Loomio

How to configure parent groups and subgroups

Sean Farmelo PublicSeen by 182

A use case that brings up an important question: how can you configure Loomio groups that are all under one umbrella but each have different needs for membership, privacy, and permissions? The answer is subgroups!

Hi all,

we just had our inaugural Students for Co-operation conference as an incorporated co-operative this past weekend in Edinburgh! It went really well and one of the things decided was that there would be online forums for the autonomous liberation caucuses.

The liberation caucus subgroups need a number of qualities

-) we want to keep them as subgroups so that people who identify as multiple caucuses don't get confused by being in loads of separate loomio groups for the same organisation.

-) admins should not be able to access them if they don't self identify as coming from a liberation caucus. So I don't identify into any caucus but It is useful for me to be an admin of the overarching loomio group becuase I do a lot of the admin for SfC, but it would compromise the automony of the caucuses if I could see it. Likewise it is not a solution to make one person from each of the four caucuses an admin because then they would be able to see the other caucuses which they might be part of. So In short as an admin I want to be able to forfeit my admin rights for particular subgroups

-) neither admins or other members of the overall loomio group should be able to see who is in the caucus sub group - people should be free to self identify into a group without other people knowing or being able to see.

Benjamin Knight

@seanfarmelo , your work with Students for Cooperation looks totally amazing, and I'm stoked that we can support it with Loomio! I just read your blog post on thenews.coop (everyone in here should read this! http://www.thenews.coop/47348/news/general/blog-students-co-operation-sean-farmelo/) and it made me very happy.

I know other people (e.g. @hannahsalmon ) have their heads around the group permissions, so will leave it to them to answer your questions, but I just wanted to say that SfC is exactly the reason we started this project in the first place :)

Oh and! I also wanted to say that you should talk to @derekrazo about Loomio and student co-ops! He was involved with a big student co-op at Berkeley, and is totally plugged in to the co-op scene in the Bay Area (as well as being a Loomio super-star).

Wael Al-Saad

The first question came in my mind weather loomio has policy regarding dark or extreme groups or groups with terrorist intention or it concern about content at all.

Benjamin Knight

@waelalsaad , we don't have a formalized policy on this, but will need to develop one as we grow.

We have a firm privacy policy that Loomio staff do not view private content, so we only know what goes on in public groups.

You can see more detail on our privacy policy here: https://www.loomio.org/privacy

Richard D. Bartlett

Sounds like y'all are doing great work @seanfarmelo :)

I'm glad to say you can configure your Loomio groups to achieve this. First make sure the parent group permissions are set to allow members to create subgroups. Then, when someone creates a new subgroup, they can set the privacy to "Members only", which will make it invisible to anyone who has not been explicitly invited to it.

Let me know if I can clarify anything :)

Alanna Irving

@seanfarmelo great question! I just updated the discussion title and context so your use case can be an example for others who are likely to have similar situations.

Mike Shaw

Thanks for clarifying this. As well as Students for Cooperation, we'll also make use of this at Edinburgh Student Housing Co-op and a number of other student co-ops. :)

Sean Farmelo

Cheers for that Richard! Think that should do the trick in general.

Your solution does still leave one problem though, people are unable to self identify into caucuses - they would have to be invited by the sub groups admins. Is there any way to make the group viewable but all of the info relating to it private including it's membership? Also some people from caucuses might not think of joining the group if they didn't know not it existed.
I guess one solution is to have an email address for each caucuses on the main group where people can send their emails so that they can be invited to the group by the admin but that sounds like an unnecessarily bureaucratic solution.

Alanna Irving

@seanfarmelo yes you can set up groups so they are just like that... private except for the group title and description and a "request to join" button. You can also set privacy on discussions on a per-discussion basis in such a group, so you can have some public content visible as well.

Richard D. Bartlett

@seanfarmelo here's how I would recommend you configure your privacy settings:

  • "Who can find this group?" is "unlisted to the public, but visible to parent group members"
  • "How do people join?" is "By request - anyone can request to join"
  • "Who can see discussions?" is "only members can see discussions."

Note, the subgroup name and description will be visible to parent members, but all the discussions and the members list will be hidden [as of 2 minutes ago since I just deployed that feature that hides the members list :P ]

Sean Farmelo

brilliant! thanks for making the change :) think that is exactly what we are looking for

Wael Al-Saad

This change supports both individuality, privacy and transperancy

Sean Farmelo

@richarddbartlett while you are at it could you change one more thing?

when I click on groups I get a dropdown list with all the groups I'm in. I've noticed you've added a search function which helps immensely because I am in too many groups - but it would be extra good if you didn't have to click in the box to start typing - you just clicked on groups and then typed the name of the group would save loads of time.

Richard D. Bartlett

Hey @seanfarmelo, that whole groups/search functionality is about to be overhauled. What do you think of this new design?

Clicking the search icon opens the search dialog, including a list of all your groups:

Start typing in the search input and your groups list is filtered, and threads that match your search terms are returned:

Alanna Irving

Guys, if you want to discuss the new search functionality, it would be much better to start another thread about that :) @richarddbartlett