Loomio

Add the ability to facilitate discussion using De Bono's six hat model.

James Samuel PublicSeen by 61

Add the ability to facilitate discussion using De Bono's six hat model.

proposal by James Samuel Closed Sun 6 May 2012 8:38PM

This suggestion (offered by my friend Trent Yeo at Ziptrek in Queenstown) could make it possible to focus the discussion very intentionally. This could be valuable when the proposition is around an issue with a major consequence. We could try it here, in a loose way with this proposition.

http://www.debonogroup.com/six_thinking_hats.php

Results

Joshua Vial
Disagree

I would suggest not building this until teams (maybe us) have trialled the process using our existing tools.

Alanna Irving
Disagree

I think most of this idea can be accomplished with tags, which also offer the flexibility to be used in other systems as well. Should be up to each group how to do their process.

James Samuel
Agree

It appears that this suggestion can be implemented with planned features - nice.

Aaron Thornton
Abstain

Wish list for now - Future functionality

James Samuel

Assuming the role of facilitator for this process (if you're willing), I invite you to offer comments while wearing the White Hat, which calls for information known or needed. "The facts, just the facts."

Richard D. Bartlett

Is it possible to run a 6 hats discussion with no additional features to Loomio?

Alanna Irving

I'm open to this idea, but I think I need to hear more about the vision of how it would work in the software

James Samuel

"Is it possible to run a 6 hats discussion with no additional features to Loomio?"

It would be awkward, but made easy with a small additional feature:
The ability to choose a coloured dot to be associated with a comment...

White - information known or needed
Yellow - positives and probing for value and benefit
Black - judgment, why it may not work
Red - feelings, hunches and intuition
Green - creativity, possibilities, alternatives, and new ideas
Blue - six-hat process


".. more about the vision of how it would work in the software"

I imagine a hover-over tip with a transparent circle, then different hints (as above) if a colour has been chosen.

If it was possible to then sort the comments by the colours, that would make it easy to know, that in the process of making a thorough 'map' of the issue, I'm now looking at all the facts (white), emotional responses (red), etc.

Richard D. Bartlett

One of the big features on the wishlist is to add tags to comments: it sounds like you could get 6 hats going nicely with just tags. Tags would work both for categorising comments, but also for sorting them after the fact. If I'm not missing something?

The great things about using tags as a solution is that they enable opinionated facilitators to run discussions how they like, while maintaining complete agnosticism, in the sense that it is a feature that adds no weight to one style of discussion over another.

Having never participated in a 6 hats discussion, I wonder if the discussion work better if you stick as rigidly as possible to the 6 categories? For instance should I be trying to remove any red from this white comment? Would it would be useful for the facilitator to come in and add tags to other peoples' comments?

James Samuel

Yes, absolutely, tags could serve this purpose, along with all the other wonderful advantages tags offer.

The second point about rigidity: My preference is towards greater not less flexibility. The idea of being able to add two tags to acknowledge there are two types of thinking going on in this comment would work just fine.

If the six-hat methodology is seen to be useful, then people would probably be inclined to try to stick to it themselves without having to have a rule applied to it.

And with that I think I've managed to start a nice rainbow of white, yellow, red, green and blue :-)