Loomio

What research has been done? on the use of Loomio

Deleted account PublicSeen by 46

I'm just wondering what research has been done on how Loomio groups are being used.

What has been learnt?

What have the keys to success? and how is success being measured?

What percentage of them take off, keep active, and for those that don't stay active or don't take off why don't they?

Have the groups/users been asked for feedback on what features they would like to see?

Does it actually help people/groups make collaborative decisions? How has this been measured?...I'm presuming it does, however it might not in reality.

The more that we understand about what is happening with Loomio the more it can be developed acording to user experiences/needs/requirements.

Matthew Bartlett

hi @neilmorris — some of this kind of stuff has been explored in the metrics group

Richard D. Bartlett

@hannahsalmon, @chelsearobinson and @sophiejerram worked on a user research project not long ago, they may have some interesting data points for you Neil :)

vivien maidaborn

@neilmorris we are at the beginning stages of commercialising so research is a bit beyond us right now. We have done huge amounts of validation, do abit, test a bit, do a bit more as could be expected in an agile development.
There are very different use cases for Loomio but they split into three main areas:

  1. an organisation talking to its external constituency. e.g Wgtn City Council talking to the public or the public talking to it

  2. Teams within an organisation organising their work on Loomio and /or talking to other parts of the organisation in new ways

  3. People organising through networks social/political/environmental actions

We have learnt for a group to be successful there are about 4 things that need to be in place

  • An urgent need to talk, share information and make decisions
  • A Loomio expert user /champion who can create energy and excitement about using it and encourage others to give it a try
  • A commitment in the group to move from the old way of discussion/decision making and the new way
  • A clear understanding of what the problem is they are trying to solve and how this will benefit group members -e.g. reduce travel time, overcome time zone differences, make it possible for more people to participate, have more collaboration in a dispersed team, move decisions off email, have a more secure discussion
  • A culture where some if not many people are already comfortable on line

We have data on percentages etc, not at my finger tips at the moment, but we are building priorities for features based on what we learn from this data, this is often why we prioritise one thing over another because it will solve the engagement issue...

Yes users are encouraged to let us know what they want to see, and do so often

Definitely Loomio helps groups make collaborative decisions. Right from the beginning our user testing has given us great feedback about the ability of the tool to deliver collaborative discussion and decision making. The challenges are much more peripheral, engagement, cultural shift, habit change.

The questions you are asking are exactly the questions we ask and the data we collect all the time. Like everything it is iterative, as we can we do more.
I am interested in you might use or be guided by these responses to your questions - is it helpful knowing this stuff for you?

Nicolas Wormser

@vivienmaidabornloo It would be very helpful to have a document titled "What we've learnt" or something, that coop members would iteratively edit as we learn from our experiences / research.

The sort of things you've written here, but in a more durable format.

Deleted account

@vivienmaidabornloo Thanks for such a comprehensive response.

For me it is useful knowing the information in terms of developing ideas of how the groups I am involved with can use Loomio successfully, but also in terms of how I can sell the concept to others.

It is also useful for me to know in terms of my contributions to the Loomio community here. As I said in the discussion context "The more that we understand about what is happening with Loomio the more it can be developed according to user experiences/needs/requirements."

Just the feel of the product to me shows that it's development has been driven by a lot of user feedback. It.

I think another thing we need to be mindful of is that people will come up with their own uses for it, which may be quite different from what we (community members here) perceive it's uses to be.

I'm excited by it's potential for creating change. I think it will be a key factor in bringing about a cultural shift around how and where we make a lot of collective decisions. I thinking there is a PhD waiting to be done tracking the changes.

I'm off to explore the metrics group!

P.S. thanks @richarddbartlett and @matthewbartlett for the information.

Katherine Despot

I’m doing some research about loomio but I’m trying to understand how/where it fits in the broader democratic deliberation spectrum and the use of loomio as a tool for environmental decision-making. I’ll share the dissertation with loomio once I finish it

Deleted account

@katherinedespot that would be fantastic. Thanks!

Charlie DeTar

Tangential, but related: I'm writing a dissertation about https://intertwinkles.org, which shares a lot of ethos with loomio (but a rather different approach). I'll be defending the dissertation at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology August 8, and will have the full written document done within a couple of weeks after that.

If you're interested in a bit of a more theoretical take, as well as tie-ins to the history of Group Decision Support System research, you might find what I'm writing useful. But I don't think anyone's in a better position than loomio right now to talk about the perspective on organizational change and acceptance.

Jon Lemmon

What you're doing is awesome @charliedetar. Would be great to say hello to you when we're in the states! =)

vivien maidaborn

@nicolaswormser I love the idea of an open document everyone can edit and keep adding information to. Will put it on my list.