Loomio
Tue 14 Jan 2020 12:31AM

Decide on the statutes principles for the asset-holding association

MQ Mauko Quiroga Public Seen by 8

Objective

Reach consensus on the principles behind the statutes.

The logic behind it would be better to set on stone the big principles of the association before writing the statues.

Open to discussion.

Links

List of shared assets

Project of statutes (FR)

Trello card

MQ

Poll Created Thu 23 Jan 2020 4:49PM

Name Closed Thu 9 Apr 2020 1:14PM

Outcome
by Mauko Quiroga Thu 9 Apr 2020 1:16PM

OpenFisca

OpenFisca Shared-Assets Holding

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 33.3% 2 MS MQ
Abstain 50.0% 3 MBJ LB T
Disagree 16.7% 1 SC
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 0  

6 of 6 people have participated (100%)

MS

Matti Schneider Thu 2 Apr 2020 7:10AM

> I was highly inspired by their own statutes for this proposal

Interesting! I guess this explains some of the limitations I have spotted in the proposed articles, where I feel that the to-be association wants to manage a good without owning it, whereas I expect it to fully own it (so that no one else does).

LB

Laurent Bossavit
Abstain
Wed 18 Mar 2020 4:51PM

I'd go with just "OpenFisca"

T

Thomas
Abstain
Wed 18 Mar 2020 7:04PM

I agree with Laurent. OpenFisca is enough.

MS

Matti Schneider
Agree
Wed 1 Apr 2020 1:31PM

I'd rather have OpenFisca Foundation, but I like that the name makes explicit the specific aim of the entity.

SC

Sandra Chakroun
Disagree
Wed 1 Apr 2020 9:33PM

I disagree with the term "holding" as it sounds like a business group. I'm fine with OpenFisca [shared assets/Foundation] 🙂

MBJ

Mahdi Ben Jelloul
Abstain
Sun 5 Apr 2020 3:20PM

Simple and clear OpenFisca

MQ

Poll Created Thu 23 Jan 2020 4:56PM

Object Closed Wed 8 Apr 2020 10:02AM

Outcome
by Mauko Quiroga Wed 15 Apr 2020 2:22PM

We're going to propose a counter-proposition.

To protect the « shared assets », whether owned (brand) or stewarded (access to Github)

What is a shared asset in the context of this association ?

  • the brand, which allows the general public to identify OpenFisca;

  • resources that allow the community to use OpenFisca;

  • resources that allow the community to contribute to OpenFisca.

What is not a shared asset in the context of this association ?

  • the code itself;

  • the way people maintain and contribute to OpenFisca;

  • the way we finance OpenFisca development, nor the management of those funds.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 20.0% 1 MQ
Abstain 60.0% 3 MBJ LB T
Disagree 20.0% 1 MS
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 0  

5 of 5 people have participated (100%)

LB

Laurent Bossavit
Abstain
Wed 18 Mar 2020 4:52PM

Would prefer this if it stated an active duty to preserve OF's status as a commons.

T

Thomas
Abstain
Wed 18 Mar 2020 7:07PM

I would explicit the prevention of enclosure of OpenFisca as a digital common.

Load More