Loomio

Thank Ian Edwards for his service

Jody Garnett PublicSeen by 4

Ian Edwards has stepped down from the website committee. I would like to ask the board to formally acknowledge his service - with a blog post or similar.

This is in keeping with our goal of "celebrate excellence, openness and service within the OSGeo community".

Dissolve the website committee.

proposal by Jody Garnett Closed Thu 29 Sep 2016 9:01AM

Outcome
by Jody Garnett

Website committee is now dissolved.

actions:

  • blog post, winding up marketing committee, thanking Ian Edwards and assorted volunteers
  • discussion on board list about next steps
  • note: website email list remains open, allows volunteers who have website access to coordinate if nothing else

The motion was made at the 2016 Face to Face meeting to dissolve the website committee as "inactive". This was delayed at the request of Ian Edwards (committee chair).

With Ian's decision to step down, and the committee's inability to attract active volunteers I would like to once again table the motion to dissolve the website committee.

Results

Maxi
Agree

maybe we could give this task to the marketing committee?

Venka
Agree

Huge thanks to Ian for his services.

Jody Garnett

Deciding how to manage the website is not the subject of this proposal, recognizing that the website committee is non functioning is.

Jody Garnett

Okay I seem to be confusing a thread and a proposal, wonder if a thread can have multiple proposals?

Anita Graser

Yes a thread can have multiple proposals

Anita Graser

Is there any summary of activities that happend while Ian was active? Is the traffic on the mailing list representative?

Jody Garnett

So how do I add a second proposal to this discussion? Reading it seems like the advise discussing first and then putting a proposal at the end..

Anita Graser

It seems like there can only be one active proposal at a time. Once the first proposal is finished, a second one can be started.

Anita Graser

Maybe you should shorten the deadline for responses, since it's currently still open for 13 more days.

Jody Garnett

Changed the proposal closing time, I am a bit suspect that the discussion topic was read, rather than the proposal given venka vote of "agreed:
Huge thanks to Ian for his services" ... but we are still learning.

Anita Graser

In case there was a misunderstanding, @venka can still change his position on the proposal while it is open.

Venka

I think I have already voted as agreed,

Venka

I see that 33% of board members had not voted.
I thought that a motion is passed when all
board members vote and no one votes -1.

Please clarify if my understanding is wrong.

Best

Venka

Jody Garnett

this tool is set up to provide a time frame for voting

Venka

Yes, I understand about the time frame. My question is regarding what do we do if everyone has not cast his/her vote? Do we table the motion again, extend the deadline or declare the motion as rejected?

Jody Garnett

I expect it depends on the context, sometimes we are voting on time sensitive topics (and have failed to get back to event organizers in time).

I think we should use the timeframe restriction on purpose, and use a long period (like 10 days) for issues that are not time sensitive. I would rather have the tool send out reminders to individuals to vote, than follow our current model where we send out email near the end (as you were just forced to do when I was slow to vote - sorry just moved no internet yet).

Venka

Yes, apart form try to tailor the tools to suit our decision making (sending remainders etc.) we need to find a way to see that the motions receive all our votes before they are declared as passed or rejected. For the time being, maybe an e-mail remainder could also be one of the options to ensure that all of us cast their votes.

Anita Graser

@venka afaik everyone who hasn't voted should receive reminders already when the deadline draws close.