Loomio

Citizens Juries

Craig Lambie PublicSeen by 38

The New Democracy Foundation has some ideas on making a Sortition based Senate/ Legislature.
I want to create an organisation that runs Citizens Juries for a political movement in Victoria.
What do you think the rules should be?
Ref:
http://newdemocracy.com.au/alternatives/structural/item/100-the-citizen-legislature-sortition
http://newdemocracy.com.au/alternatives/structural/item/98-a-citizens-senate

[Edit]
I have started to document this idea here

Craig Lambie

Questions:
How many people should be on the jury?

Craig Lambie

Questions:
How selectively representative should it be?
(eg. what demographic and geographic factors should be taken into account to be representative? Socio-economic status, age, income, education)
eg.
Across the 8 upper house zones of Victoria there should be 20% from each socio economic grouping, with a 50/50 split of male/female.

Craig Lambie

Questions:
How should a juror be able to get out of jury duty?
What should cause a presenter/ side to call a juror out?

John Graham

Wow I just want to 'like' the heck out of newdemocracy.com.au and this discussion starter.

PauKokura

Hey, here we have a similar iniciatiive (and others, but this one is really similar). Its called "ParlaMent ciutadà" ("citizen parliament", where "ment" is also "mind").
Hope you can translate it from catalan and understand something: http://parlamentciutada.cat/

Its not based on a lottery, but on social movements joint in a descentralised way, "watching close" the political and economic powers. You can enter this "parliament" as an individual or a collective and work some topics. The motivation is not to legislate itself but to propose concrete changes and require the "real" parlament to ask all citizens in a via of referendum or other legislative grassroots iniciatives.

I'm not part of it, but seems interesting.

PauKokura

The quid is all this is that one social movement (f.ex. ecological) assume other fights (f.ex. feminist) etc etc, coordinated to struggle real changes. This is an idea its getting very important here, called sometimes "popular unity" in diferent associations, collectives and citizen-based candidatures in elections.

Craig Lambie

@zombilechuck that is is an interesting idea, I had a similar type idea in the past, but after reading and speaking to newDemocracy Foundation I was convinced the best way forward was via sortition, ie. a full cross section of society.... and then have interest groups present their case.
Then each interest group gets their point of view across to the decision maker, who will make the best decision for society, not based on the interest group.