Cycle 3 Altar
A place for offerings that may inform the directon of cycle 3
Wow @Ronen Hirsch , I went through the sequence and I love it. So much WISDOM captured there. I need to "let the generative process work" for a few days before bringing more feedback and sharing reflections regarding the different perspectives you mentioned. It felt much less abstract than the previous one. In my particular case, I see that I could contribute to develop/enrich it in cycle 3, though I have not envisioned yet how that communal work should be done.
I am curious to know in what extent our previous cycles helped to shape it. That could be a nice talk in a future sync gathering.
Thank you @Ronen Hirsch for offering this! I just finished listening through it. I enjoyed the experience and it definitely ignited a desire to come to an agreement around framing our next cycle!
Would you be willing to share the written text as well? If so, I may be interested in trying a "remix" of the score :)
The written text is not a "written text." It is made up of small pieces organized within the collective-one application. I look forward to bringing you all into the collective-one space but that requires some intentional coordination (and it may turn out to be a good place for you to "remix"). Until then there is a read-only public link where you can access "the text":
http://www.collectiveone.org/#/section/ac1342e2-76af-1d0b-8176-b50c3e80002b
and I am attaching a markdown text dump which I am not sure is very useful since it loses the structure.
Thanks!! I'll hold off until I learn more about collective one and what's possible there. fwiw what I meant by "written text" was whatever it was you were reading off of when you were recording the audio ... more like a musical score than a poem or novel I guess? :)
I was reading what I had written ... as is. I think (hope) it comes off as it does because it is written in unfolding generative steps.
The link above (to collectiveone) will take you to "the text" as you heard it. You may need to reload it a few times it if doesn't load the first time ... it is there!
Impressions
Thanks for these fine offerings @Ronen Hirsch - beautiful design work you've articulated on these recordings.
1) as an example of a generative process it feels pretty whole to me.
2) as an experiment in describing software; I think its far more grounding than most other attempts I've come across which often feel neurotic and heavily invested in a particular narrative.
3) It feels like a warm and welcoming offering for cycle three. I'm encouraged by the clear directionality.
4) A martial arts studio, where you often sit and watch the first lesson. And a motion arts space (e.g. circus arts) where the environment is often casual, welcoming and playful.
Having only checked into this space now, I find it quite synchronistic that I was writing a similar in my own practice space :p Your articulation is much cleaner with a better end result I must say, which speaks to my own process needing refinement. Looking forward to more practice in that regard!
Reflections
Foundations
• This seems like a set of "we" statements offered in good faith. The content of these sit unusually well with me and articulate values that I can resonate with.
Structure
• The passages between spaces seem analogous to communicative bandwidth. Each space a domain with passages representing 'cross-domain' translation. Some passages might be wide open, while others more narrow and esoteric depending how much specialisation s required to grasp the context.
Practice space
• This feels like a welcoming place, with a well designed onboarding process. A space that enfolds you into itself. A moving set of minimal options relevant to the context your embedded in.
Activities guide
• Uncommon sense. This feels like an articulation of what implicitly emerges in a space regardless of what we think should happen in one. I like this social poetry. (note for @Toni Blanco: pricing guide non existent so opportunity to eventually expand and enrich that branch).
Participate
• Indicate interest signal could also have conditions. "I'm interested in attending this IF ... people/price/dates etc.". While price/dates could possibly be articulated in the activities guide people attending probably won't be. Hence some values should be dynamic, while others should be constant.
• The dimensions of immersion in a given theory/practice via interest/practice groups seem on point to me too.
Interest signalling
• Keeping a signalling vocabulary seems both common and novel. Threshold settings for vulnerability and signal decay also seem like pretty fresh parameters. Some spaces have them to very limited degrees but expanding on how to attune them would be a worthy addition to the web.
1. As an example/practice of "generative process"
I realized that a generative process has to be specific enough to make available the essential building blocks, vague enough to let room for imagination. This process was generative that the previous one. Also the audio format works really well, like it did with the Japanese Tea House example.
2. As an experiment in using generative process(es) as a way to describe software
Not an expert myself on software architecture and engineering, but looks to me like a great starting point for generating use cases, jouney maps, list of requirements, etc. and let the process happen.
3. As an offering for collaboration in cycle 3
Is an excellent contribution because is generative (see 1.), reduces complexity from previous cycle and points to more possible concrete outcomes.
4. The actual image that these generative processes evoke in you
I actually imagined a "minimal viable" version of it with our current tools in which tjust the four of us interacted. Silly image, but fun.
Thanks so much, @Ronen Hirsch , looking forward to diving into the files :-)
Thank you all for ingesting this material. Your comments have led to a sense of vitality in me. These are some things that are alive in me:
A question that I've asked before wants to be asked again: do you still feel this is a good investment of your (personal) and our (collective) time and attention? Can you see/imagine/feel something that is needed (in the world you witness and partake in) and that it may viable to create it? To be clear: I do, but I do not feel I have enough contact with the world to assess this reliably.
Some details that came up in your comments (eg: @Alex Rodriguez remixing / @Josh Fairhead pricing) are great materials to work with. However I am holding off on relating to them because they are "in cycle" material ... and we are not there yet. I do wonder if you can see/feel how the existing generative process can become a canvas/scaffolding for placing and developing more ideas WITHIN an existing wholeness?
Your response has provoked in me a generative description (which I have not yet given attention to or placed into writing) for a digital tool that would make it possible to fluidly create and collaborate on such generative descriptions.
This raised another question: how do you feel about making cycle3 about HOW we would approach working on such a generative process? To be clear, this implies that though we would work on this generative process, our focus would be on what is required for this work to be fluid, pleasant, enlivening, and beautiful? This may (likely?) lead to a new generative-process - a description of the above-mentioned digital tool.
I feel inclined to share this with a friend who is involved in Buiding Beauty. BB is a program for architects that is based on Alexander's work. This year they launched a "Beautiful Software" initiative and I wonder if there is a bridge to build there to other people there who may wish to play along in actually building said tool.
Last, but not least, informed by all this, and more, I have a wish to see you all. I want to give time for some more async with your responses/reflections ... but a wish to gather is already alive in me ... wondering about next week (Feb 25th) during sandbox time.
1) I've been reflecting on this as well recently, and a very strong "yes" is up for me here. I'm actually trying to reduce other work commitments in the short term with the idea that this may help open up more sustainable projects for me in the medium term, so I definitely want to commit some time to tending to this if there is a shared sense that it would be valuable.
2) Agree that this belongs "in-cycle", thanks for that very clear and useful language
3) I was also seeing/hearing this possibility inherent in the exercise you shared with us Ronen! I think this is definitely worth exploring together.
4) This makes very good sense to me. I feel enthusiastic and supportive of that as a frame for "cycle 3"
5) Very cool. I also have some ideas about partnerships/bridges/collaborative possibilities with others that I'd love to explore as this unfolds.
Sandbox time on 2/25 sounds good to me!
The investment is good, the key is how good relating to the rest of the things we have on the plate. As it looks now, it will be a priority for me. I value the most the degree of innovation and experimentation I perceive.
I even felt that we were in the inauguration of the new cycle, as a natural flow. But I think that we should take those materials as more sacrificial offerings in the altar, like prefigurative of how we could proceed in the near future, even the 3rd cycle. They are the prove that the process is generative.
Glad you are cooling the urge to write it, so we do not lose focus for the third cycle. Yet is an interesting idea to put also in our sacrificial altar, concerning the next point.
I learned from our 1-1 that you are very sensitive on how difficult collaborative writing can be, (again, I imagine "scars" from the past). This is a critical issue in which we crashed in the present cycle. I would like to address it by experimenting and iterating ideas right away.
I think that inviting timely prospective collaborators to get at least feedback on the project, and eventually organically incorporate them with different degrees of commitment sounds like a clever move.
I would like to meet you as well, next sandbox time works for me. I would love to get from that gathering a quick update of our whereabouts, and a proposal from each of us on how to start to work in the generative process next cycle. A consensus on how we could start to work would be a blast, but not a must.
The time we are investing seems worthwhile to me, there's been no major "catastrophes" and the interaction feels pleasant with ever strengthening connection. I'm leaning towards a mentality of grow slow, fail fast. When you ask whats needed in the world that may be viable, I see a lot of things... and its typically these projects I direct my attention towards. Distributed (sibyl proof) Identity and portable social graphs are a big one for me; I think the latter is a primitive that can be used for soooo many things. I've got a ton of stuff in reserve e.g. this has been tested in workshop but could work great as a community signalling tool.
Yeah, I see the scaffold; in my head it looks something like a Pythagorean tree with different potential branches to follow. I figured it was a later thing but verbalised it as a placeholder ;)
Sounds great, I'd love to see some kind of stigmergic group description tool. I strongly feel that group articulation is a worthy effort. Words cast spells.
The suggestion makes sense to me; I think we have a sense of WHY, so it only feel natural to move to HOW before WHAT. In fact I'd be hesitant to do it any other way, only too often do groups jump straight into the what. Side note: at night I often look up at the big dipper/plough tilt my head on the side so it looks like a question mark and ask myself "why?" to see what emerges.
Again, sounds good to me. I'm open to a slow flow of potential collaborators peeking through the window and seeing if what were up to resonates with them. In related notes, last week when Maija asked me what I'd been up to for the day, I mentioned responding to this thread and sent it over to her. I wonder if the group might like to meet her sometime as well?
Feb 25th during sandbox time works for me and I look forward to seeing you all. Side note on timing though, I often find that the 3-5pm CET window is in the middle of daytime activities. While not necessary to contemplate right now, I wonder how we would feel about starting a little later like 5pm CET or so?
Much love!
Just noting here that though cycle 3 hasn't been officiated , it has, practically, begun.
Hi all, I read through the cards today and recorded myself reading them. I tried to do it in one long take but was interrupted about halfway through, so the recording is in two files. It's a rather large file so it may take a minute to download. The total time of my reading was about 50 minutes.
Thank you, I listened today.
I listened as well and loved it.
Generative Process(es) for a Practice Space
In the attached zip file you will find 8 audio files. Each one is a generative process (though one of them combines two processes into one sequence).
The sequence of the files is ... well ... also a sequence :) Skipping forward will not make much sense as the later processes address things that come up in the earlier processes = the earlier processes set the ground for the later processes.
I am curious how this meets you all :) As you ingest it please consider it from different perspectives:
As an example/practice of "generative process"
As an experiment in using generative process(es) as a way to describe software
As an offering for collaboration in cycle 3
The actual image that these generative processes evoke in you
As agreed ... I offer this in a sacrificial spirit :)