Separate into two options to select "Invite and approve new members"

Edit group settings - Permissions

I hope I don't seem off-topic by bringing up the way invitations work, because that directly influences my ideas regarding who gets to make invitations.

The invitation tool is ideally IMO nothing other than a convenience feature, which shouldn't allow people to add others to groups without their knowledge or informed consent. We discussed that a little in this thread of yours @carlosgallogaravan a couple of months ago.

Alanna created a Trello roadmap card on that subject before. I missed it before, and I just upvoted that card now! I hope others may consider upvoting that Trello card.

Regarding your suggestions in this new topic, Carlos: I think it could be a nice added option, but I don't really think it would create much added benefit. If we separate the ability to invite from the ability to approve members, then we create something equivalent to the existing case when a person directly requests to join a group. (They must be approved by someone else.) We can already create 'indirect invitations' for publicly viewable groups (and subgroup) by sharing a group's URL with someone and asking them to please check the group out. We can suggest that they click the "Ask to join group" button.

I do realize that things are more complicated with invisible groups and subgroups. That's where the suggested feature would be most helpful, but it seems like a very limited benefit. (You can always ask a group coordinator to invite someone whom you wish you could personally invite.) I'm not sure that the benefit would justify the added complexity in the Group Options, even if it were easy to code. I'm certainly not opposed to it, however. :)

@gregorycassel
I'll explain better, to eliminate confusions

In the discussion, Invite Existing users to join group, instead of automatically making them a member, was analyzed, the freedom to accept an invitation:

a) Exist Loomio user account, adhered to the group without waiting for user acceptance

b) There is no user account Loomio, awaiting the decision of the invited person. New user account in Loomio and acceptance of the invitation to join the group

That is the proposal of Alanna in Trello with the title "User must accept invitation to be added to a group, even if They are Loomio Already a user"

About this discussion:

Currently, if I am the coordinator of a group and I do not want any member approves the incorporation of other people in the group, it is only possible unchecking the option "invite and approve new members"

Therefore, members of the group can not invite. Only way, request the coordinator that you send the invitation.

My proposal
Group members can invite any person
The coordinator approves the incorporation of people in the group

The sole purpose of my proposal is to enable all members of the group, the possibility: always invite.

I hope to have improved the explanation

Oh! I get it. You would like to be able to approve invitations!

That's super interesting.

So before the invitation is sent, the coordinator must approve the outgoing invitation.

Read again the description

I made some adjustments taking into account the comments of @robertguthrie