Opportunité atelier ESG-UQAM - 25 octobre
Bonjour à tous,
Fabien Durif (vice doyen à la recherche de l'ESG-UQAM), nous a sollicité pour animer un atelier lors de ses portes ouvertes de la recherche de l'ESG UQAM le 25 octobre 2017.
Il y a une possibilité que ce soit rémunéré mais ce n'est pas encore sûr.
L'atelier est animé en coopération avec 2 chercheurs que j'ai rencontré (Viviane Sergi et Claudine Bonneau).
Le public est une 40taine de personnes (chercheurs et gens d'affaire)
L'objectif est d'aborder avec eux les thèmes suivants :
* Nouvelles attentes des travailleurs
* Nouvelles formes d’organisation et de management (plateforme et leadership)
* Opportunité de l’innovation ouverte (innovation en écosystèmes ouverts)
L'atelier doit durer 1h15. Le format pressenti est celui du Bocal (fishbowl), pour permettre une discussion participative, qui sera introduit pas 25 min de concepts que nous amenons (exempled e OuiShare).
Est-ce que quelqu'un s'oppose à ce que nous participions à cette journée ?
Même si elle n'est finalement pas rémunérée, j'y vois un bon moyen d'élargir notre réseau, de travailler avec de nouveaux chercheurs et de renforcer notre partenariat avec l'UQAM.
Est-ce que quelqu'un veut contribuer ?
Dans la mesure où je serai sur la fin de la période de transition, ce serait un bon moyen pour quelqu'un de s'approprier le discours OuiShare.
Je cherche une personne pour m'aider à préparer la présentation
Nice! Super cool! C'est une très bonne idée d'y participer.
Oui, participons
I believe that a network should be permissive to all kinds of activities, and should allow others to solicit work for free. If some affiliates are willing to do free work, good, fine.
But, and this but is very subtle and I invite everyone to stop and think for a minute before dismissing it, there is a form of injustice and abuse that sets in if the network does most of the work for free to anyone, especially to those who have resources to reward our work but contact us because they know that they can get it for free.
The problem comes from an asymmetry.
We are willing to provide with no expectation of reciprocation, to those in need and who cannot reciprocate. Or we find a secondary advantage in providing in such way. But if the receiver can reciprocate, has resources to help Ouishare in return, but doesn't want to do it because his purpose is to save, then we have a problem.
Open networks fall pray to all sorts or third party organisations who try to get something for free. Again, my intervention here is not against giving for free. It is against giving to the people who have the wrong intentions and approach. The problem is that very few open and collaborative networks have mechanisms in place to overcome this form of abuse.
If you think OuiShare is immune to this sort of abuse please take a minute to explain it here.
Is this even a problem?
I think it is, because some of us would like to spend more time on Ouishare if they could pay their rent. Some activities such as this one proposed here can be a vehicle to generate some revenue to that purpose. In absence of this revenue ouishare will lose good tallent, dedicated individuals, who will need to go back to a capitalist job to pay the rent, and will also leave somewhat frustrated because ouishare as an organisation feels like an uphill struggle.
well, I agree with you in principle that we need to charge for our participation when possible. As for the cases of Univerities, in my 12 years experience as a faculty member, there are no funds available to pay for people to participate in class or workshop for a single class or a workshop that is part of a scheduled course, only for non-curricular of continuing education. In a con-ed context, we should charge the going rate for faculty or about 200$ per hour or 1000$ for a whole day (that is usually 6 hours in a university). Otherwise you need to become a member of the teachers union or be setup as a TA. Exceptions are always possible, but are, by nature, exceptional. I think participating in a university graduate or event undergraduate course is good for us but we need to be able to do it professionally and leave all participants with the info on how they can get more info about us and how they can joining OuiShare.
I don't resonate with "we should charge whenever possible". It's not what I said.
We should definitely charge those who have the means to reciprocate but who try to exploit the network.
The core of my message is to surface this form of subtle abuse of open networks, and their incapacity to get out of it because most of them don't have mechanisms in place to deal with it.
But we can also think beyound monetary exchange. If those who need our help are unable to reciprocate monetarly they can do it in other ways. For example we can ask for a post on theor FB wall or for a tweet, or for other type of favors.
And again, we should not think only in terms of exchange. But in my opinon open networks are largely unaware of their value and operate on the other side of the spectrum, getting screwd most of the time.
Also, individuals are free to provide a free service as part of OuiShare. Most of them do that for second order benefits (be seen, gain acceptance, reputation, etc. ). The network's capacity to provide these free services has its advantages. That is clear. But at the same time it also hurts the network. For example, some outsiders understand that they can come to OuiShare and get away with a free service and and save some cash. And they get used to that and this is where the abuse comes from. It's like being nice to people all the time and sooner or later you find out that a lot of your so called friends are in fact there to profit from your goodness. While you get cut into this pattern of giving and are more and more solicited to give and valued by others for giving you wake up one day that you have nothing to eat, because you were too much focused on others and not enough on your own subsistance.
Also not what I said. I said when, not whenever.
The same subject has been discussed in the global connectors group, regarding repeated invitations by the European Commission to collaborate on projects for free.
I have to say that it is not clear for the moment that th workshop is for free. Fabien has to try to find partners. If Manuvie accepts to finance the workshop, we could earn 5K.
I decided to move on because Fabien is a friend, that gave us our reputation on the market with the Mapping and the study for the government. So he is not a random instution that want our services.
J'a reçu mes horaires pour l'automne et je donnes 3 cours le 25 octobre. Je ne serais donc pas en mesure de participer à cet atelier le 25. Le 24 ou le 26 serait très bien,mais le 25 c'est impossible pour moi.
Très bonne idée, POUR cette participation!!