Loomio

Replace admin "user tags" with sub-groups

Jon Lemmon PublicSeen by 37

Replace admin "user tags" with sub-groups

proposal by Jon Lemmon Closed Fri 27 Apr 2012 4:00AM

We've been debating between sub-groups and user-tags (settable by the admin) for a while.

After weeks of thinking about this (and also implementing a basic tagging system), I think that we should abandon user-tags for now and stick with sub-groups. There are a few reasons for this:

  1. Sub-groups have more immediate functionality (you can instantly create motions for specific sub-groups), whereas with tags we would have to code that functionality in and there doesn't seem to be a very elegant way to do that.

  2. Sub-groups is more instantly intuitive to the end-user (e.g. "I know what a group is, so I understand what a sub-group is")

  3. Sub-groups have been implemented and are functional, whereas the current implementation of tags has a few strange bugs in it. (This is really just a side-point)

I don't think we should keep both for now, because otherwise it will be unclear which feature to use (e.g. "well, I could make a 'developers' tag... or I could create a sub-group"). I think everyone would agree that we want to keep Loomio's feature-set minimal wherever possible.

All of this said, what I'm suggesting above has a few issues:

  1. Sometimes you may want to label a member, but not create sub-group functionality (e.g. we might not want "friends" of enspiral to have their own discussion board)

  2. There's a sort of unwanted "duplication" that can occur. For instance, if Bucky Box has their own group, and then Enspiral creates a "Bucky Box" sub-group and adds all of the Bucky Box members to it, there now exists two Bucky Box groups (bad!).

However, I think that the two issues above are solvable. And I think that one of the solutions will add an entire extra level of awesomeness to Loomio. I'm going to outline the solutions here, however, I'll mention that these solutions are NOT part of this proposal. I'm simply outlining potential solutions to the above issues to provide some context as to why I think sub-groups will be an adequate solution for us in the short-to-medium term.

  1. When creating a sub-group you are prompted with the dialog "Would you like to enable discussion for this sub-group? (Yes/No)"

This means that we can add arbitrary sub-groups which will effectively act like tags. This may or may not be a good idea. We'll see. I'm just putting it out there as a potential fix to one of the issues.

  1. External Groups

I see this as a potential game-changer for us, although I don't expect us to implement it immediately. The basic idea is that groups can be members of other groups (but in a non-parent sort-of-way).

For instance, Bucky Box and Rabid Tech could both be members of Enspiral. And that membership can have parameters. Maybe by default all Rabid Tech members can view Enspiral motions but cannot vote on them. Several of the Rabid Tech members might also be members of Enspiral, but they don't have to be. This solves the group duplication problem, since Enspiral won't need to create a separate Bucky Box sub-group just to label it's members).

Another aspect of external groups is that they will potentially be able to form from sub-groups. For instance, say Loomio starts out as a sub-group of Enspiral and then grows very large and becomes its own separate entity (but still is associated with Enspiral). At that point, Loomio can break away from being a sub-group of Enspiral and become our own parent group, and then just join Enspiral as a member. The result is that all groups become more organic and flexible to change larger changes over time.

I've created a very simple mockup showing what the Group page might vaguely look like if it had external groups: https://gomockingbird.com/mockingbird/#htca3te/NElxme

In short, I think sub-groups are the way to go for now. They have a lot of potential for the future and they also provide useful functionality that we can implement immediately.

Results

Jon Lemmon
Agree

I wouldn't have written that much text if I didn't think it was a good idea (sorry for the novel!)

Joshua Vial
Agree

excellent idea - less is more

guillaume
Agree

I've pledged on this since the beginning !