Exploring together opportunities for income generation like NOW
I start this thread as a container of the conversations related to the material conditions of the existence of our crew. When I say "container" I mean that its purpose is to "contain" the discussion of the particulars of the (financial) needs of the members of the crew so they do not "spread" over other conversations related to the needs of sustainability of the digital space. In the future the creation of the generative space could address the needs of income of the members of the crew, but we are not there yet. In other words, the design of the generative process and the digital space should be informed but not subordinated to the current needs of the crew. We are back somehow to the distinction of two different generative processes, the one we are experiencing as a crew and the one of the digital space.
Until now, we have been lucky to self-sustain/fund our participation here with incomes out of this crew. It is true that I (and probably the rest of us) have been modulating our participation in accordance with the pressures of the work that generate incomes. However, we cannot take for granted that the need for an income will not jeopardize our participation in the crew.
Of course, an option can be to just be absent until we can self-fund again our staying here. But another more interesting option is to make solidarity happen in our micro-dimension and explore together ways of getting the income needed for making everyones' participation possible.
I have been re-posting job offers at Discord that could be interesting to members of the crew and that is OK. This thread is for bringing this spirit further and exploring together if by sharing and combining knowledge, skills, contacts, and the ripened fruits of our work here we can address the changing needs of the personal incomes that make possible our participation in the crew. This kind of support is critical to our crew because sharing/mutualizing things that affect the material conditions are barely possible because of the remote element of the equation.
The same situation we are in will likely be similar to crews forming in the digital space so all learnings in this aspect could/should be translated into design features of the digital space.
Informal gathering on Pantheon Work consulting
poll by Toni Blanco Closed Tue 2 Nov 2021 3:07PM
18th of November at sandbox time (15h-17h UTC) we will have a gathering in which Sergio and I will share with you how we stepped together in consulting in a way that we are happy with it. Link will be shared at the discord channel the day before.
I want to make an offer open to the members of the crew. I would like to offer a detailed explanation of what Sergio and I are doing under the digital identity called Pantheon Work (which is not even a legal entity). Origin, what are we hired for, how we "sell", what kind of organizational leaders hire us, what we do, what methodologies we took from others, and what we have developed, and new areas of work that seems to be emerging (in the crypto sphere). Sergio will be delighted to do this with me. I think it is important because I brought him into the consulting business so his perspective is different than mine. I keep him updated on what we do although I have not shared the digital space with him (yet). He is not very fluent in English but @Alex Rodriguez will be happy to assist if some translation is needed.
Three are objectives of this informal gathering:
1) Inform our conversation on money. I would like Sergio to retell the conversation on money we held when we started Pantheon Work. I have the feeling that we covered most of the ghosts that are haunting our crew regarding money (with the help of our friend and colleague Ingrid), and I think that we had a positive influence on each other regarding this issue, for we both changed our relationship with it for good.
2) Make thinkable ways for income generation. Sharing context about the way I earn money and explore together if we envision options of leverage on that to other members of the crew make money too, either with our current clients or new ones. So the exploration is broader than "making consulting together", whatever we mean by "consulting" or how we could frame different forms of support to organizations. Opportunities could come from offering specific services to our clients not related to consulting, subcontracting tasks in projects, etc.
3) Extra ball: lessons for external signaling. Sharing how we went out to the world two and a half years ago, for I feel that our crew is quite in a similar moment. It worked, so maybe we can learn some lessons from that.
The gathering would happen at sandbox time for two hours. It will feel short.
Results
| Results | Option | % of points | Voters | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 18th | 46 | 6 | ||||
| November 11th | 38 | 5 | ||||
| November 4th | 15 | 2 | ||||
| Not voted | 0 |
Two things speak to me from your offer Toni:
1) It's a story of YOUR direct experience which I'd love to hear :)
2) It's experience I stand to profit from as I begin to set sail on similar waters
Nov 11th is tricky already, I could possibly do Nov 4th if you have an itch (I'm feeling a sense of imperative in your posts which I'm interpreting as coming from a place sensed opportunity). If it can wait, my preference would be to meet on the 18th as some opportunity seems to be emerging this week my side as well and I'd like to maintain enough space for it to unfold.
Due to travel timing and flights, @Jennifer Damashek and I will be unavailable at that time on November 4th, but the other days should work fine.
What incredibly precise container text Toni, exceptionally clear and well articulated. Differentiating discussions like this makes a lot of sense. Slowly new opportunities are presenting themselves to me and should there be surplus I'll be sure to present offerings here.
The most recent update being that an old collegue of mine has gotten a job with a crypto vc and has reached out looking for talent. The specifics were quite general but content writing and such sounded in demand. I'll learn more as the week progresses but I can imagine you are encountering similar requests from these outfits.
If I were Santa, vcs and crypto funds would probably be on my naughty list but I'm less rigid with my moral code these days (ethics ftw); I actually figure its fine to interface with and appropriate from leviathan as the transcendental slime machine will keep transcending us either way. Whatever opportunities happen to arise, I'll share here as... sacrificial offerings (😂 loving the #sin references available in this paragraph)
Invitation to share gifts/skills and map relationships
proposal by Jennifer Damashek Closed Fri 12 Nov 2021 4:25PM
It's been agreed that it is a good idea to create a container to share what gifts and skills we bring to the crew. Included as gifts we bring are the networks of relationships we each inhabit. Robert and I will propose how to collect and keep this information by November 21st.
A container was created to identify the needs of the crew. I am proposing there also be a container to share what gifts and skills we bring to the crew. Included as gifts we bring are the networks of relationships we each inhabit. If we agree to share these gifts and skills, I propose that it include a map of the networks each member inhabits.
I propose this to allow the crew to discover and realize the abundance that is already here, like hearing what Toni and his partner are already doing. If the crew does want to do meaningful work together, to me it makes sense to understand fully what each member offers, and to visualize relationships can be drawn on to engage that meaningful work.
If you have already created something along these lines, I’m not aware of it, and would someone please point me to it?
I think this could help facilitate a shift from focusing on what is lacking to what is abundant. I learned the power of this approach through working with the Post Growth Institute, which uses the Asset Based Community Development approach.
In our society, we usually we operate from a place of lack because that is how we are trained. Here is a comparison of Deficit Based vs Asset Based development.
Deficit Based vs Asset BasedIn the past when a person had a need they went to their neighbourhood for assistance. But this has shifted today to the belief that the neighbour does not have the skills to help them. Therefore they must seek services and go to a professional for assistance. In so doing, reinforcing the form of system that divides people into providers and recipients.
Deficit Based |
Asset Based |
Problems, Blame, What’s missing, Scarcity, Risks, Needs, Control-outside in, Top-down, Do to, Clients & passive receivers, Provider-led |
Possibilities, Shared ownership, What’s there, Abundance, Courageous leadership, Strengths, capacities, assets, Lead by stepping back, Inside-out, Do with & enable to do, Co-producers & active creators, Citizen-led |
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 6 | 100 | 100 | ||
| Abstain | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 0 | 0 |
For what it's worth it seems like there is overlap here with the Value Network Analysis process @Toni Blanco had proposed to lead us through in the last Cycle, but that we opted not to. Perhaps Jennifer and Toni could put their heads together to lead the crew through some sort of facilitated process?
I can see how we are "trained for scarcity."
I definitely experience scarcity in my day-to-day life but I don't think it is just because of the "training."
I am aware of and have tried to place "warning signs" around me that I am informed by that mentality.
I can't see, from where I am, how implicit mapping can change this.
This meets me as an invitation to try a different mindset and to discover what emerges when this mindset meets the established crew mindset.
I am grateful for the invitation.
I agree in the value of looking at (and being surprised by) how much we have to offer each other, and wherever the crew decides to go. I developed a list of all the initiatives of my career along with related skills, was totally blown away, and it helped me hone my own target for where I wanted to go.
You never know when you can need something, and sometimes you don't know either what you need in a particular moment. Also, very often you are not aware of the gifts you can offer because you are not aware of them or you do not value them properly. With those limitations in mind, I think that this kind of listing/mapping will be very positive for the crew.
@Alex Rodriguez A value network analysis would be a different approach, because it would start by mapping the current-already on-going exchanges. This cycle has started with lots of offerings, so it kind of start to look as our future digital space :-) I think we can keep that activity for later in the cycle.
So expanding on why jobs; to hold space for 'asset based development'. Bringing in a deficit based approach out of need would be a bad way of doing things.
Here is the thread where we talked about Value Network Analysis: https://www.loomio.org/d/XgZktJyH/gathering-12-june-10-2021-collaborating-on-a-generative-process
Yesterday I had a conversation with a fellow volunteer at The Post Growth Institute. I asked to speak with Naryan because he knows how to conduct network mapping. I participated in a workshop that he offered on the subject a few weeks ago. I wanted guidance on network mapping for our crew.
It came a delightful surprise to learn that Naryan actually is working with a crew. It seems his crew is already doing what our crew hopes to do. They have formed a coherent working group of five people, within a larger cohort of 50 people. The metaphor Naryan used was a slime mold. Apparently slime molds exist as independent cells when food is abundant, but when food is more scarce the free cells come together and function as units to find food and help deliver it to each other. In the past few weeks, Naryan's crew has formed and begun working as an intelligent organism. He shared with me that after this short period of time, his crew has successfully identified so many ways to bring opportunities for work for each other that they couldn't possibly take advantage of them all. I found the conversation encouraging.
I recorded the last 30 minutes or so of our conversation. I missed the first 45 minutes because I didn't think to record it. Here are some notes on what he shared about being a crew, at least the kind of crew he is in.
The most important skills for his crew are social skills: how to develop a truly collaborative culture. This is hard work. He referred to adult development and authentic relating. These skills are needed in order for a collective consciousness to emerge. Trust between members is required.
Also important is systems thinking, and being able to identify which level of thinking and relating is active in the moment, otherwise people talk past one another.
Record relevant conversations so other members of the crew can learn from them.
If there are side conversations between crew members, report back to the crew anything that is important for other members to know.
The last 30 minutes of the conversation was about network mapping. He shared with me how network mapping is useful to a crew and what tool he uses to do it.
Robert and I made a first pass at creating a network map, which also can contain experiences, passions, knowledge areas, and skills, using the tool Naryan told me about: kumu.io. Robert will share about the map in a post after this one.
Here is the recording of the last part of my conversation with Naryan.
On Slime Mold :)
Thank you @Jennifer Damashek for taking the time to explore this with Naryan and for sharing the notes and the recording.
Some initial thoughts:
As with "offers and needs" I believe that this needs to be a (continuous) process and not a (one-off) project ... for numerous reasons.
I am superficially familiar with kumu.io (played with a couple of times). It feels like a good tool, but I got the impression that it may have performance issues when scaling. I believe that Obsidian has similar (at least basic) capabilities that can be explored if we wish to continue to work within our newly established environment.
I believe that "not placing yourself" on the map is a (critical?) error as it allows for a gods-eye-view which is, in my opinion, risky (if not delusional).
I have a feeling that there is an information-architecture challenge here that could radically increase the leverage of such intuitive efforts.
I get the impression that mapping is somewhat of a fashion but I have not yet encountered (personally, directly) an effective application of this kind of mapping.
The relational network mapping does not seem to systemically address offers/needs which makes me feel that the mapping is incomplete.
IF (and that is a big if in my mind) this kind of work can be effective then I feel that individuals or crews creating separate maps is wasteful since the more enmeshed the network becomes (which is what seems to be happening) the more people will be working on separate maps which are the same map. This feels like it should be a collaborative effort on a larger scale.
I believe that such "living maps" can be an emergent outcome in the Digital Space. There, instead of mapping being a retro-active documentation effort it can be a dynamic (living, responsive, ever-changing) outcome that comes from relationships forming (without any additional explicit work).
Proposal to use kumu as a mapping tool
proposal by Robert Damashek Closed Sat 27 Nov 2021 9:03PM
Kumu appears to be a possible tool for our crew to understand ourselves better, by mapping out our relationships, skills, knowledge and experiences. Today we began creating an initial sample of what the crew’s network map might look like in Kumu here. I was able to take data from a projects table I had built for my consulting resume and reformat it easily into an Excel spreadsheet structured for import into the tool (it can take CSV as well). Jennifer created a fresh spreadsheet and imported it into the same map. The tool is all data-driven and the map is built automatically from the data.
I propose that we each build out the data for our network, and use the tool to fuse and visualize that network. We will share the spreadsheets we used and the crew can decide what types of data they want to gather, share and integrate.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 3 | 50 | 50 | ||
| Abstain | 2 | 33 | 33 | ||
| Disagree | 1 | 17 | 17 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 0 | 0 |
I don't mind (in sacrificial spirit) experimenting with kumu.io
I'd like to hear from @Josh Fairhead about the possibility of using Obsidian and the graph view to work within our (newfly found) natural habitat.
As I replied to Jennifer, I believe that for this to be effective, this needs to be a process and not a one-off effort. I believe that in Obsidian (given that we are already shifting towards inhabiting it) a good process/protocol is more likely to manifest and flow well (which is why I want to hear from Josh).
It is not clear to me if the free version of Kumu.io allows for team collaboration or only isolated users.
As an extension, it is unclear to me if your invitation to is collaborate on Kumu.io or to each submit spreadsheets to your or Jennifer in order to integrate in Kumu.
I believe that mapping a personal network (and seeing it is part of an interconnected network) is not a one-off thing, that it is a continuous process of reflection, review and discovery. Therefore if it is NOT a collaborative (generative) process I believe it will stutter and stagnate.
I am abstaining because I want to both offer my thoughts and inputs AND to signal that I am willing to play along with your invitation as it stands.
I've previously tried keeping data on entities in the external world but this tends to decay. The cost of articulation has generally outweighed the benefits of this practice for me so I'm hesitant; I have a variety of spreadsheets trying to do this; people, orgs, networks ect. which I've tried to reformat, store and organise in Obsidian. Honestly though said conversion is a mess; as I don't find the data valuable I'm reluctant to spend time ordering it...
First of all, I'm not quite sure that mapping is a great use of our collective energy right now. I feel like there are some needed steps to take around how we agree to invest our shared energy/effort into something as a crew. I think before we do this it would be better to decide on a workflow for maintaining a map, and also a shared sense of what the map would be a map of for it to be valuable to all of us. Second of all, I'm not a huge fan of kumu.io as it does get glitchy and also I think something like Maptio would be a better fit for the sort of thing we're trying to make happen with the digital space. In other words, if we're starting to build a map, I'd want it to be something we're learning how to do in service of the digital space we're starting to imagine into being with the GP. I'm also feeling like I have enough "tool skilling up" work in front of me with the Obsidian/Git transition.
Also, I totally don't mind anyone playing around with this tool in a sacrificial spirit!
I will try to find the time to do this and see what comes out.
Here are a few points in response to comment by @Ronen Hirsch and @Josh Fairhead.
My proposal is really just an experiment to allow us to get to know each other better, while exploring the circles, resources and connections we have to help with steps like the crowdsourcing initiative the crew discussed today. In that regard, it might help us shape our outreach communication.
Since Kumu is entirely data-driven, no one needs to actually look at the visual relationships if they don’t find that helpful. Kumu has an option to both view and edit the data directly, as well as doing so visually.
In addition to CSV/Excel and Google Sheets integrations, Kumu has a JSON-driven import/export mechanism import into Kumu (used internally for backup and transfer), so it’s possible that an Obsidian linkage could be established.
I want to state that gathering this data for myself, at least in terms of projects and connections was a lifesaver in one instance a couple of years ago when I got let go from a large consulting firm and had to free lance it for a bit. That’s why I had the data for the Kumu test handy, and it was easy to reformat it to import into Kumu. Just to note - we’re not stuck with Kumu as the data can be exported in the same ways discussed above.
I fully agree with Ronen that the network mapping has to be collaborative and the content will evolve dynamically. In fact, I have envisioned the identification of dynamic correlations and potential connections/collaboration opportunities as a valuable service in and of the digital space that we could approach at some point through integration with AI. @Josh Fairhead and I discussed this a little in our visit earlier this week.
The free version of kumu fully supports team collaboration, editing and extension. What it doesn’t support is automatic notification of changes. Jennifer and I had hoped to build this collaboratively, but if anyone is hesitant at using kumu, we can take the raw data (perhaps through a spreadsheet or form) and put it into kumu.
I hope this helps clarify the proposal’s intention.
Thanks,
Robert
Regarding point 4 - I am curious @Robert Damashek about your experience of revisiting your network:
was actual mapping (as in graphically/visually using a tool like Kumu.io) a part of the experience you had a couple of years ago or did you use some other tools such as a document/spreadsheet?
If it did not include graphic mapping, reflecting back on what you did do a couple of years ago, do you feel that visual mapping would have made your effort more effective?
If so, how?
@Ronen Hirsch When I did my actual mapping, I was using a freelancing company’s tool that used a spreadsheet metaphor, and it didn’t have an explicit visualization component. Instead it focused on analyzing the depth of a freelancer’s experience and comparing that with active opportunities. It also generated excellent reports that were useful for resumes.
Given that exercise and my subsequent use of the knowledge I gathered for research in conjunction with LinkedIn, I do think that the visual mapping of relationships would have been extremely useful in that research to help identify existing or new relationships and potential consulting opportunities.
That’s why I think it would be helpful to the crew to do the same for potential crowdfunding opportunities.
@Alex Rodriguez if your response to the Kumu.io proposal includes "I don't mind anyone playing with this in sacrificial spirit", should it not be an "abstain" instead of "object"?
In my mind "object" is a blocking signal that indicates that you are not OK with this moving forward.
What I hear you saying is that you are not interested in investing in this, but that you are OK if others want to move forward with it without you. Is my understanding correct?
Thank you @Ronen Hirsch for trying to clarify the response from @Alex Rodriguez . I was unclear how to proceed with an outcome from this poll, particularly because the crew had already approved the poll submitted by @Jennifer Damashek to map out our networks in support of identifying potential connections for either generating income or crowd funding. If this is indeed a block, then does someone want to submit a proposal for an alternative way of capturing the map? I’m definitely not stuck on using any specific tool. Kumu came up in a meeting @Jennifer Damashek and I had with an acquaintance from another solidarity community, and I was every impressed with the usefulness of the map he had built for that community. In fact, developing these kinds of maps is one way he makes a living as a consultant. After I tried Kumu out and figured out the import mechanism, I personally found it really easy to use. I would just like to move forward with gathering the data and building our network map.
Hmm, it seems that we aren't all on the same page about what the signals in Loomio polls mean. I voted "disagree", not "object", because I wanted to signal that although I wasn't personally sold that this was the best tool for the job, that I did not intend to block it moving forward. Had I objected, I would have voted "block." In any case, I think it is important that we establish some protocols for how we make decisions moving forward. This seems especially relevant to our scope this cycle around working with money.
Thank you @Toni Blanco for initiating this thread. I feel I have very little to offer as input on the short-term subject which you are holding and so I will be mostly listening.
I just wanted to clarify that exploration signals that I will probably be putting out on the longer-term view of money are offered in parallel to this initiative and not intended to compete with or ignore it.