Loomio's legal structure
We're at the stage where we really need to nail down an appropriate legal structure for Loomio. Not being set up as a legal entity has already become a bit of a roadblock to getting funding.
There's been lots of great discussion over the last few months about our core values and bottom line(s). From near the beginning we've been operating under the shared understanding that neither the traditional charity model, or the traditional company (dividend distributing) model were a good fit for our values and social mission.
This means that two main options are under consideration:
1.a social business [a non-distributing company with social values]
2.a cooperative [an organisation collectively owned by and democratically operated for the benefit of those using its services].
I'm pretty happy with whatever you guys want to do.
I like companies because I understand them and they are super flexible so it's easy to do whatever we want.
I like a co-op because it is something new and we will learn a whole lot by trying it out.
So I'm pretty happy either way.
Well by this time I have considered both nfp company and cooperatives several times and changed my mind several times. In the end I am supporting the Cooperative Model. To be really honest I think it offers an incredible opportunity to tell our story and market Loomio in a powerful way internationally. I dont think the legal concerns are deal breakers and I have really appreciated the work Rochelle and Stephen have put into their advise. I also think the cooperatives model offers us a way to bring 'users' into the legal structure which is very appropriate for us. Finally I think it gives real power to the workers of the cooperative to both set the salaries and pay for staff but also to consider use of surplus at year end, this includes ways to reinvest in the business, ways to support more social enterprise, and ways to acknowledge and reward staff well. I would love to hear what other people are thinking at this stage
A lawyer with experience of forming and working with co-ops on a long term basis is Alastair Hercus of Buddle Findlay (498 7318). He tells me he knows one of the Enspiral people.
I've been putting off thinking about this up until now, but having just read through everything in this discussion, I'm very excited by the concept of a co-op.
The inherit values implied by the co-op structure seem to mirror many of Loomio's core values. I particularly like the idea that co-ops are easy to join, so we are minimizing our barriers to access for people who want to start getting involved in the project. Open, fluid, friendly. It sounds like to sort of thing that excites me.
So the question is... if we go with the legal structure of a co-op, will we be able to bend it to fit our needs? Certainly it means more legal work for us in the short-term, and perhaps just more legal-work overall in the long-term too. But perhaps worth it.
One question though. I'm just thinking about our limited resources right now, and whether starting off as a co-op would mean more legal work than we currently have the resources for. If that were the case and we decided to go with an NFP legal structure to start with, how hard would it be to switch to a co-op model later on?
Ultimately, I don't have the time or expertise to dive into the technical differences and legal implications between co-ops and NFPs, but I love the idea of becoming a co-op. So I'll let those closer to the issue work out the details as to whether it's a viable (and non-detrimental) option for us right now.
Hey Jon, a couple of things for clarification, we dont have to decide between a NFP and a coop, but rather between a nfp company structure and a nfp coop structure. We could start with a company structure and convert it into a coop and infact from a legal process point of view every coop starts setting up a company. However because our company structure would be designed for us and our weird ideas and beliefs it will take as much constitutional development work as a coop, so no real cost difference between the two for us. I asked Rochelle exactly that question yesterday! Interesting what you say about a Coop being easy to join, it certainly could be but that would depend on the different classes of shareholder defined in the constitution, and I guess the real practical issue that it will be primarily a workers cooperative and the number of workers is set by the success of the business - how many people we need.
Have you ever thought about getting a copy of Co-opoly? It's a board game in which players collaborate to start and run a democratic business. Find out about it at coopolygame.com.
Thanks heaps for getting involved in the discussion everybody! Looks like it's about time for a proposal eh?
That we go with a Cooperative legal structure for Loomio (figuring out the specific legal details as we develop the constitution)
proposal by Benjamin Knight Closed Mon 6 Aug 2012 7:27AM
We're getting set up as a cooperative social enterprise! Stephen and Rochelle are helping us develop the constitution.
We're at the stage where we really need to nail down an appropriate legal structure for Loomio. Not being set up as a legal entity has already become a bit of a roadblock to getting funding.
There's been lots of great discussion over the last few months about our core values and bottom line(s). From near the beginning we've been operating under the shared understanding that neither the traditional charity model, or the traditional company (dividend distributing) model were a good fit for our values and social mission.
This means that two main options are under consideration: 1.a social business [a non-distributing company with social values] 2.a cooperative [an organisation collectively owned by and democratically operated for the benefit of those using its services].
Viv and I have been doing lots of research into both, and are pretty excited about the cooperative model, mainly because the underlying values fit really well with what we're doing. See here (http://nz.coop/understanding-cooperatives-principles/) for a good description of the values underlying the cooperative model.
When we first spoke with Rochelle, she was less keen on the coop model, largely because it's less familiar and there's not much case law that can be used to clarify the specifics. This means there's a bit more ambiguity, and that it would take more research before setting up. She also felt that there might be some unknown barriers or annoyances that could be problematic.
Last week we set up a meeting with Ramsey Margolis (director of NZ Cooperatives Association), Rochelle, and Stephen, to discuss the pros and cons of each model (full notes here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1en1KK8k-CzPtoxZvBT6g8jWjuY0WssQwdRzgIoJKQI0/edit) and the legal details of the coop model.
Although there is some ambiguity surrounding the definition of 'transactional shareholder' in the Cooperatives Act, there didn't seem to be any major barriers to the coop model doing what we need it to do for Loomio.
There are various types of coop that we could consider (workers coop, multi-stakeholder coop), and we'll need to do a bit more research before making the decision, but I just wanted to start this proposal to see how people feel about the coop model in general.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 8 | 73 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 3 | 27 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 889 | 99 |
I really like the fit with our core values, and I don't see any serious technical reasons against it. Plus the .coop domain will be so heartwarming!
Hell yeah!
It seems like coop is slightly harder to get set up, but it feels like the good kind of effort. I am still open to being convinced otherwise, however.
Co-op seems like a cool idea, but I don't reaaaally understand these legal structures enough to agree.
it is a powerful way of living our values and indicating that to everyone we work with
I'm with Paul
Same as Paul and Matt.
Please don't hesitate to ask if there's anything in the proposal that needs clarification
@Ramsey - Co-opoly looks amazing! Thanks for that
Hey Matthew and Paul - thanks for the feedback - if there are points you're not clear on, feel totally free to ask for clarification!
I've seen the dicussions through yammer and the attached google docs, it does seem clear to me that there's enough people who really do understand the legal structures and you all agree. I'd have delegated my vote but the features not here yet.
We're at the stage where we really need to nail down an appropriate legal structure for Loomio. Not being set up as a legal entity has already become a bit of a roadblock to getting funding.
There's been lots of great discussion over the last few months about our core values and bottom line(s). From near the beginning we've been operating under the shared understanding that neither the traditional charity model, or the traditional company (dividend distributing) model were a good fit for our values and social mission.
This means that two main options are under consideration:
1.a social business [a non-distributing company with social values]
2.a cooperative [an organisation collectively owned by and democratically operated for the benefit of those using its services].
Viv and I have been doing lots of research into both, and are pretty excited about the cooperative model, mainly because the underlying values fit really well with what we're doing. See here (http://nz.coop/understanding-cooperatives-principles/) for a good description of the values underlying the cooperative model.
When we first spoke with Rochelle, she was less keen on the coop model, largely because it's less familiar and there's not much case law that can be used to clarify the specifics. This means there's a bit more ambiguity, and that it would take more research before setting up. She also felt that there might be some unknown barriers or annoyances that could be problematic.
Last week we set up a meeting with Ramsey Margolis (director of NZ Cooperatives Association), Rochelle, and Stephen, to discuss the pros and cons of each model (full notes here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1en1KK8k-CzPtoxZvBT6g8jWjuY0WssQwdRzgIoJKQI0/edit) and the legal details of the coop model.
Although there is some ambiguity surrounding the definition of 'transactional shareholder' in the Cooperatives Act, there didn't seem to be any major barriers to the coop model doing what we need it to do for Loomio.
There are various types of coop that we could consider (workers coop, multi-stakeholder coop), and we'll need to do a bit more research before making the decision, but I just wanted to start this discussion and get everyone on the same page.
What does everybody think?
PS I'm going to invite Rochelle and Stephen and Ramsey into the discussion to offer some educated opinion!