Loomio

Outcomes and Closure in Loomio discusisons

Robert Guthrie PublicSeen by 78

We've been spending some time thinking about the end part of the life of a Loomio thread.
Currently we have a very minimal feature called “proposal outcomes”. These allow the proposer to specify the outcome of a proposal after the proposal has closed.

We have had some feedback suggesting that people would like to leave a Loomio discussion, and that people would like to be able to close a loomio discussion, to provide that human understanding of closure to the process.

We want to have a discussion with the community to hear what people would like; how you find the proposal outcome feature, and how you want to deal with discussions when they have reached some natural end point.

As a starter we were talking about moving from individual proposal outcomes to a single Loomio discussion conclusion. The ideal system would do a good job of informing the participants of the end of the discussion and the closure statement. The long term result being that a group ends up with a collection of conclusions at the end of their threads, which provide an easy to digest overview for the readers.

So, what do you want in terms of when a discussion ends? What would be useful to your group?

Tathra Street

An outcome is often linked to an action. It would be good to see what the action is and who is going to take it and by when. That might be a bit beyond what Loomio offers, tho I know from facilitating meetings that this piece often gets lost and contributes to the 'nothing ever changes' sentiment.

goob

There are many cases in which a proposal is for a specific item in a wider discussion. Therefore it is not always the case that the closing of a proposal is the end of the discussion - it might move the discussion on to a new stage. There are also votes on proposals which are inconclusive, in which case clearly the discussion is not at a natural end!

I like Tathra's idea of making proposal outcome statements more 'task-focused'. You could perhaps have a field in which names of those who will be responsible for taking the named action can be entered. You could have auto-complete for names of people who are part of that Loomio group, but it would be good to be able to enter other names as well, in case the work will be carried out by a working party and you want to enter that party's name.

It would be useful to have the facility to close discussions, and also for participants in the discussion to be able to 'leave' the discussion (by which I assume you mean they will stop receiving updates.

But please don't link the closure and outcome of an individual proposal - in many cases, it is desirable and necessary to continue the discussion after a proposal has closed - either to refine and move discussion on to the next step, or to work out where to go after a proposal vote has gone an unexpected way and thrown things into confusion.

Richard D. Bartlett

The more I think about this the more convinced I am that you're absolutely right @goob: discussions often need some kind of closure/outcome/action/conclusion/denoument...

Imagine in the future there are various 'plugins' that a Loomio facilitator can bring into the discussion, e.g. polling, temperature check, survey, etc, in addition to the existing proposal. At the end of all of that activity, you'll often want an over-arching conclusion.

I'm just wondering where is the simplest step in that direction.

Currently, when a proposal closes, the author is notified: "your proposal has closed, please specify an outcome", and they can fill in the little 'outcome' field on the proposal. At the moment, that feature has had very little design attention, e.g. once the outcome has been entered, nothing happens! As a result we're currently seeing only about 12% of proposals have outcomes specified.

What if we changed the notification to say: "your proposal has closed, please specify an outcome and we'll notify your group members". Then once the outcome has been entered, an email goes out to all group members (or just all participants?) with a record of the proposal, outcome, and all the positions.

Good place to start?

goob

@richarddbartlett I guess the best place to start would be to think about what would most encourage people to complete this step.

At the moment, it's very limited. It's been a while since I've used it, but from memory I think it simply provides a text field with an allowance of a couple of hundred characters.

I suspect that if it was more focused and more flexible, it would encourage people to fill it out, because there would be more point in filling it out.

I would suggest splitting it up into several fields, which will (a) allow a bit more detail to be given (more characters allowed in total) and help it to be more focused on outcomes and future work, as Tathra proposed above.

Perhaps:

  • Decision/outcome:
  • What needs to happen next:
  • Who will work on this: (can use mentions and auto-fill for people who are members of the relevant Loomio group, but need to be able to write other people's names in here as well)
  • When this work should be completed by:
  • Any other decisions needing to be taken at this point?

Most of these fields should be optional, e.g. if the vote is inconclusive the outcome will probably be 'need to discuss further and take another vote', so most fields can't be filled in.

Prob best to discuss this with your Loomio team to find what's going to work best, but those are my initial thoughts - make the outcomes tool a more useful tool by making it both more focused on next steps and more flexible, and people may use it more.

It may be that many people don't really know how to use it, or that it exists at all. It's been quite a while since I've received one of the emails sent to the person who opened a proposal once the vote closes, but I seem to remember it isn't particularly clear about what one needs to do. It might be worth looking at the wording of that email, to see if it can be made clear for even the most dunderheaded user (or, more realistically, people who don't use Loomio that often and so don't retain the fine details of how it works in their minds, and don't read emails in detail when they receive them. One thing you could consider is having the various fields in the email body, so the person who receives the email can fill them out there and then and reply to the email, and the text will be taken from the email and entered into the fields by the Loomio software. I don't know whether that would be too complex and/or insecure, but it might be worth considering.

You suggest notifying everyone when this step is taken. I had a feeling that everyone who had voted was notified already. But if not, it might be a good idea, probably to notify each person who is a member of that particular sub-group. And telling the person who opened the proposal that everyone will be notified when they fill out the outcomes form will probably encourage them to do so, I think.

Good luck.

Richard D. Bartlett

Thanks @goob for the thoughtful reply. Tagging specific people onto outcomes is a very interesting idea.

Yep, at the moment nobody is notified of a proposal outcome, which seems like an obvious design flaw. I'm sure outcomes will get more use if we raise their visibility like this.

Alanna Irving

@hannahsalmon would be great to have your new outcomes email design posted here for discussion fodder

Matthew Bartlett

Just being able to at-mention people in outcomes would be quite cool

Deleted account

Just a first attempt but sure thing

PauKokura

I'm not sure i've understood all. Keep english simple please ; )

It can be useful to ask (who, the author of the last proposal?) for an outcome and all the group to recieve it. Not just "participants/voters"! everybody needs to know, I think included those that actively silenced the discussion comment-by-comment, but maybe they want to know the final result. If not, they just have to the group.)

In n-1.cc no one is asked to write anything after the decision gets to the final date, it's assumed that the accepted proposal self-explains what is needed to do next, but the author (or any group moderator i dont remember) can change the "state" of the decision (new, draft, accepted, discarded, posposed). They are attached to virtual assemblies (temporarly) and to a list of decisions (all-time decisions, can be filtered by "state") Its a really complex system and has some bugs, but some ideas can be rescued.

It would be nice to change the state of the decision and a thread. To keep loomio simple, I would ask something like:
Mark the decision as [accepted] [discarded]
... and in the options to edit the discussion
[close] the entire discusion.

In the last graph it says "closed" until the state is changed to "accepted" or "discarded" so that any visitor can see if the final result of the voting and participation are considered legitimate enough to put the decision in practice. Questionmark icon in "previous decisions" can also be changed to reflect the state of decisions and can be filtered.

The other thing, to close the discussion, can also solve the "duplicated threads" (https://www.loomio.org/discussions/9280#comment-62378) , as coordiinator can link the other in his las comment and close.

Deleted account

An option to archive a discussion in a separate area would be useful, along with an option for group members being able to move it back into the main group area if someone wants to resurrect the discussion.

Stewart Harrison

For continuity of proposal to action it would be nice to see athird section of discussion in the group summary page; i.e. Open Discussions; Open Proposals; Proposals being actioned. An archive of completed and actioned proposals would be useful (apologies if this is available - I'm quite new to Loomio and am not aware of all of the features), but would not need to be on the group page.

[I like the way that Loomio does away with the need for meeting minutes :o)

Alanna Irving

I like that idea @stewart - I'm interested in a related feature where you could set a "follow up date" when an outcome is set, which would then send you a reminder to report back to the group about how the outcome was actioned.