Rename Desicion to Proposal
In the same spirit as the original renaming of Motion to Proposal, I suggest the use of the term "Decision" is replaced with "Proposal" as well.
In the same spirit as the original renaming of Motion to Proposal, I suggest the use of the term "Decision" is replaced with "Proposal" as well.
proposal by Chris Zumbrunn Closed Fri 10 Oct 2014 12:09PM
Voting on proposals is often more of a temerature check rather than a actual decision. It fits Loomio better when that kind of possible sentiment is taken into account. Where a vote on a proposal is indeed intended to be a decision, it can be taken as that without that it needs to be explicitely called that. On the other hand, when it is a temperature check, having the outcome refered to as a desicion will not go down easy, especially with those people that did not have time to participate and vote, but none the less have a opinion they still want to contribute. Consistently using only the term “Proposal” is more adapatble and flexible for the various Loomio use cases.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 5 | 19 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 2 | 7 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 20 | 74 | 2 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 876 | 97 |
This proposal is well conceived and anticipates that the results of proposals may (or may not) not be decisions directly. When the results is representation of a collective mind, the positioning to the decision maker is very important. This helps.
This proposal is well conceived and anticipates that the results of proposals may (or may not) not be decisions directly. When the results is arepresentation of a collective mind, the positioning to the decision maker is very important. This helps.
This proposal is well conceived and anticipates that the result of proposals may (or may not) not be decisions directly. When the result is a representation of a collective mind, the positioning to the decision maker is very important. This helps.
I disagree because it's confused when you are going to terms.
It's ok to say current proposal.
But it's wrong to say previous proposals, but since you voted and ended the proposal it's decision. So you must read previous decisions!
The term "Proposal" looks more flexible. In many cases, the summary of all opinions may result in a practical decision or not.
For people to participate appropriately, there should be clarity regarding when a temperature check is being sought vs. when it is an actual decision. Decisions should be labeled as such; anything short of that should be labeled "poll" or some such.
It should be clearly labeled either as a temperature check or decision.
I agree with what Tree said, and that it should be clearly labeled either as a temperature check or decision, to increase clarity and avoid confusion.
Different things have different names. Why not call "decisions" what they really are: "polls". A "proposal" is contains "polls" which are created to check the temperature. After several "polls" & "discussion" a decision emerges, the "final proposal".
If this is a proposal I agree in the use of "I agree but I think we can find a better one. If not then this one is fine". Lets see if there is another proposal with better results.
The argument that a non-final decision would better be called a 'poll' is a strong one for me. For minimal confusion, I would stick with 'decision'.
This proposal is well conceived and anticipates that the result of proposals may (or may not) not be decisions directly. When the result is a representation of a collective mind, the positioning to the decision maker is very important. This helps.
I now believe that we should leave this as-is. The proposal writer has every opportunity to describe the result(s) of the group vote, whether a solid decision, a poll, "temperature" or other. The casting of the vote is the individuals decision.
The beauty of Loomio is its simplicity. "Decision" implies a clear end result. "Proposal" implies the possibility of further discussion. The fundamental purpose of Loomio is for collaborative decision making - let's keep that clear and simple.
This is an awesome discussion bringing out lots of important points. But I don't think there's one answer. We've looked into custom options for vote labels and decision/proposal/recommendation etc.. I think that's more the way to go.
Em sembla be, al final crec que lo primer que fem es devati. I despres decidim .
It sounds better
I think it is confusing to have 'Decision' as the heading and then 'Create a proposal' as the action.
What Jochen Walter sais.
The term 'decision' in this place has provoked some hot blood in our group already as it sounds way more determined as particularly the early proposals in a discussions usually are meant to be.
There is too much semantical overloading of both words. Loomio seems to work best for me as a decision support tool and decisions are the products of a vote. The decision can be a big or little deal (hot or cold temp) but it's still a decision.
I think decision sticks better in line with Loomio's simplicity. Aditionally, in a group people make proposals in the discussion itself but from time to time a decision needs to take place.
I think decision sticks better in line with Loomio's simplicity. In a group, people make proposals in the discussion itself but from time to time a decision needs to take place. And current design reflects that.
"Motion" and "Proposal" are somewhat synonymous. "Decision" and "Proposal" are not.
I don't really see the logic of this Motion/Proposal - so I think a Decision should be taken to reject it...
I think there are many legitimate cases where as a community we need to make time sensitive decisions. In those cases the distinction between decision and proposal becomes clear, we would have no choice but to make a decision before a given deadline.
I find a problem with the title proposal. When and how does a proposal become a decision. If what is being considered is a proposal, then what happens next to reach a decision?
I dont disagree with the challenge about the way language is used but there is no one right answer. I would prefer to just move to developing options so people can pick the language right for each instance or group
I went and voted for the Trello card to make this customizable instead: https://trello.com/c/RHrN06a5
I encourage you to go and do the same.
I went and voted for the Trello card to make this customizable instead:
I encourage you to go and do the same.
I changed my vote because of this Trello idea "custom language for headings e.g. "ideas" or "recommendations" instead of "proposal" or "decision", per group"
Changed and voted for Trello card https://trello.com/c/RHrN06a5
old: If this is a proposal I agree in the use of "I agree but I think we can find a better one. If not then this one is fine". Lets see if there is another proposal with better results.
Different things have different names. Why not call "decisions" what they really are: "polls". A "proposal" contains "polls" which are created to check the temperature. After several "polls" & "discussion" a decision emerges, the "final proposal".
Consistent language is always good; and accurate language, which appears to be the reason for the change is even better.
Sometimes a decision is needed and helpful to put closure to an idea/proposal. If the term proposal is overused, it seems there is never a final say or end to the discussion.
I feel 'decision' is more appropriate as a broader umbrella term - some decisions involve proposals, others involve suggestions, others involve ideas
I dont disagree with the challenge about the way language is used but there is no one right answer. I would prefer to just move to developing options so people can pick the language right for each instance or group
In many cases Loomio is used to (at least temporarily) finish off a discussion, calling the results of votes decisions aids in this process. If people did not get enough time, that's another problem which could be solved by... more time for voting.
Pondering. I wonder if a voter knew that the result of the vote would be a decision vs. a proposal leading to a decision, if they would vote equally. The latter potentially providing "one more kick at the cat". Somewhat less than a terminal vote.
If this is true, then there may be a need to distinguish between the two results of the vote.
In essence "An aggregated recommendation to an offline authority leading to an unknown decision" or
"an aggregated decision as the result".
In a Government context - Would one vote the same for a placebo as a referendum? Possibly, but not necessarily.
Words are important and "temperature check", while descriptive to some is prone to confusion or misinterpretation. The use of idioms should be avoided.
While some may be unclear on use of placebo vs. referendum if we can't settle on "Proposal" as generic, we need to offer an alternative. I offer no such alternative but remain open to another proposal.
We propose a suggestion/idea/option for people to voice their choice/decision/position/opinion.
Words. Is there ever a perfect one?
@Joum: So what is your suggestion/idea/option to propose? That we use none of the words or all of the words?
As long as we have to use words in different countries and ommunities there will be no word telling the absolut truth, or? But I will vote as well...
If the voting method is changed for that we can vote like:
- I agree with no exception
- I agree with some minor exception(s)
- I disagreee with major exception(s) but I could live this if there is no other proposal that leads to a better decision
- block - I can't live with that
- abstain
than it would be more clear that a proposal would not lead to a decision just because there is a majority which agrees. You won't know if there is a bigger majority for another proposal...
Just a note to highlight that the usual dichotomy between planners and doers is shaping up nicely on this thread with the doers seeming to have an advantage in this developer heavy group. Understand that building an ecosystem can be done bottom up and perhaps in the early stages it should be, however I am a proponent of working bottom up, top down and middle out all at once so that we do not need to wait for evolutionary time to get shit done. Deva value their freedom and the lack of distraction buy are generally not oriented toward the big picture (except the big picture in their own minds, which is in a small container). This is not a bad thing as we do need working code and that is how it is made, by ignoring things, not by paying attention to conflicting and fuzzy requirements. The key question is who is your audience, and how are you enabled. Getting code working only motivates developers. When I see this kind of talk I yawn and resolve to come back later and see if you've accidentally built something useful. Just poking the bear folks.
@robertbeck A proposal can be a decision as long as there is no other proposal with more agreement or less disagreement. Perhaps thats why it is a type of conflict: we disagree or block a proposal hoping that there is a better one to come. So, when is a proposal is voted and there is more than 50% of agreement, when would You accept this proposal as a decision and who has to decide? Do the group has to vote if the proposal is a decision or does the admin has to decide? Is there a decision when there is no one blocking and a majority took the proposal (whether Yes or No)? Perhaps every group or admin decides itself.
But if people who never lived democracy in such a direct way are to get in contact with Loomio couldn't it be that after the first "decision" is proclaimed they think that this point is fixed? - Even if there is told something else in the description?
At the risk of sounding simplistic, could it not just be an editable field so that each individual group could rename it to whatever title was most appropriate to their needs on that particular occasion?
Each group could then internally define & post their own lexicon, as to what each term specifically meant to them.
Yes, the idea to simply have customisable language for "decision" and "proposal" etc is already in the backlog: https://trello.com/c/RHrN06a5
As I said in my statement of position, I think that's the answer. We should let groups decide.
Thank you @alanna ...I went and voted for that Trello card in the backlog ...and would encourage others to go and do the same!
The comment above was intended for another loomio thread, not sure how it got into this one, and loomio won't let me delete it, so my apologies..
Hi!
I'm travelling at present and may be slow to respond to email between October 6th and October 22nd 2014. Please allow a few days for a reply.
Thanks,
Alex.
Voting on proposals is often more of a temerature check rather than a actual decision. It fits Loomio better when that kind of possible sentiment is taken into account. Where a vote on a proposal is indeed intended to be a decision, it can be taken as that without that it needs to be explicitely called that. On the other hand, when it is a temperature check, having the outcome refered to as a desicion will not go down easy, especially with those people that did not have time to participate and vote, but none the less have a opinion they still want to contribute. Consistently using only the term "Proposal" is more adapatble and flexible for the various Loomio use cases.