Loomio and the power of including introverts (and other communication styles) in groups
I'm reading Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking and I've been thinking about it in terms of what Loomio can enable in group dynamics.
She also gave a TED talk that's worth watching.
Here's an excerpt that I think really captures it. Have you noticed Loomio empowering the quieter people in your groups to be heard? I certainly have.
Even at Harvard Business School there are signs that something might be wrong with a leadership style that values quick and assertive answers over quiet, slow decision-making.
Every autumn the incoming class participates in an elaborate role-playing game called the Subarctic Survival Situation.
“It is approximately 2:30 p.m., October 5,” the students are told, “and you have just crash-landed in a float plane on the east shore of Laura Lake in the subarctic region of the northern Quebec-Newfoundland border.”
The students are divided into small groups and asked to imagine that their group has salvaged fifteen items from the plane—a compass, sleeping bag, axe, and so on. Then they’re told to rank them in order of importance to the group’s survival. First the students rank the items individually; then they do so as a team. Next they score those rankings against an expert’s to see how well they did. Finally they watch a videotape of their team’s discussions to see what went right—or wrong.
The point of the exercise is to teach group synergy. Successful synergy means a higher ranking for the team than for its individual members. The group fails when any of its members has a better ranking than the overall team. And failure is exactly what can happen when students prize assertiveness too highly.
One of Don’s classmates was in a group lucky to include a young man with extensive experience in the northern backwoods. He had a lot of good ideas about how to rank the fifteen salvaged items. But his group didn’t listen, because he expressed his views too quietly.
“Our action plan hinged on what the most vocal people suggested,” recalls the classmate. “When the less vocal people put out ideas, those ideas were discarded. The ideas that were rejected would have kept us alive and out of trouble, but they were dismissed because of the conviction with which the more vocal people suggested their ideas. Afterwards they played us back the videotape, and it was so embarrassing.”
The Subarctic Survival Situation may sound like a harmless game played inside the ivory tower, but if you think of meetings you’ve attended, you can probably recall a time—plenty of times—when the opinion of the most dynamic or talkative person prevailed to the detriment of all.
@alannakrause quite interesting topic... a practical approach to this in Loomio (those who want to give a valuable opinion and are too shy to do it) is to allow anonymous comments but that will imply to allow "externals" to the group to do it or allow members to become anonymous, both things can work if.... 1) you can rate a comment as "big troll doing their thing" 2) yo do not allow it to count on the voting (as someone can be voting twice, own name and anonymously).
Coincidentally, I started a discussion in my group yesterday in which I referred to a similar issue quoting an example from Kelly B. Howe's thesis: Adapting Boal's Legislative Theatre. (http://gradworks.umi.com/34/17/3417498.html)
Commenting on the process leading to one of the Legislative Theatre performances she argued that a “democratic process” should not be defined by a lack of structure or it can actually mean less access for those who are already marginalised because of lack of charisma, knowledge , status etc. Our discursive baggage and cultural power cannot be fully checked at the door, and the same people will often emerge in a workshop as do outside it. Hence it is important for our group to reflect, before, during and after the event, on all the various layers of identities brought to the mix and about ways to counter some potential barriers.
Although this point concerns specifically workshops, I believe like you that it has some resonance with what happens in virtual platforms like Loomio.
I think that trying to find rules/mechanisms to create a space conducive to respect is very important but a lot of it is also in the explicit on-going questioning of these issues early on and openly within the group.
Ooh yeah, good blog topic. From my introverted perspective... one of the best things about Loomio, is it gives me time to think. Hearing, thinking and responding in a meeting, on the spot, doesn't work so well for my poor brain!
Yes! Its great @alannakrause. I think we really want the blog to showcase how useful and important Loomio can be, so I think its a great idea. And the title is enticing!
Thinking about this, I suspect that what drew me to consensus-based groups all those years ago is precisely the way good facilitators make space for introverts to participate without having to compete to be heard. Loomio builds on this, as others have said, by providing more opportunity for reflection, and not requiring a loud voice to get heard.
I grew up in a big family, full of big personalities, all competing to be heard. This, combined with doing a lot of drama and other performance-based activity, allowed me to develop a loud, confident, outgoing persona which I can hide behind when I need to. However, I'm really quite introverted. My favourite place through most of my school years was the library, or anywhere I could bury myself in a book, and these days, I spend most of my time alone reading books or on the internet.
@annaguenther @emmahosking do you reckon this topic might be good for the blog?