A Pirate Mandat
Hey everyone,
I contacted Richard yesterday, to inform him about my candidacy for a seat in the national parliament of Germany. I have been thinking about this step quite a while, and I will try to get on the list for the Pirate Party Berlin. The chances that I make it are pretty low, to be honested, Berlin is one of the smallest states within Germany, and when and if the Pirates make it, Berlin will probably get 3 of 620 seats, and there is a long list of applicants.
Nevertheless it is still the biggest chance to get even close to a seat, and I believe the discussions, information and experience I will collect will still be useful in future events.
Why?
Because I don´t want to merely run with some emphatic promises but bind my electoral power towards a the members of the pirate party berlin and the people here in Berlin. In other words I want to run with an imperative mandate (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperative_mandate).
The consequence of this is that, in case of election, I would use the complete budget attached to being a mep in order to develop tools and plattforms allowing the people here in berlin to influence my time as a politician.
This is roughly 300K € per year, and I believe that should be enough to optimize and adapt some plattforms, hire one or two people responsible for communication plus someone to do the administration stuff.
Well, I contact Rich and writing you today, because I desprately need help. I believe, the loom.io community and myself share a common goal: To empower individuals to take part in decision making and so put the (in my case political) decision making process on bigger base. Ultimately to overcome the feeling of being powerless and voiceless. I hope you agree with me on that point. If so, I would like to invite you to join a discussion about this. In need to review tools, form a more detailed opinion about the hows, the impediments. I have been following many discussion you had so far and believe you are a remarkable community with very valuable insights.
Since there is a 12 hour time differences, I wont be able to answer always on time, I don´t even know how the next 6 weeks - that´s when the decision whose running will be
made within the pirates of berlin - will roll out. But be sure, I will read everything and be very thankful for any sort of contributions.
So tl,dr:
Please help me to gather ressources about different tools, plattforms, possibilities and so on, in my road to the national parliament.
Best. Torsten
Ditto to what Rich said.
Start small, simple and local. It's worked really well for us. It's easier to experiment and figure out what works when you start with small simple solutions than if you try to architect the perfect system.
The question I would ask if I were you is, "What is the simplest possible solution for what I'm trying to achieve?" Which obviously begs the question, "What am I trying to achieve?" (this should probably be asked first).
For instance, in Iceland they decided that they wanted to write a new constitution which better represented the desires of the people. So they came up with an extremely simple system (using just facebook and twitter) to crowd-source their new constitution.
So...
- What do you want to achieve? (be as specific as possible)
- What's the simplest way to achieve it?
Thanks @richarddbartlett @jonlemmon. since the term imperative mandate is misleading I shall exchange it with the term pirate mandat which yet has to be defined. Here in Berlin, we have been quite successful with the slogan:
We are the ones to ask the questions, you are the ones to provide the answers.
But instead of focusing on developing new processess the pirate are currently concentrating on writing a full programme. Here is where I think we are missing a historic change.
I think a pirate mandate should bind itself towards this slogan. As a politician you have a privileged access towards information, in order to upgrade democracy, my vision of a professional politician is that s/he use this information and translates it into understandable communication, not only text based but also visualisations, videos, interviews, personal talks and so on. After this translation, I would ask questions via yet to be choosen plattform, and invite people to submit answers for this particular political problem. Since the pirates are far away from taking any governmental responsibility, the job of the opposition is than to use this input and slip it into the political decision making process.
I think, this can build some pressure, make politicians aware of more aspects of a problem and create better and more sustainable solutions.
That is what I want to achieve.
And I am reaching out to find the simplest way to reach it. ;-
oh, and thanks for the links, richard. this kind of meta overview is priceless. Of course I know some tools, but within the pirates we are currently mostly spinning around ourselves. which is exactly the reason why I want to candidate. And no worries about ranting, it is good sparring for the internal grilling, that is about to happen in a few weeks.
Even though, I think I need to think about more than a mvp, because it is not only the product but mostly the offer towards the pirates here in berlin and the general public and the attitude that I want to have (or need to develop) towards. It may sounds stupid, but I am thinking about rather being the vessel for direct democratic elements within a representative democracy. whilst staying a human being with all the flaws included. Currently I am spending a lot of thought in the difference between social role - having a public role - and a person. In sociology you work with the definition of a role as cluster of expectations. And while these expectations have to be answered in one way or the other, a solid and clear concept towards it, could allow me to keep my personality and proctect me and everyone in contact with me to become a sugarcoater. What I mean is, yes, binding my vote towards a public decision based by the crowd/community, but keeping my own personal views visible.
So let´t say the crowd decides that they want more cars within in germany, something I couldn´t agree less with, I would still vote for it, but at the same time not keep my mouth shut, that I think, it is a stupid idea.
My hope is, that overtime, people starts to learn taking decisions more serious in the sense, that they spend more time in reflecting consequeneces and hope that me contiously commenting the processes and decisions does make a differences. I know, it does sounds schizo in the beginning, but come on, three line whips is, too, or?
Exciting stuff @torstenfischer! Excuse me while I rant a little... (I'm still on holiday so I'm allowed to :)
I assume your campaign will be centered around your particular version of the imperative mandate. This raises so many juicy questions! e.g. what will the mechanism looks like, who are you seeking a mandate from, how does the system self-correct, etc...
In some respects I see a parallel to where my thinking was at the start of this Loomio journey: if you're not careful the questions will overwhelm you and/or cause your brain to explode! My recommendation would be to break it down to the smallest possible system ('minimum viable product') and roll forward from there.
If it were me I would put more emphasis on getting people involved with the system design, as opposed to worrying about getting the design perfect. I don't believe there's an 'ideal system' of governance that's just waiting to be applied. In fact I think putting too much effort into the theoretical aspects of governance can be counterproductive, an elitist thought-experiment that is unlikely to have dramatic real world impact.
I think the most important thing is that people participate. If the system is dynamic and the people are engaged, you'll be doing better than the currently popular forms of representative democracy. This means you have to give people an incentive to participate: there needs to be a tight feedback loop so the citizens can see the effect of their input.
I really recommend especially the first half of this conversation about the revolution in Iceland to give you an example of what I mean: the system is rudimentary but the outcomes were really significant. Of course in that example the incentive was the financial crisis - I suspect you're going to have to come up with something different to mobilise people in Berlin :)
Also re: tools, I'm sure you've seen the metagovernment wiki? Also this is worth a look.