Loomio

Multiple Consensus Strategies?

David PublicSeen by 113

A colleague of mine pointed out that loomio only has one consensus strategy, and it seems to be, quote*: "mostly majority-rule, with some consensus stuff tacked on".

I think, given the rich history of consensus decision making, and the multitude of successful consensus strategies, perhaps loomio could provide more than one way to come to agreement.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consensus_decision-making lists several, including the very successful Quaker model.

  • not actually a quote

Mike Hargreaves

Couldn't agree more. Even if no one used other methods it would greatly enhance the brand to be seen as the leaders in exploring the essence of decision making.

The selection GUI of which decision making system could be used as a very powerful learning tool for newly formed groups.

Alanna Irving

How would the different ways work in the app that's different from how it works now?

mostly majority-rule, with some consensus stuff tacked on

I totally disagree with this characterisation. Personally I am not part of any majority-rules Loomio groups, although there may be some out there. There are much better majority rules polling apps out there. Every Loomio group I have participated in myself has followed either 100% consensus, or near-consensus.

Alanna Irving

I want to share a response I gave to @treebressen when she inquired about whether Loomio was a consensus tool or not.

I am a facilitator myself, and have fairly extensive experience with consensus based groups (especially from living in cooperative housing, activist spaces, and coordinating volunteers in various contexts). Many of the Loomio team members came to this work through their experience with consensus decision-making at Occupy. We were deeply motivated to try to capture the amazing, transformative power of consensus, while trying to help people avoid some of the potential frustration and heartache of consensus when it doesn't go well.

The Loomio app itself does not seek to determine the "right" decision making protocol for the group - that's up to the people in the group to decide. I tend to describe this in terms of the software being "agnostic". However, Loomio is explicitly designed not to be a majority rules polling/voting app. As you know, making a decision that a significant minority of the group disagrees with (or don't understand, or aren't invited to participate on) deeply fails the potential of the group to evolve better solutions by thinking together. On the other hand, nor does Loomio insist on 100% consensus (though many groups on Loomio do use 100% consensus).

In practice in Loomio groups I am a member of, the group tend to strive for consensus but have flexibility on a case by case basis. Someone disagreeing will trigger the people who care most about the issue to "swarm" and address the concerns being raised, or persuade the disagreers to change their mind. Often the swarmers end up having their minds changed though! Blocks tend to be treated extremely seriously, and if one happens the group will stop and rethink the proposal from the ground up. Many large groups I'm a part of have a culture that if the majority if people agree and there are a few "no's" but they are not serious (and no blocks) the proposal might still go ahead.

What Loomio does for every group is to make their decision-making protocol - whatever it may be - explicit. Having to answer a question like "Who gets invited to what kinds of decisions on Loomio?" or "Is this topic public or private?" or "If a few people disagree but most people agree, what happens?" or "Who needs to agree for a decision to actually get implemented?" or "What is the meaning of a block?" has the effect of immediately revealing the power dynamics in the group, which in many groups remain implicit and uncritiqued up to that point. That alone can be quite transformative.

That said, I tend to agree with you that there is some work to be done to better support deeper understanding and better implementation of these concepts among all kinds of Loomio groups. In the software, I'm interested in ideas like a block turning the entire pie chart red, instead of just your slice, to demonstrate how serious it is, and allowing the definitions and colors of the buttons (we call them statements of position, not votes) to be customizable so groups could define them themselves.

Tree

David, when you say "perhaps loomio could provide more than one way to come to agreement," what do you have in mind?

David

@alanna I didn't mean to characterize loomio in any way. I want to be clear that I am very excited about the future of loomio, and that I think this is a giant leap forward for our future.

I think what my colleague meant was that while the loomio process is indeed general and more of a "guideline", that even as a guideline, it perhaps inadvertently un-assumes some aspects of consensus and assumes others. An example follows.

@treebressen For a specific example of a different model, see the "Quaker-Based model" in the wikipedia link above. The Quaker model shares in some of the spirit of the loomio model, but is slightly different. The "ensure each speaker is heard" concept is arguably much stronger and more central in the Quaker model.

One could envision, as @mikehargreaves suggested, a selection modal where the user would choose the consensus strategy best fit for that particular group. One may be the default loomio "discuss, propose, vote, repeat" process. One may be the Quaker model. Yet another could be the Iroquois model.

This is simply a rough idea for an additional feature, and definitely not intended as a criticism. I only wish to spark discussion :)

Tree

I am deeply familiar with consensus models. What i am aiming at in my question to you is: what do you think the distinctions between those different models would look like in a Loomio context?

As a long-time consensus practitioner and teacher i am never satisfied with the Wikipedia article on the subject, but i never get around to editing it either. I am brand new to Loomio and if there is a tutorial available i haven't found it yet, so i don't even really know how it works and what the current features are. As far as i can tell so far, of the models listed on that Wikipedia page, Loomio's default is probably most similar to the model which Tim Hartnett calls "Consensus-Oriented Decision-Making." (Lysbeth Borie called it "agreement-seeking" years ago in working with our regional Green Party, and it's similar to what's proposed in Cochran's book "Roberta's Rules of Order.") I think it can be fairly summarized in all these cases as having a discussion where people hopefully listen well to each other, and see what proposal emerges from that; then after a fair hearing of concerns and possible modifications, if there is not full consensus but support is strong, the proposal passes. Alanna fairly points out that this software is "agnostic" with regard to decision rule--thus my statement amounts to a guess that without further explicit guidance, the decision rule of "super-majority fallback" will emerge among user groups who lack a strong culture of either full consensus or majority voting.

Tree

P.S. Here is a write-up i posted years ago on the glorious "biodiversity" of consensus models.

http://treegroup.info/topics/types_of_consensus_biodiversity.pdf

You can tell it's outdated because it doesn't include Occupy among the examples of Agreement-Seeking. I don't know about in other countries, but in the US that model emerged simultaneously among Occupy groups all over the place, it was fascinating to see.

Alanna Irving

Great document @treebressen - thanks for sharing!

@david11 I think you're raising some good points here, and I hope you didn't take my comments as resistance to opening the discussion. I think this is an important topic and I'm very happy to see the community exploring it.

I think Loomio as an organization my have a role to play in deepening knowledge of decision-making models and facilitation techniques. Creating learning resources or a knowledge wiki and trainings is something we've talked about and I really hope comes to happen.

However, I think this is a problem of "cultural technology" not of software, at least at this stage. Right now, without changing anything about the Loomio app, you could put into practice testing different consensus strategies. Loomio is intentionally kept very simple, so various groups can use the tool in the way that works best for them. I'd love to support people using all kinds of different models, but I think we can do a lot of that without needing extra features.

Do you think there are things about the software right now that block this experimentation and groups using Loomio to support a wide variety of consensus and other decision making models? if so I'd be interested to know what they are.

David

@treebressen ah sorry I thought you were already familiar with the Loomio process. It is described quickly here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1gLEAKPkOc
Great write-up by the way! Yes, I would agree Loomio's process more closely fits with "Consensus-Oriented Decision-Making".

@alanna I absolutely love the Loomio approach to simplicity and agnosticism. It is what drew me to Loomio to begin with. I just wonder if Loomio could be even more simple and even more agnostic, and yet provide more structure to those that want it.

As for a specific distinction between Loomio's model and the Quaker model, the role of the "Clerk" is an obvious one. Let's say the Quakers want to use this software to bring their consensus process online (far fetched perhaps, but who knows). If they don't see any option to set a "Clerk", perhaps they would be put off by Loomio. Again, just a thought.

Loomio is definitely more agnostic than any other platform I've ever seen, and way more in tune with consensus. But I do think perhaps additional models would benefit the Loomio software tremendously.

For instance, in my own personal fictional group, let's say that I don't want the pie chart. I still want a proposal to be clearly "all consensus" or "blocked", but I just don't want the pie chart because I feel its sheer existence on the page seems confrontational. Shouldn't my group have that option? Now this fictional example may be trivial and possibly nonsense, but hopefully the idea is clear.

Perhaps different groups could use Loomio as it is and provide their own structure, or ignore aspects they don't want, but wouldn't it be better to provide fully operational models for those that want it? Maybe even a plugin system where developers could add new models.

David

Is there no way to edit comments? I had intended to type @alanna @treebressen , but only added @alanna . Now it looks like I'm mostly addressing @alanna and only briefly addressing @treebressen :P That giant page of text was directed at you too, @treebressen :)

Rasikananda Dasa

What possibility could there be for node-based decision making modules which can be combined by users to design and innovate their own decision making systems?

For example:
A decision host sets up a discussion and invites users or opens to public:

A need is detailed - Goal Node is added in block 1

A single or multiple solutions are proposed - One or more possible solution nodes are added to block 2

Each step of the discussion is systematically discussed and voted upon in sub-goal decisions, which add up to inform and weigh the final decision. - Discussion nodes are added to each solution node, which are connected under their respective nodes in block 2, or displayed separately in block 3

Alternative discussion threads and solutions can be added by users to go outside the box, so that all possible solutions get fair exploration and consideration.

...

That's how I'd like to use Loomio in any case.

What could be done to manifest that? What could I do to help?

Rasikananda Dasa

Using such a node-based system, various existing model templates can be applied to use and cusomize. It could be very powerful.

It could also be interesting to see the same discussion modeled through different decision making models and see how that impacts the outcome :)

Quite revolutionary actually.

Rasikananda Dasa

Also having an authority reference node/function would be needed. For example, reference to community laws, or historical reference, or scriptural injunctions, or instructions from group leader

Alanna Irving

I think all of these are really interesting ideas. And I think nothing is stopping you from beginning to implement them right now, without needing to change the software. New features in Loomio should follow how people use the tool, not dictate how they should use it.

@david11 every loomio discussion could easily note the 'clerk' in the context box. And if the group only want to use "agree" and "block" as the only options on proposal, then it's really easy - just only use those two buttons. Software will never be a replacement for the shared agreements, and culture that come from human connection and communication... groups need to set their own norms.

@rasikanandadasa in the same way you could easily run exactly that process you described right now. You'd just need to design and facilitate the process, and make sure everyone participating understood how it was going to work. Then you could raise a series of discussions and proposals.

I'm not sure how much experience you have with software design and development, but working on Loomio and other apps has taught me an important lesson: first you made do with an ugly, unpolished version that lets you test what you think would be a good process in the most basic way, then you take that learn and build the software to match what you've discovered. Not the other way around, where you guess at how the software should work, take the time to build new features, and then try the process in the real world.

So I would say to you, YES I love what you are suggesting! Go try it out with real groups right now. Do you have real groups with real decisions to make who are willing to try these different approaches with you? I would be very, very happy to help you if you'd like to collaborate on some process design. But we don't need to change anything about the Loomio software to get started, we can start with the tool exactly how it is now.

Danyl Strype

Great write-up @treebressen , thanks for sharing it. Another style I would add to your list is the 'talking stick circles' used in the rainbow gatherings, inspired by Native American practices. Everyone who wants to participate sits in a circle and a talking stick (or stone, feather, shell, anything really) is passed around the circle. Each person gets to speak while they hold the stick, for as long as they need to. The circle continues until the stick does a full round with nobody speaking, although people can come and go throughout.

The philosophy behind it is that group conflict generally arises from people's unacknowledged emotional needs, and that by having the chance to speak and be heard without interruptions or time limits, everyone can have their needs acknowledged. Once everyone is sufficiently present, and feels fully included, practical decisions can just about make themselves because the process is no longer bring disrupted by drama driven by personal and group baggage.

Alanna Irving

Nice idea @strypey - would be really interested to see a Loomio group test a process where each person makes one comment, and then the group moves on to more open discussion. How interesting would this be to combine with other ideas people have had around asking for individual input before exposing everyone to other's input? So each person would make a comment, then everyone would get to read them at once, then the group moves to discussion.

Alanna Irving

I wonder if we could develop some "collaboration recipes" - writeups of different facilitation techniques and consensus models, with some step by step directions to follow on how to set it up, and recommendations for what sorts of discussions and group sizes different recipes would work well for.

@carlscrase @vivienmaidaborn @mjkaplan @chelsearobinson

Chelsea Robinson

I think building some recipes together based on experience on Loomio and other online spaces would be helpful to provide the unique insights needed to differentiate the online and offline. I would have thought there were many write ups of step by step consensus building models, each culturally relevant in their own context. Perhaps we can focus our energy on sharing and "open sourcing" our noticings of what works in these spaces? In saying that, the global models would of course be the place to begin!

Danyl Strype

@alanna's suggestion could work with the 'in-the-room' feature. This might look like:
* A round is proposed
* Everyone makes a comment
* Once everyone who is 'in-the-room' has commented, the comments appear, and the discussion moves on

This could be used in conjunction with a period of reflection, where comments are frozen for a given period of time, to make sure everyone 'in-the-room' has had time to digest all the comments, before the discussion moves on.

Richard D. Bartlett

Great idea @strypey, rounds are an absolute staple of in-person facilitation. Would be fun to play with that format online.

Carl Scrase

Sorry for being a bit quite Loomio! Been BUSY at Groupwork and Commonground!

My 'Wondering' is if it is less about the actual function of the tool and more about the framing that happens before in tutorials and such...

STeve Ray

This is a great discussion.. I looked back on a comment from you @alanna about the Loomio process and it was a great help in terms of explaining decision making generally as it relates to the tool. I’m greatly encouraged by the idea that what can often be unspoken and unconscious in many groups, can be made conscious or “exposed” because of the way Loomio has been developed.

Consensus, or collaborative decision making is important when the decision will affect everyone significantly, but less important when people have just some interest but perhaps are not so attached to the outcome. Majority rule is fine in such situations. The key to any decision in the end is making sure you are clear about what kind of decision-making will be best. Its great to know that Loomio supports all and any decision making protocols and leaves it to the group to work that bit out :)

To me the secret of consensus and how you get there is to know why people block or hold on to their idea, because quite often its unconscious reasons that may be related to not feeling heard. When they are, they loosen their grip on their opinion in favour of the larger group direction. Going to a vote can be a sign that we have reached the limits of our capacity to facilitate conversations well and we havent stood by people during the discussion process, so once again there are winners and losers, instead of shared understanding and shared commitment to the final outcome. @carlscrase @vivienmaidaborn

Carl Scrase

Very wise words @steveray

Carl Scrase

Glen's video explanation of 'difficult people' may further expand on your points about 'why people withhold or block'.

Video here: http://youtu.be/feeA-eZDMC8