Loomio

Feature idea: ability to create disposable groups with expiration dates!

Tobias Eigen PublicSeen by 60

(I tried joining the feature request group last week but my request is still pending - so here's my feature request. Please move it if desired)

I realize this is a radical idea and has probably already been considered and dismissed. But I think it could really help with making loomio more broadly accessible and useful to communities around the world.

I'd like to be able to create disposable groups that can be accessed by anyone with a hashed link, like a doodle poll or google doc. To contribute to the discussion or to vote you have to log in, but to see the status of the discussion and voting you do not. The group creator sets a deadline by which time the decision has to be made at which time the group is exported into a PDF document summarizing discussions and decisions, a copy is emailed to all contributors, and the group is then deleted from the server.

My use case is this. I am on mailing lists for many communities I am involved in, including for example the various schools my kids are in. We often make decisions by email either via email discussion groups or a massive CC. It drives me completely bonkers to have to actively watch long threads of email only to see emerge what is often an imperfect decision.

Instead whenever I see this start to happen I'd like to head over to loomio.org (or, much preferred, my own self-hosted loomio instance), create a disposable group, and send the link to everyone and ask them to continue the conversation there and make a decision together.

The advantage to this is that we are not asking every community to switch from where they are already connecting (change is very hard) and we also are not littering the Internet with alot of content that is not needed and needs to be managed. But we get the advantage of all the goodness in loomio including full transparency and participation.

Alanna Irving

Hi @tobiaseigen - sorry about your request to join feature ideas falling through the cracks... I'll look into that!

You'll be happy to know we're already hard at work at pretty much exactly your idea! It will work like the demo in this video. Things like PDF export are also in the pipeline.

However, you can also accomplish your suggested use case right now, without waiting for any updates to the software. Just create a Loomio group and email the link as you described. You can create proposals with your desired deadline. You could also state that the group will be closed on a certain date. when it's done, email out the outcome.

Sort of a manual hack, but it would be lightyears ahead of you having to "actively watch long threads of email only to see emerge what is often an imperfect decision."

Jelle Langbroek

Thanks for your usecase scenario. These kind of examples expand my thoughts about Loomio and how to use it in my community.
Does @alanna solve your problem here?

Alanna Irving

Yeah it's so great to hear about use cases!

Tobias Eigen

Thanks @alanna! I've watched that video before but I guess I need to explore more and start using loomio for actual decision making before I start promoting it in my day to day life.

To me loomio feels very much like a community site each person involved will have to join in order to contribute from it rather than a "utility" like doodle that makes it super easy to get to the part where you put in your email address. I think while that is the case it will be hard even for advocates to convince people in their local communities to start using it.

It's all good, though :) I know this is a process and I am excited to see where loomio is headed.

Alanna Irving

Yeah totally - we are totally on the same page. Here at Loomio HQ we’ve been referring to it as “shifting from group-centric to discussion-centric” and specifically look to Doodle for inspiration for a low-friction easy to jump into web utility. At the same time, people can discover the value and decide to move to create persistent groups and form communities too if that’s what they want.