Loomio Collective Legal Structure
I'm new to Loomio and have great admiration for what you're seeking to achieve with the project and the approach you're taking to get there.
I myself have similar values and hope to employ Loomio in projects to facilitate communication and collaborative decision making.
I'm interested in the structure of the Loomio enterprise. I understand it is some form of cooperative. Does it have a formal incorporated structure? Is it a non profit? Or does it distribute a share of profits between the workers? Is it egaliterian or is there differential pay based on merit?
All these issues I will have to confront when I set up my own enterprise.
Thanks @kurtlaitner ! Loomio is part of the Enspiral ecosystem for sure. We share a small amount of revenue with the Enspiral Foundation (it's small now because Loomio doesn't have much revenue). You can find out more about Enspiral here, and read an in-depth account of how Loomio grew at Enspiral here.
However, the structure of Loomio itself is actually a lot simpler than that! Loomio Cooperative Limited is a separate company that has a voluntary association with Enspiral. Loomio itself is a registered cooperative company. It's collectively owned by its workers.
We've talked a lot about how to reflect our deeply held social values (which are right up front in our company constitution) in our internal structures, and so far we've learned a lot and done our best at that. Of course we've put thought into how to deal with sharing the upside if Loomio takes off - the constitution specifies that surplus will be distributed to cooperative members, invested back in the company, and used to support other values-aligned projects, and discretionary distribution to people who contribute to the project but aren't members. But right now the idea of having such a surplus seems so far away that we're not focusing a lot of attention on it and are instead focused on the work at hand.
Happy to answer more questions.
Alannah and Kurt
Thanks so much for a very speedy and comprehensive. Its resolved many of the questions about Loomio.
How big a role do the directors play in decisionmaking? Are all workers directors or are they primarily apart from the company and play a primarily advisory role? I'm sorry if I'm a little presumpteous in asking such prying question, but there a so few companies with similar business models to emulate and take inspiration from, especially in this country. Its difficult enough incorporating a company when your model is Business As Usual, but when you wish to operate on a values basis where there are few blueprints or templates to follow, it becomes an order of magnifude harder. I appreciate your openness and willingness to be so forthcoming about the enterprise.
Will be that much easy when I'm ready to set up my own enterprise knowing that others have already blazed the trail ahead of me and have learnt the challenges, pitfalls, and rewards of social enterprise. Keep up the good work.
thanks heaps.
btw is it possible to add an edit function in case one makes a mistake and needs to correct it after posting?
@jamesedwards don't apologise, I like these questions! I always ask the same kind of things when I'm trying to understand how an organisation works internally.
The directors have important legal responsibilities as defined by the NZ companies act and our company constitution. It's up to them to make sure the company is solvent and legal, so they need to be the backstop for things like strategy setting, compliance, and risk management. In practice, directors meet once a month, and there is an interplay between them and the membership. Up until last week we had an Establishment Board consisting of 3 independent (non-member) directors and 4 member-directors. We had an AGM last week and are shifting to our Inaugural Board which includes two of the same member-directors, one previously external director who has now become a member, and one new member-director. The two other external directors are moving on, and we're beginning a search for some (probably two) more external directors with expertise relevant to the next phase of Loomio's development as a company.
Day to day, all operational decisions are made by the worker-members. We have a members Loomio group where decisions appropriate to business owners such as hiring, budgeting, and new members are discussed. We have a policy of starting discussions at the widest most open level possible - the only things kept to members only are things that really need to be for ethical reasons (such as discussing someone's employment, privacy concerns, etc). It's our intention as a company to be as transparent as possible. Most of the day to day decision-making thus far has therefore gone on in the Loomio Contributors group, which includes a larger number of people who are regularly involved with working on Loomio.
All of this is kind of in flux right now because we've been through an internal restructuring post-crowdfunding, but the basics of the relationship between members, directors, and the wider Loomio community will not change, as it's defined clearly in our constitution. We're also holding very strongly to our values as a social enterprise, and we critically question any company structure decision in that light.
Its difficult enough incorporating a company when your model is Business As Usual, but when you wish to operate on a values basis where there are few blueprints or templates to follow, it becomes an order of magnifude harder.
Tell me about it!!!!! We're not only creating a new startup, a new software tool, trying to create a new market and find a revenue stream while sticking to our values strongly, we're also reinventing core business structures as we go. A major goal for us is to open source not only our software, but our processes and internal structures as well, to help others who want to work this way not have to reinvent the wheel. That's been important to us right from the start, but investing in communicating it all is sometimes tough in our ultra-lean state.
@richarddbartlett has been working on a blog post about restructuring a democratic organisation which I hope will be published soon. We also wrote an in-depth post about how being a workers co-op affects our technical dev processes.
hello Alanna,
My apologies for neglecting to respond to your reply. I appreciate the time you committed in engaging with me and the openness of your explanation about the structure of Loomio.
I applaud you guys for blazing a path for the rest of us to follow and for your aspiration to allow others to copy your formula. I wish you guys all the best with your endeavors.
And in all those words i got lost, it sounded like a basic pyramid structure.
From quora, post by Joshua:
Joshua Vial, Founder of Enspiral
Votes by Seb Paquet, Alex Korban, Andre Teow, Jon Lemmon, and 3 more.
Enspiral is a network of companies and individuals so there are a few layers to our structure.
At a social level individuals relate to enspiral through three categories of engagement - members, contributors and friends which we often draw as concentric circles with members at the centre. This was inspired by early conversations with the BetterMeans crew and has worked quite well, though we would love to find better names.
Members are like citizens in the collective, there is one vote per person and they are the ultimate locus of power in the group. We currently have about 30 members.
Contributors are people who are active in the community and participate in our internal gift economy. They are people we know and trust and are happy to represent Enspiral professionally. We currently have about 20 contributors.
Friends are people we know and like who are plugged into our information streams (yammer and loomio) - they can earn money through the collective and participate in our decision making. We currently have about 70 friends.
So that's the social structure which we use to organise the community. We've also done a fair bit of work on our legal structure.
There are generally 3 types of companies in the network - we don't have good labels for them but something like 100% social, partially social and private will do for now.
100% social are companies where 100% of the surplus goes to the social and environmental mission of the company. They do not pay dividends and individuals can only earn 'active income' for work done. Most core enspiral companies with Enspiral in the name have this sort of structure.
Partially social are companies where a % of the surplus is allocated to the social mission. This is sometimes expressed as a dividend cap or by allocating a significant amount of equity to a charitable entity.
Private companies use a traditional equity structure but still have a strong social or environmental mission as a significant part of their business.
We see these legal structures as equal though they have quite different characteristics (e.g. ability to raise investment) and its about choosing the right tool for the job. The legal mechanism we use for most of them is a New Zealand Limited Liability Company with custom clauses in the constitution and share holders agreements.
The Enspiral Foundation Limited is the root node in the network which owns the core IP of the collective. When a company joins the network it is this entity they have a relationship with (usually a revenue share or equity) and we are currently in the process of issuing one share to each of the members. This company is the campfire we sit around to make decisions about the whole network.
Simon Tegg has been playing with some data visualisations of the network which may prove useful - blue dots are people and it is a chronological history of our evolution.
http://simontegg.info/EnspiralViz2
http://simontegg.info/EnspiralViz
Hope this helps, happy to answer any other questions people have.