Loomio
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:08PM

Participatory budgeting process

D Darren Public Seen by 217

We recently had a poll on preferences for spending a part of our funds which led to discussions around how we should go about contributing to some of the software projects Social Coop uses and the suggestion ,which had a fair amount of support, that we should use a participatory budgeting process.

Following on from that I'm bringing forward a proposal to organise that process

AU

Ana Ulin
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

Thanks for moving this forwad, @Darren.

I agree with the comments from others about having our strategy discussion first, and on moving towards a more holistic approach towards use of our funds, but I think those things can be addressed in parallel with a first experiment in allocating funds via co-budgeting.

JO

Jere Odell
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

Agree with "participatory," but flexible on the amounts and purpose.

MC

Matthew Cropp
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

This feels like a reasonably scaled pilot project to me. I definitely feel like we should be both contributing resources to the software we rely on, along with using our little bit of clout to incentivize development that serves the unique needs of co-op/democratic software. I'll be interested to see how the first process goes!

NS

Nick Sellen
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

Yup, seems a good thing to try out! Thanks for proposing it :)

D

djm
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

It makes sense to me that we would help support development of software we use as an instance. The participatory budgeting aspect allows for member input on specifics.

J

Joshua
Agree
Wed 21 Dec 2022 5:52AM

Sounds like a great idea! As a new member, I'm not yet clear on the current budgeting process, but I like the idea of using a dot vote to proportionally distribute discretionary funds.

ZS

Zee Spencer
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

While 5% of cash-on-hand seems like a large chunk, and it's also only roughly ~15 members annual dues. I think it's safe-to-try and I would enjoy seeing the participatory budgeting play out.

That said, I could see a smaller amount still being significant enough for us to learn real lessons from; and a ~200 would bring it to < 1.5% of our cash-on-hand.

BJ

Blake Johnson
Agree
Thu 22 Dec 2022 12:28AM

This is a worthwhile experiment, and could be a great ongoing process. Open source maintainership can often be thankless, and efforts like this could enable a move towards professional maintainership outside of corporate contract sponsorship.

N

Neil - @[email protected]
Agree
Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:20PM

Around 5% seems fair for kicking up to projects that we depend on, though agree that revisiting in 6 months is a good plan. I like the idea of collaboratively deciding upon projects to support first, and then disbursing based on dot votes. I think participatory budgeting is exactly the kind of democratic process that social.coop should be experimenting with and look forward to it happening!

AW

Aaron Wolf Sat 17 Dec 2022 11:55PM

Meta: is there a method in Loomio for a sort of gut-check, room-check sort of "how are we feeling about this?" poll prior to formal proposals?

Load More