How Does Facilitation Work in a Loomio Group?
Who is responsible for facilitation in a Loomio group/ discussion? This is a question that seems to lurk in the background of quite a few discussions here.
In face-to-face meetings of groups which make decisions by consensus, the first thing we usually do is decide who is facilitating (the only exception being small, intimate, affinity groups). If the facilitator finds themselves wanting to speak a lot about a certain topic, or advocate strongly for a position, they or the group can decide to shift the facilitation role to someone who is more neutral on that topic. If the facilitator has to leave the meeting for some reason, the group can choose another facilitator.
Without an explicit agreement about who is facilitating, a number of problems can emerge:
* nobody is facilitating, and discussion wanders around without resolution, or even into polarization and flaming
* everybody (or multiple people) trying to facilitate at once, creating conflict and frustration
* tyranny of structurelessness - somebody is facilitating unofficially, so they are not accountable or able to be replaced. A new member has to come to quite a few meetings before they figure out who facilitates them.
In Loomio, the basic unit of decision-making is not the meeting, but the discussion thread. I'd like to suggest that:
- when a new discussion is created, there is a mechanism for agreeing on who is going to facilitate that discussion.
- The name/ handle of the user facilitating could be displayed prominently at the top of the discussion page, and there is a mechanism for changing facilitator if appropriate
- The facilitator is responsible for mood-minding and moderating tone, keeping discussion friendly and constructive
- They are also responsible for keeping the discussion moving towards consensus and if needed, action. For example, checking with the person who initiated the thread that their reasons for starting it is being addressed by the discussion, and making sure tangents which go too far off-topic are spun off into their own threads.
I think Loomio needs to encourage collective facilitation, not centralize it into one person. It's not about the person, but the role a given act of facilitation plays. For example, in the same discussion, sometimes I'm moderating the mood, mediating conflicts between others, providing background info, clarifying or amplifying other's statements, restating what I'm hearing emerge, etc etc etc AND I am also participating as myself, sharing my opinions, thoughts, and feelings. The whole group needs to be responsible for collective outcomes, not just one person.
Good question @mixirving :) It certainly shouldn't be me, as I'm coming in with an axe to grind.
I hear what @alanna is saying about collective facilitation, and I'm certainly not advocating that each Loomio group elect a Dictator-For-Life! My proposal would involve having a different group member facilitating each discussion, and even taking turns facilitating a long and tricky discussion (maybe even bringing in a non-member mediator if needed). It's still collective facilitation, but it makes sure someone reasonably neutral is acting as the steward of a particular discussion, and makes it clear who that is at a given time.
As I said, free-for-all discussion can work just fine in a small, intimate, affinity group, where either everyone knows each other well, or everyone is experienced with consensus process (or both). The sort of group that really needs Loomio is one that is large, composed mainly of acquaintances or strangers, composed mainly of people unfamiliar with consensus, or all of the above. From what I've observed so far, there is sometimes a need in such groups for more active and disinterested facilitation.
This is a great example of a problem that doesn't require software to solve. If your discussion needs a facilitator, just put their name in the context box. Viola.
Yeah I am a big believer in acts of facilitation, individuals deciding they would like to offer facilitation in a discussion or part of it, or someone in the group noticing facilitation would be good and inviting it. All these mean everyone is staying conscious and facial action is just another role people take on from time to time.
While I think a lot of what @strypey is suggesting can be managed without a software solution, I do like thinking about ways in which loomio might encourage such 'acts of facilitation'. I think for some groups such as ours, because of our strength in facilitation, it can be easy to forget that it is a skill that needs to be practiced. I think it's also easy to forget that in some circumstances, a conversation will work much better when strongly held.
To that end, it might be nice to be able to enable a feature like the one @strypey is suggesting from time to time.
it could be a sub-feature of one of my favourite features-to-be : who's-in-the-room
with an option for hats.
[facillitator]
I'm noticing this exploration has reached a point where someone could break out and run a test, then report back to the group
this is an example of how existing features might be used to test the viability of such a feature
Hats!
Hi,
I am new to Loomio and this is my first time joining a discussion thread. I am so happy to see this conversation happening!
I'm a full-time freelance group facilitator & trainer (www.treegroup.info if you are curious), so now you'll know my bias up front. I had a housemate in a long-time collective who used to say, "If it's everyone's responsibility, then it's no one's responsibility," and his words ring true to my experience. Wishing that everyone would act facilitatively doesn't make it so, and the point of having a facilitator is not to prevent others from being helpful, it's to prevent the bad effects of a vacuum in this area.
I notice in the online groups i participate in how much difference it makes when they are actively nurtured and moderated by someone. In an established f2f group, if the tone turns bad, you might lose 20% of the participants (the more sensitive souls, let's say) and have trouble recruiting anyone new to join. Whereas in an online group if the tone turns bad, you can easily lose upwards of 50% of the participants, and then you no longer have critical mass to do whatever it was you were attempting. Aside from flaminess, i have seen many f2f groups go around and around without results, and when i come in and simply start summarizing what they are saying they are able to move forward to action.
Rather than start over in the new world of online decision-making, i say let's learn from what we already know works well f2f. The software does not need to require a facilitator on every thread, but i really like the idea of allowing it as an option, and then let groups decide whether or not to invoke it. Just like in real life!
Cheers,
--Tree
Nice to see you here @treebressen !
Everyone who sees a need for more explicit facilitation in Loomio, can you think about how it might actually work in practice? First, think what can people do right now, without changing the software, that would help improve this or give people good techniques and tools?
I think the best way we can learn how the software can support good facilitation is to do real life experimentation on Loomio as it is now and see what works.
What are people already doing in Loomio groups that is working in terms of facilitation?
@chelsearobinson @vivienmaidaborn @mjkaplan @carlscrase @silviazuur @richarddbartlett @seantilleycommunit
Kia ora everyone - wonderful to be involved in this rich discussion.
There are a few easy things I tend to encourage about how people facilitate on Loomio, here are a couple, I would love to hear how other's have seen it work well:
- The person who opens the group, also start a "introduce yourselves" discussion and invite key people in first.
- Whomever starts a discussion facilitates it. This one works well as it means the person who is feeling the pain or excitement of the idea or issue take care of it. However, someone with strong opinion may also struggle to be neutral, so there's pros and cons.
- nominate someone in your group to learn all the different functions of the Loomio tool, so they can Facilitate Learning and be the awesome helper who says "Have you noticed how powerful it is to tag someone if they haven't seen the discussion yet?
My one key thought is that if you want deep engagement from a team, then however you would prepare for a meeting, do the same for a Loomio discussion. Invite people, tell them it's happening, present draft ideas early on to get feedback so you don't launch something on a path which people aren't keen on, keep people updated as thigns change etc.
And similarly, if you want mass engagement from the public, in a public discussion, prepare for it as you would prepare for an event. Promote it, get the key participants confirmed, send invitations, share it on social media etc.
@treebressen I agree, use what works F2F, translate it online, and learn from there :)
Just re-reading my contribution, I'd add that my notes are coming especially from a place of "how to get it going from the beginning". And I guess the theme you can notice across the ideas is the theme of making shared norms about how to use Loomio.
I agree with @vivienmaidaborn about "Acts of facilitation". Very much so, and I think this comes later. At first, a little coaching and some simple, volunteered roles are helpful.
@treebressen I posted and deleted a comment here for entirely neurotic reasons! I realised again I have no headspace for internet conversations right now.
With regards and appreciation for your work, John
For a start, a facilitator feature could be as simple as adding a small, user-editable box on the discussion page, with the words "is facilitating this discussion" underneath it, and the default text in the box being "nobody" or "everybody".
@alanna I totally understand your desire to keep the software simple, and minimize the work going into the coders' backlog, and it's true that users can tack functions onto Loomio by group agreement. However, doing so makes the tool less scalable, because it adds admin work to train new group members to use such 'social software' functions correctly, and less helpful, because new users will muddy group process until they master these implicit functions.
Yes, a 'clerk' or 'facilitator' could be identified in the Context Box, in the same way that what Loomio does could be implemented using a web forum and a polling module. I'd rather use Loomio though, because simply by making a number of decision functions explicit, it's visual design does a lot of the training for the users. I think a dedicated 'facilitator' feature would reminds users to identify who is facilitating, or to be aware that nobody/ everybody is.
A more developed version could allow the person facilitating a complex and tense discussion to activate tools such as a talking stick round, or freeze the discussion for a period of days and invite participants to think deeply about their goals and concerns around the topic before returning to discussion.
lots of good things, here. just wanted to quickly chime in...
my experience suggests to me that a good first step is to look at the "facilitator" as a set of discrete tasks that are performed in the course of a decisionmaking process, identify which of those tasks are things that are either handled or obviated by the platform (both as it exists today, and as it theoretically might exist), separating them from facilitation tasks that are still something a person should provide.
see, i agree with most of the sentiments here suggesting that there is still a need for a facilitator of discussions. without someone shouldering the responsibility of trying to keep the discussion moving, the process working, much of the emotive value of a consensus process slips away. to that end, in identifying the "tasks" that are more appropriate for a person (or rotating group of people, or whatever), as opposed to the platform, i think it's important to consider the emotional influence being brought to bear by a facilitator, and identifying how the Loomio can best enable its users acting in a facilitative role to achieve a similar effect.
interesting question. who's facilitating this discussion before i step in? :P