Government E-Democracy
I completely agree. It's not about telling them: "This is Loomio, use it!"
It's more about getting the conversation started and saying:
"Hey guys, we've been thinking about this full-time for the past year and we've already built a tool (which is continually improving) specifically to address this need. Before you make a massive 5 year-long plan to invest millions of dollars into building a large clunky piece of software, you should have a look at what we're doing."
I think that we want to get this conversation started EARLY (as in now), because I think that once the government commits to investing in something they will be very hesitant to switch to something else.
And I really I think that the panel which is in charge of this e-democracy investigation would take comfort in knowing that there is a Wellington-based software development startup which is working to address this exact problem at a global scale.
I think not getting the conversation started early on this could result in a really big missed opportunity for both Loomio and the New Zealand government.
Seems likely Labour MP Clare Curran would be interested in talking with us, if that were felt to be of use...?
Good point Matthew. I think we should arrange a conversation with her if possible.
I think there are two contexts here. The immediate NZ gov interest in tools for engagement, and the global shift toward more user-centered govt of which the NZ interest is one piece. I agree with JL that it is about a conversation in terms of NZ. You're really building for a different use case than citizen/resident participation, but their are similarities and Loomio could potentially create good products for that niche. I have a lot of background with this and would be happy to talk it through with folks wrt what are the products and strategies that are being offered and which are getting results. Not something that I can lay out in a Loomio. I suggest you start thinking of citizen participation as a large sector you want to explore and spend some time understanding the different contexts that takes place in and how Loomio can add value in those contexts (either in current or modified form). There is so much variation and contingent constraints/hurdles that you can't come at everything with a single approach; and you'll be much more persuasive if you can help govts think through the issues and options.
Front page of the DomPost today has former PM Geoffrey Palmer talking about restructuring the city councils in the Greater Wellington Region into something like the Auckland 'super city'. The take-away from that article: "You really have to devise a system that allows people at the grassroots to have their say." Loomio anyone?
http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/business/7629256/Capital-risks-becoming-backwater
One does not simply go to "the government" and say "here try Loomio", IMO this stuff works by a combination of sharp and broad focus. Sharp = talking to strategic gatekeepers and broad = developing a broad public 'brand awareness' of the project.
As far as I'm concerned the comms and bizdev teams have this covered for the immediate future I reckon.
On the sharp front we're developing a relationship with both Wellington Regional Council and City Council as early adopters. The Mayor had dinner with Ben and Alanna this week and is advocating Loomio to her councillors. We're having an input into the local governance review panel.
On the broad front the presentations this week at Digital Earth Summit and the NFP CFO conferences are both big wins. We talked to a friend who is a Young Greens member and PA to the co-leader of the Greens Party; she's championing Loomio to the party.
You're going to have to put up with me saying this for the next three weeks, but I don't think anymore works needs to be done on this before October 1 :P
The story stuff covered specifically says the new GOES project is looking for ideas/input:
"The department has invited software companies to provide advice and take part in workshops that will be held next month."
I think refusing an invitation should be an active decision not a passive one and those workshops might provide some really useful insight for us. Unless I've misread this and they've already invited OTHER software companies.
Also... I've noticed we've reached out to the Greens and there's discussion here about talking to a Labour MP. I'd be really interested to see what a National MP thought about Loomio at some point if not just for diversity's sake.
I'm sure the bizdev and comms teams are packed till oct, I just couldn't help but move the conversation, there's heaps of awesome points already.
Thanks for drawing attention to this Paul!
This looks like a really interesting opportunity, but I definitely hear Richard's concerns about diverting our focus. I think it's really a matter of finding out as much as we can with the minimum effort before we commit any substantial time into it.
My worry is that their process will be pretty clunky and time-consuming (I don't much like the idea of spending time putting together budgets and viability reports at this point) - but there's no harm in finding out!
I think it might be telling that they're specifically looking at tools for consulting, rather than actual citizen engagement in decision-making.
I'm happy to take a quick initial look at this next week
I have so many thoughts on this they could fill multiple comment threads here :) Briefly:
1) Yes, get your foot in the door where you can
2) Yes, help people in gov map the problem space, and be realistic about which problems your software can solve, and which ones it can't
3) focus on people in the public service, govt departments etc, not politicians. AFAIK this is how we got CreativeCommons into the NZGOAL strategy, and approved by Cabinet for all non-personal data traditionally under Crown Copyright.
4) Yes, talk to politicians too when they're interested (more feet in doors), and yes, cover all the political parties. The NZ First ICT spokeswoman seems interesting...
5) check out the Open Government Ninjas:
http://groups.open.org.nz/groups/ninja-talk
I did some digging into the government's initiative to explore 'e-democracy'
I spoke to the project manager at DIA yesterday and unfortunately, the system is that companies have to put in a tender to even have the opportunity to be selected to participate in workshops to have a discussion with govt people about what they're doing. Looks like quite a lengthy process that I'm not sure we'd get much out of at this point.
There's been 2 news articles I've seen in the last 2 days about government looking into E-Democracy.
There was a bit of discussion on yammer about this:
https://www.yammer.com/loomio#/Threads/show?threadId=208918270
https://www.yammer.com/loomio#/Threads/show?threadId=209770269
So I wanted to create a space in loomio to really discuss this as I feel like it's saying "GIVE US LOOMIO" and that deserves an active decision/discussion here.
--
To get the ball rolling: I really think this is worth following up. Even if we don't think loomio is ready (message or code wise) for government level participation, getting the feedback as to what is needed is better as early on as possible.