date is calculated. Let's say that at the end of 2013 Jane holds 5% of loomio fluid equity.
The startup years pass by in a flash. Jane has continued to receive some fluid equity and now her total is $100k. However, by 2015 other people have joined loomio as workers, and as they have also taken fluid equity for a portion of contributions that are unpaid, Jane's share has been diluted to 2%. Now loomio is making an operating profit! Revenues are larger than outgoings [outgoing's include the Enspiral contribution], and loomio is now in a position to disburse its surplus. Total investor disbursement is set at 50% of surplus The fluid equity disbursement is 25% of surplus. Surplus is $1M, Total Investor disbursement is $500k. Fluid Equity disbursement is $250k Jane receives 2% of the fluid equity disbursement or $5k .
The following year, loomio's surplus increases to $3M!
As Jane is paid out her share may or may not decrease [different options here]. For simplicity, Jane stops recieving fluid equity and her share remains at 2%, but Jane's total pay out is capped at 20x her total investment [more options here]. In 2016, Investor disbursement is $1.5M. Fluid Equity disbursement is $750k. Jane receives 2% of the fluid equity disbursement or $15k , and so on, until over following years the total amount paid out equals $2M ( = 20x her total holding of $100k).
This is amazing @simontegg. Great work!
I have lots of questions... but I'm not sure where to start. I think probably having an in-person group discussion is in order here. But maybe first we can put together a list of things to talk about when we meet up? A few things I'm wondering about are:
- Sacrificing $40k of pay in 2013 for $5k of disbursement in 2015 doesn't sound very appealing. Maybe we could flush this story out a bit more to show the incentive of working for fluid equity?
- Should investors have voting rights? If so, how much?
- What's the incentive for giving a social loan vs. an investment loan (besides just a good feeling inside)? Are social loans supposed to be smaller than investment loans?
- I'm interested in the concept of giving greater rewards/interest for even small amounts of investment and lean towards almost a crowd-investment/funding model. Is this possible in NZ?
Hmmm.. excellent questions. I have edited the scenario as you suggested.
Regarding question 3. One thought is that because social lenders would be paid out first, they bear less risk, and that is a reasonable enough tradeoff for receiving lower interest.
An alternative is to just give everyone (both financial and sweat investors) fluid equity ( even the randoms whose commits are merged into master). This is what Sensorica does. This is simpler conceptually, more radical, and may have big plusses for the brand in terms of "walking the talk". The downside is that traditional investment channels may be turned off by its radicalness (-@vivienmaidaborn).
I have made a proper approach to Sensorica, inviting them on here and asking for their advice.
In this case, we would likely apply a risk-diminishment-based-inflation to people's contributions. The risk of investing in loomio is diminishing month-by-month as more learning partners join, and the business model is validated. Therefore, people who got in early took greater risk, so the value of their contribution should inflate proportional to this diminishment.
The Big Kahuna strategic decision is -does loomio want to be more like a community, or more like a network?
Hey Simon, I may have missed some of the conversation leading up to this thread, but just curious if this effected or restricted in any part by being a co-op?
My totally-lacking-in-legal-expertise impression from those convesations is that unusual equity/payment structures can be made to work (in either a coop, or a company), but it definitely helps if the lawyers are involved in this process. Might be completely wrong on this @stephenparry1 ?
I believe that this is the template that Sensorica use for fluid equity share agreements https://docs.google.com/document/edit?id=1w4dzjBGKr8G5yIRZAhmP82orOyFar-F8wgZoeYteiBQ&hl=en#
From a systems perspective, an argument against giving financial investors access to fluid equity and potentially large returns is that this is one of the mechanisms that feed and reinforce inequality in capitalism. There's a paper out there somewhere that models this but the gist is that if several agents invest money into a stock market, some will fail, but some will receive very high returns allowing them to reinvest even more. Even using random investment strategies eventually the system produces a few agents with a large proportion of the total financial wealth.
Arguably, by restricting fluid equity to people contributing labour to loomio, we mitigate this outcome (in our own small way).
http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/crowdfunding-come-under-microscope-securities-law-overhaul-bd-130064
It seems current legislation does not allow for equity-based crowdfunding but that upcoming revisions will allow it.
From a financial point of view Loomio would be better off paying off its high interest rate loans before the low ones.
@joshuavial . From the modelling I've done so far, I'm assuming the social loans are $50-100k and the high interest loans are enough to cover the projected following 12 months of costs -which generally comes out around $1-1.4M. With these assumptions it doesn't hugely matter which is paid off first because the high interest investment is so much larger, and the social loans are dealt with quite easily.
Currently pondering what constitutes a good metric of financial sustainability. Probably some combination of revenue vs. costs combined with assets vs. [liabilities + unadjusted outstanding fluid equity].
Working model at the moment has a low level (10% of revenue) investor disbursement triggered once operating cash balance is positive, and then a larger additional of level disbursement once financial sustainability is reached
Interesting, would be keen to have a look at the moels. Have you managed to get your doc into a google format yet or is it still locked away in excel?
@simontegg
@joshuavial
Loomio > Business > Business Model + pricing > Loomio business strategy for 2013: 11/12/2012.
The overview page isn't current. Most of the guts is in Monthly and Control Panel
When I say "working model". I mean some of it is still in my head.
Wow amazing to catch up with this conversation. I am thinking we should break the complexity into bite sized pieces. From our meeting today we know we will seek social loans for up to 200k (ish) in the automate phase. And we know we have fluid equity situation right now. So let's focus on placing mechanisms for these in the consitution and the financial modeling first and Trsut we will be able to resolve the bigger investment questions Ina years time or so when we are in the hard out scale fast phase.
"Reinvestment" is pretty fuzzy and in practice this will probably be new hiring + extension of contracts + other costs, and, as such would be set at the time. Any disbursement formula would probably apply to Surplus less Reinvestment.