Loomio

Wellington's City Council working on Loomio?

Chris Taklis PublicSeen by 63

I have read somewhere here on Loomio that Wellington's City Council has installed local and working on it!

I want to know if someone from here is on Wellington's City Council or knows how exactly are they working and if they are satisfied?

I want to know because in Greece in 5 months we have local elections and i participate with Pirate Party of Hellas so we want to learn if it is working for a city council and to suggest it for a proposal on our local muncipalities.

Richard D. Bartlett

Hi Chris, earlier this year Wellington City Council used Loomio for a public engagement exercise. You can read more about that here: http://loomio.org/press

I'm not aware of any other projects that they're using Loomio for at this stage. I know there are a lot of good people at all levels of government here in Aotearoa New Zealand that are starting to look this way though :)

Alanna Irving

@chelsearobinson or @benjaminknightloom might be able to give some more info

Caelan MacIntyre

Even local governments are not democratic, and I can imagine 'Loomio usage' as a 'whitewash-as-democracy'.

Alanna Irving

Baby steps in the right diretion @caelanmacintyre :) Our experience working with local government is that there are many, many problems and institutional barriers, but there are many people working on the inside that care about fixing those issues as much as we do! Turns out, it's just really hard and there are no easy answers. But certainly any move toward more transparency and engagement from citizens is a good move.

Simon

The Wellington City Council's Youth Council (YC) has been using Loomio for about 18 months. The YC is an advisory group set up under a Terms of Reference - http://wellington.govt.nz/~/media/your-council/meetings/files/toryouth.pdf. It has up to 20 members aged between 12 and 24 and meets face-to-face every 2 weeks. It uses Loomio to make decisions that can't wait for the next meeting and Loomio works well for this purpose. Increasingly they are using Loomio to augument their formal meetings. YC has a tradition of forming working groups that meet between the formal meetings to progress projects. Increasingly the working groups are using Loomio to help them with their project work. Youth Councillors are getting better at using Loomio for their their own decision making. To date, they haven't used it to engage with people who are not Youth Councillors.

Caelan MacIntyre

@AlannaKrause
The fundamentally coercive, and therefore unethical, nature of the state makes working with it, or a branch of it, an activity of some dubiousness or at least concern, and it is imagined those of Maori decent would agree.

Alanna Irving

The Loomio community and everything we're about is geared toward creating space for constructive collaboration among diverse perspectives. There is no one answer, there is only the power of working together to try to make things incrementally better, more human, less coercive.

Engaging with reality is frustrating complex and nuanced. The truth is that "the state" is only a big collection of tiny actions and individual people adding up to a complex system. My experience has been that there are many, many fantastic, ethical, passionate people working in government who are just as concerned about when it doesn't create good outcomes (perhaps more) than the activists who challenge the state to be better. I believe the best outcomes will come come all kinds of people working with, not against, one another on these issues.

I welcome your voice here @caelanmacintyre (along with all activist voices, and institutional voices, and everyone else), but I leave you with this challenge from a formidable critic of social systems:

“You never change things by fighting the existing reality.
To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.” ― R Buckminster Fuller

We are building a platform for collaboration, which very much includes government as well.

What are you building?

Caelan MacIntyre

Hi Alanna, pardon the delay...
I suspect that what has happened, is happening and will happen is 'everything'...
Some will fight, some will, for example, blow up oil infrastructure, some will build, some will dismantle, some will hide 'eco-warriors' from the illegitimate authorities in their attics, some will subvert the system, some will do other things, while others will do little of anything at all, etc..
Certainly, it would seem that many ethical people have been duped by the system-- the matrix or Plato's Cave, if you will-- that we all appear locked into, prisoners of.
I write this just before reading the recent article over at PRI.
Nature may have a deadline for us, though, so, if so, unless we can get our acts together before that time, she may build a new world that involves our destruction.
As for your last question, ironically, many things already built for us are being destroyed; trees, clean drinking water, good climate, soil and air, real community etc.. I am building a number of things, including Permaea, and resent, to put it mildly, having to build some things just to address certain kinds of destruction.