Loomio

Move Burning Nest start date to the following Monday in 2025

The Nest Board PublicSeen by 211

What is the decision you need to make?

Whether to move Nest and start the event on the late May Bank Holiday Monday

Why is this important and what impact does it have?

  • Moving it allows families to bring their children as it aligns with the half-term holiday,

  • it clashes with Fire In The Mountain (FITM) which many of our community also attend,

  • there is a perception that moving it means less people will stay to help Strike

What information do people need for context?

There is no problem with the landowner in moving the date

When we tried this in the past it meant Flim Flam didn't bring their camp as too many of their members go to FITM

A consultation has already been launched in a newsletter (56 responses) and a majority supported moving the start date

We have held a Google Poll about moving the event to half term week. The results are as follows:
8/56 - no preference for moving
8/56 - keep dates the same
40/56 - move to the following Monday (align with Half Term)

Previous comments from a Google Poll

As Google Poll comments are private and not able to be viewed by the community, we wanted to list a few for transparency, so people see what has already been said.

Option 1: For Changing Dates to align with School Holidays:

  • "Kids being able to come is a big positive"

  • "Putting it during the school holidays is a more inclusive date"

  • "Option 2 is more child friendly and therefore more parent friendly.There are lots of great burner parents who I would love to see returning to Nest."

  • "Aligning with school holidays is key to inclusion, as it doesn't automatically exclude children, families, Just that personally as somebody in education I really appreciate being able to participate and am grateful when the dates fall during half term."

  • "Aligning with school holidays is key to inclusion, as it doesn't automatically exclude children, families, and everyone with teaching or education-related positions from attending"

  • "I know a lot of great humans who are teachers"

  • "School holidays make it much more accessible to me, as I have one in secondary and one in primary. I also work term times in an alternative education setting for young people, so holidays are much more accessible for my work."

  • "The weather is normally warmer & drier. Slightly More daylight hours too"



    Option 2: For Keeping it as it is:

  • "Very happy to be consulted, thank you x"

  • "Cost of trains and coach travel increases during school holidays and the roads are busier and more congested"

  • "Ending on the bank holidays means only taking days off work in one week, instead of leaving before temple burn."

  • "Family commitments during the half term holiday would clash with Nest if it were held in that week.

  • "Fire in the Mountain!!!"

Who is the facilitator?

Event Link (Michael Kossew)

What conditions need to be met for a decision?

We'd like to have a discussion with the community before finally deciding to move the date, after making sure that we are more aware of the implications of moving. Following a discussion and having met all objections to moving the event, the Links will infer a decision.

The conversation continues below the poll, so please do keep reading :)

Dee

😆

Alex Macklen

Having strike on a bank holiday makes the strike far easier. I think its a no on this alone.

Sadly for teachers, I'm no also because of the traffic and extra costs of things over the bank holiday. There is a line in "Withnail and I" when he was getting the empty holiday let keys, Withnail says 'Free to the people that can afford it' which refers to private schools not having 1/2 term at the same time as state schools. Try flying somewhere during 1/2 term. You''ll wait a week or two.

If private school teachers attend, they wouldn't be able to go if it was moved, so this is just for state school teachers. Nest going pure socialist?

While I understand teachers desire to attend, moving a fairly big event for a fairly small minority of attendees is taking radical inclusion to a level I don't think even Larry Harvey was thinking about when he created that line. They know when they choose that profession their holiday schedule, which prevents them attending certain events. e.g. Teachers can't do Glastonbury but can do Shambala. Having lived with a number of Teachers, they often spent those 1/2 terms working, writing reports etc. They didn't have to, but if they didn't they would have to work till 9pm for the following week or more. So the number of people we're talking about is too small for Nest to move its dates.

This will be true for other people for other reasons

I feel this is a very minor issue to hand wring to this level.

Adrian Godwin

I can't see the comment now, maybe it was deleted. But I'd like to say that despite my opinion being in line with dave wybrow's, in my limited experience I have had absolutely no problem with the children that I have encountered - and the last year I attended, my theme camp was adjacent to one specifically aimed at entertaining children.

The only negative I have was with a parent, who for some reason objected to her son seeing the buttocks of a very well liked and industrious member of the community (not me).

dave wybrow

I can see it would be nice to have more teachers able to attend but moving the event dates deliberately to encourage attendance by more children raises a lot of issues.

We would be irresponsible to do this on 50 odd votes out of 800 attendees or whatever.

We couldn't do it without getting serious about care/creche facilities, H&S and washing provision well beyond what it already is - plus we'll need a debate about public nudity, drugs, family camping etc etc

Care required! Especially when children cant be held accountable for the 12 precepts the way everyone else can.

If we actively encourage large numbers of children into Nest, who will we need to ask to do what in order to comply with the law and our own ethical stance about looking after them?

Kids attend Burning Man, but a whole extra level of thinking through has gone into it.....

https://survival.burningman.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/BurningMan_Family_SurvivalGuide_2024.pdf?_gl=1*1vokwy7*_ga*MTc5NjEzNjMyMC4xNzI2NjczMDE1*_ga_FWW1ZLL84X*MTcyNjY3MzAxNC4xLjEuMTcyNjY3MzEwNC4wLjAuMA..*_ga_411YJ8ZFDE*MTcyNjY3MzAxNS4xLjEuMTcyNjY3MzEwNC4wLjAuMA..*_ga_4334FXWCMM*MTcyNjY3MzAxNS4xLjEuMTcyNjY3MzEwNC4wLjAuMA..

Dan

My colleagues with kids always get priority off for half term so likely I wouldn't be able to come. I also agree Flim Flam is a huge part of Nest and if they weren't there it would be a massive hole in Nest. Also people might not stay for Temple if we didn't have the bank holiday the following day.

Ola Forman

I too would like to vote “no” to the date change as I want Flim Flam to be there!

Mark Hermida

I'd like to keep the date the same please. I know that Flim Flam would be unable to attend the following week and I personally think Nest would be a much diminished event without the ludicrousness we bring.

Carole Billingham

I would like to vote not to move the date for obvious personal reasons as I have a paid role at Fire in the Mountain and I don't want to miss Nest. I also think that Flim Flam is quite important to the whole event as no other camp brings quite the same vibe as they do and a variety of camps is always great.

It was moved to the later date in 2022 and the decision was made to move it back to the original date, presumably because some elements didn't work? Would be good to know the number of children, input of families with children with regards to strike etc. but as it was also the post pandemic hiatus, the stats wouldn't necessarily tell us much.

Inclusivity is also applicable to not moving the date for Flim Flam!!!

R. Mutt

The original survey has such a low number of people compared to the hundreds of Nestlings who likely have an opinion. I didn't even see there was a survey then. Does everybody know about this one?

Reason

Suggestion re: how to compensate strike numbers.

Overcompensate on Comms and make excessively clear that this is a big concern to organisers (as the price to pay to be more inclusive) and put front and centre of every newsletter that more heroes are required to sign up to stay for strike; pointing out that if you normally take off five days Mon-Fri of event, then it's the same number of days holiday (the benefit of the bank holiday just credited during event week instead of during strike).

Purely in a personal capacity: I don't remember a we-are-worried-about-not-having-enough-strikers call to action in previous years; if there were one, I think it would work on me.

If we rely on the strategy of letting people sign up to strike without a grasp of the high need, I understand that people would be less likely to stay without the bank holiday, and that's when we'd run into problems.

Nest Eventlink

Or Sunday to Saturday?

One issue with Friday is that Theme Camps need to get to site to set up, so they'll take more days off... And it gives DPW 2 fewer days to set up, stretched as they already are <3

I like your thinking though and it's definitely up for discussion if we do align with half term

Nest Eventlink

I guess another question is how could we incentivise people to stay for strike if Nest was during half term? Is it a given that people won't show up?

Jess

5 - No
1 - Yes

Sunday would turn into strike day with lots of people leaving before the temple burn.

Daniel Hurley

4 - No
2 - Yes

Not competing for leave allowance with colleagues who have children

Ali Puddle

5 - No
1 - Yes

My colleagues take school holiday dates.

Paul Lenz

5 - No
1 - Yes

Impact upon strike

Amir

5 - No
1 - Yes

I think we should consider more factors beyond only moving the week e.g. also moving the burn days to be Fri/Sat to allow a clear non-working day for camp strike and departure.

Johanna Kollmann

5 - No
1 - Yes

I wouldn't be able to make Nest if the dates change, as would the majority of my theme camp's crew.

Ben C

5 - No
1 - Yes

Better availability for strike and more people from my camp able to attend.

Untipr

5 - Yes
1 - No

Tough one, changing the date would allow individuals and camps that haven't been able to attend in years to return and has the potential to allow more new burners to join in. I don't think it should be a permanent change but I would love to be able to participate at least every couple of years. 🤗

Nori Clarke

5 - Yes
1 - No

I am a school teacher and i wish to be able to attend the full event

Robyn

5 - No
1 - Yes

As a teacher I'd have to leave on the Saturday morning and miss both burns in order to get back in time to work, and it would be a pretty grim week without any recovery time. I'd support a Friday to Friday option also if there was one, but at the moment I am able to get to Nest for the second half, support strike, and make my way back down to earth in good time. My enjoyment of the whole event would be massively impacted knowing that I'd have to leave my camp early to solo drive back.

Tara

5 - Yes
1 - No

A yes to try another date. The date change does not affect me personally but giving a different groups of people the opportunity to attend feels a good thing to do (and alternating each year seems like a decent compromise) - it's a shame that it seems like an all or nothing decision. As Allan has already said it may have an impact on folks staying for temple burn and strike, but if we don't try, we won't know (other events run successfully and don't end on a bank holiday).

Allan

3 - Yes
3 - No

I'm largely ambivalent about the date changes, my concerns are the potential to discourage people from staying for Temple Burn and for (at least the first day of) strike.
In 2018, the only previous time we've had dates outside the May bank holiday (4-11 June) we had a difficult strike (admittedly this was also first time at that site) with many people choosing to leave on Sat or Sun, missing Temple & unable to assist with strike.
That said happy to give it a try, a lot has changed since 2018.

Matthew

3 - Yes
3 - No

Flim flam are important, but also access for school teachers and parents is also important . The problem with strike if we change the dates could be overcome by running the event Saturday to Saturday

Gemma Smith

4 - Yes
3 - No

We should tread carefully where changes may fundamentally change the event and exclude a different group. I absolutely do not want that FF can't be there, but my thought is that there may be factors that no1 is anticipating, and we should perhaps just try it to see what happens. I like the idea of alternating each year, so that everyone gets a go, and then maybe it will become clear which way (if any) works best for the community and the event. So yes, for 1y & alternating. Not for a perm move.

Lauren Coates

3 - Yes
3 - No

I have mixed feelings on this, and maybe its for a separate community discussion. I work in schools and work with children. I think Nest is great. It would be much easier for me personally to join over half term but I think we need to be having a more proactive conversation as a community about safeguarding children at our events if we do end up moving the dates (/ we really probably should be having a more proactive conversation about this anyway) x

Ash

5 - No
1 - Yes

Sadly only had bad experiences of people's children at Nest.

wolfgang

5 - No
1 - Yes

flim flam obvs

Michael

5 - Yes
1 - No

I adore Flim Flam and they are absolutely one of the best theme camps anywhere. However, aligning with half term affects a much broader spectrum of the community which is really important for Nest as it grows along with its participants. I also like the idea of alternating weeks each year so it creates a balance between families attending and potentially having more people for strike. If this were a permanent change, I may answer differently, but I think it's worth an experiment for 2025

Joe

5 - No
2 - Yes

I’m not from Flim flam, but I see them as a real heartbeat of nest, I think them not being there would drastically change the event sadly.

The Nest Board

5 - No
1 - Yes

I personally would hate to see Flim Flam absent from Nest

Iona Steen

5 - No
1 - Yes

i have teenage kids but would not bring them to Nest ( too much drug use) so easier for me to go if not in half term- though it is of course better for people with younger kids

Georgina waters

5 - No
1 - Yes

I think the dates work better around the bank holiday and time off work. It would difficult to attend build if at all. I also really value camp film am.

Giorgia N

5 - No
1 - Yes

Our camp Flim Flam won’t be able to make it with the new dates :’(

Ola Forman

5 - No
1 - Yes

Keep Flim Flam at Nest!

Ally

5 - No
1 - Yes

It clashes with many other events happening that next weekend and would prevent many other people from coming including many of those who bring infrastructure.

Lew Husbands

5 - No
1 - Yes

The clash with FITM and change of bank holiday alignment would mean I might not attend as part of the flim flam theme camp

Maddie Broad

5 - No
1 - Yes

Flim Flam would not be able to come and would have to find a new annual home for our unique flavour of silliness which would be a mighty shame!

Lucy

5 - No
1 - Yes

Personal - I like having FlimFlam there, who are a core camp IMO, and the move also means having to take more work holiday for recovery and landing time. Also lots of people take the half term off at my work & they book it in at the start of the year and so I often can’t also have it off and so I likely won’t be able to come if it moves.

El Young

5 - No
1 - Yes

Flim Flam silliness & creativity is the heart of Nest for me, it would be so sad if the camp had to pull out. Also to support strike days and have as many people participate as possible on bank hol Monday to share to load

Mark Hermida

5 - No
1 - Yes

The inability of Flim Flam to attend.

Roofie

5 - No
1 - Yes

Flimflam won't be able to come because a chunk of the crew have paid work at FITM and all our infrastructure goes there that week.

Alex C

5 - No
1 - Yes

Voting out of self interest for dates next year, and my theme camp Flim Flam won’t make it else. Also the bank holiday for temple burn and strike is kinda handy. ‘Move it Sunday to Sunday’ idea might not be dealing with fact that pushes build back into the previous week. So…someone’s taking extra annual leave whatever!

However if there was an option of ‘alternate each year to capture maximum access long term’, I would pick that (but hope doesn’t it move next year).

Dominique Bull

5 - No
1 - Yes

I'm part of Flim Flam, and as many of our core members I go to Fire in the Mountain each year. We won't be able to bring Flim Flam to Nest if the dates change.

Nest is Flim Flam's home, was where I connected with my partner, and we now have a child together, and I definitely want to support families to come! But we wouldn't be one of those families of the dates changed. 😢

Joe

5 - No
1 - Yes

FLIM FLAM 🦡 🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡🦡

Kieran

5 - No
1 - Yes

Several reasons: people with families are prioritised for annual leave during school holidays, secondly having significant numbers of minors may cause complaints from parents when adults choose to express themselves in certain ways thereby controlling radical self expression, strike and temple attendance will be affected as folks will want to leave early to get home for the Monday return to school.

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it.