Loomio

Public Noticeboard

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture) PublicSeen by 154

Place for announcements or to start conversations that may spin out into new threads.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

😆 Welcome to the co-operative movement. Joking aside, I think that the more organisms in the environment, the greater the experimentation and potential for cross-pollination.. Platform 6 is also hopefully going to be much more than a platform and about much more than co-op start-up.

Emma

How on earth did this and Unfound all happen independently of one another??

Graham

Well done Mark, looks good. I've been snowed under with day to day in the last couple of weeks and haven't been able to advance as much as I'd have liked. However, have noticed this morning that https://start.coop/ in the UK looks now to be open for business. Lots for us to learn there I think. I'm trying to get a call lined up with Greg Brodsky there to discuss collaboration potential.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

I'm proposing to send the following update to the people who have signed up to our mailing list. I'll hang fire for a couple of days if anyone would like to suggest any changes.

Platform 6 – June 2018 Update

As we enter Co-operatives Fortnight, we thought that we should update everybody who has taken an interest in the creation Platform 6.

We are a new co-operative of UK co-operators and co-operatives who want to sustainably grow the co-operative economy through the peer to peer provision of high quality expertise, services and funding, accessible to all through a co-operatively owned and controlled digital platform.

We want a world where co-operatives work together to support the next generation of co-operatives in an open and dynamic co-operative economy.

We are building an on-line supportive community of co-operative practice that will:

  1. Facilitate a network of co-operative expertise and shared resource.
  2. Generate funds for any co-operative development or education activity.
  3. Broker relationships within that community of practice to deliver formal co-operative business support to new and existing co-operatives.

We have incorporated as a Company Limited by Guarantee: Platform 6 Development Co-operative Limited (Company no. 11402403). We are currently setting up a bank account and once we have that set up we will open up membership of Platform 6 to new members in late summer 2018.

Membership will be open to “any individual, corporate body or nominee of a unincorporated body, firm, partnership or corporate body that wishes to use the services of the Co-operative and has paid or agreed to pay any subscription or other sum due in respect of Membership or the use of the Co-operative's services.”

Initially we will be targetting individual co-operators, with a target of 50 members in Year 1.

Membership will require a regular monthly contribution to the co-operative. Using the on-line platform, the members will then collaboratively manage the distribution of those funds to projects that support the objects of the co-operative.

It is envisaged that early proposals to the fund will be mainly concerned with the development of the technology to create the next iteration of the platform, which we will then promote to the wider co-operative movement. However we will be open to proposals from elsewhere and ultimately the members will decide how funds are spent.

We are also exploring other ways to fund this early development, so that we can increase our impact in the early days.

We'll be back in touch soon.

Mark Simmonds
Company Secretary

Platform 6 Development Co-operative Limited
http://platform6.coop
Twitter: @platform6_coop
Facebook: www.facebook.com/platform6/

John Atherton

Yeah I went to the one last year they did in Manchester, was very good

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

I've just booked on to the Masterclass in Decentralised Organising - July 13th
London option on July 21st

I think that this will be very useful to Platform 6 and wider.

About this Event
If you are trying to organise in a decentralised, collaborative, less-hierarchical team, you are probably asking yourself: How do we include people in decisions without spending so much time in meetings? How do we develop an open, collaborative culture? How do we encourage participation, engagement, and shared responsibility? And if nobody is in charge, where does accountability come from?

https://www.thehum.org/events

Graham

I'm keen to learn views on this from others in the CDB sector.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

As we are now incorporated, I have created sub-loomios for full members and Directors. I anticipate that they will be little used until we have a bank account and can invite applications for membership.

bob cannell

Loomio is difficult to follow. Too many threads with maybe impoetant things hidden in them and hidden in the acres of text. To keep up takes a long time. And the more people the longer it takes and then its just the usual suspects talking to each other at length again. Your mindmaps are 'at a glance'. Wonder if there is an internet equivalent?
I did ask Loomio if they would offer a character number limited version, like Twitter to make it easier to scan read posts limited to 200 characters.
Young people use Snapchat to limit their information over load, texts are deleted after a few minutes and users encouraged to use pictures. I was surprised Loomio in practice is so much like the old bulletin boards of 20 years ago. Richard Bartlett etc. use more modern communication techniques In Real Life as we saw in Manchester.

Hope this is of some help.

Bob

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

Cheers Bob. Do you think that Loomio, which we intend the use at first, will provide that? If not, where is it lacking?

bob cannell

Hi, folks. Ive been quiet but I fully support Platform 6 (great brand name) I am concentrating on the people dimensions of coops and cooperation via CoopHRM (boring working title). Slow progress, lot of interest and need but everyone is as confused as me about where to start!
For Platform 6 I would ask for a network in which the entity and members can communicate two way and the members inter communicate, efficently and effectively.
Simple and intuitive. So members are able to engage 'at a glance'. Fewer words (sorry).
If Im getting coop overload other people must be!

Emma

Does anyone know of any lovely, patient, co-operative, (good value) accountants keen to help out a budding platform co-op?!

Emma

Yup, we are eccoo (Equal Care Co-op, name changed from Careshare) and not actually online yet so hope to get good benefit from the programme. Launch event was Tuesday to meet everyone, which went pretty well - I've been following Platform 6 with a lot of interest as its certainly something we could really use! A core challenge of the platform co-op model is that the user / service provider base are not usually tech-savvy themselves, so balancing out the development expertise needed together with the membership and user decision-making ethos / requirements of the co-operative is an on-going question. So far we're approaching it with bespoke rules, sociocracy, service design and really friendly developers who do accessibility properly. Plus a bit of funding and a relaxed approach to learning as we go. Though reading through some of the threads on this group it feels like there's a lot we're missing!

Asher (attached) also input some useful governance challenges to the day (there aren't enough baby pictures in this working group imho)

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

I've been working with ECCOO and @emmaback is in this group. I've also had some contact with Open Food Network - a more co-operative version of the Food Assembly model, which Nick Weir is involved with.

Graham

Just picked this info up about the groups that have been supported by the strangley named 'Unfound' programme:

The eight successful accelerator teams

CabFair
Equal Care Co-op
Schumacher Commons
The Media Fund
The Physio Co-op
We Collective (Weco)
Land Explorer
Open Food Network UK

I know about Weco, and a bit about the Open Food Network. Anyone got any insight on any of the others? Is Equal Care the social care cooperative in Hebden @marksimmonds ? In which case that's you @emmaback ?

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

One of the things I like about this project is that, as others have stated, we may be able to crowdsource the accountability, quality assurance etc. It may be that all we need to do is provide templates for proposals.

The other is that we don't need to decide all this stuff - we can simply create the platform and see what happens, the membership then making democratic decisions informed by the learning generated.

If this just becomes a virtual CDB of the usual suspects then I'm much less excited about it. See also comments elsewhere in this Loomio.

Much to talk about on Thursday.

Nathan Brown (Co-op Culture)

Barefoot Co-op Development is another area where there is another shared interest with Solid Fund. I think bottoming out how SolidFund and Platform 6 interact is important

Graham

I'd like to think we can collaborate with this programme and be a partner.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

Would be good to game ways to defraud the platform - ie creation of imaginary projects requiring support. Will the membership spot these during a participatory budgetting process? Presumably gofundme etc. deal with the same problem. Does it matter? Can we live with the odd rogue application and learn?

Graham

I agree. We aren't in the business of providing support, but we are in the business of connecting people, so we don't need to be insurable in that respect, and we can make it clear in our T&Cs what the deal is. We can also make it clear that only some of the people offering advice are professional advisors (and are insured), and others are barefoot advisors/mentors (who won't necessarily be insured), and let people make their own choices. As a peer 2 peer platform with a vision of a growing and vibrant co-operative economy I believe that we have to enable and support ordinary people to offer their skills and experience to start-ups and scale-ups. The important thing is to be open and transparent. I also agree on the need for a reputation system of some sort.

In terms of "rogue practitioners" I'm curious as to what their motivation might be. If people are able to upvote/downvote and provide negative reviews (or possibly even blow the whistle) then wouldn't poor practice be quickly spotted?

Nathan Brown (Co-op Culture)

I don't think we necessarily need to go down the route of "having to be insurable" in terms of support provided. The providers of support have to be responsible and liable. I think we need to be clear if this is to be a platform (a thing that connects) or a service provider (a traditional consortium). The platform business model connects the support provider with the user of the support. E.g. using Airbnb as an example, if I stay in your flat, your insurance covers you, Airbnb has no insurance for your flat. Can we develop an ebay/airbnb approach whereby user feedback indicates quality? Would they even know what good quality is? If quality assurance and professionalism are pre-requisites to registration as support provider that role is perhaps best met by a separate yet possibly connected body (a professional association for advisors?). Perhaps the question is "How do we respond in the instance of a rogue practitioner and how do we find out they are rogue?".

Austen Cordasco

We have to assure quality and professionalism, we have to be insurable and we have to be able to filter out rogue practitioners. These things are not automatic for any platform and we will have to make sure they are in place and robust before we launch, but they are at least doable.
I am wary about setting up this platform as a vehicle for barefoot CD practice because I am not convinced that barefoot practice is able to achieve these things - they seem to be problems inherent to that model. Barefoot practice is good for mutual co-operation between consenting co-ops that are willing to share the risk of failure or sub-optimal outcomes but it takes only one rogue practitioner to destroy the reputation of a professional service provider and so we have tread very carefully here.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

I think that if we get this right then the platform would be the ideal vehicle for barefoot co-op development.

John Atherton

Another initiative going on at the moment is the Co-operative Barefoot Advisers programme. Although starting with some physical workshops, I think it will develop into the need for an online space for people to share resources, mentor and support each other. I'm just wondering how we ensure synergy with this project and how it develops?

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

Cheers Austen,

I've no problem with any of that. I'll make sure the next
iteration reflects that.

I am sure the mailing list glitch will be sorted (not in my
gift).

Mark

Graham

Thanks for taking the time to report the issues. For you, I've added in the hyphens on the website. I disagree with your position on the hyphen, but I'm not going to lose any sleep over it. I've turned off the on-screen error reporting on the website so the notice won't be seen by others. I've not added the full name of the company or other details as yet, becuase that company doesn't yet exist. Clearly the website is very much a work in progress and needs a lot of input. Volunteers welcome.

Austen Cordasco

Great that we have a business plan. I can't see any serious faults with it except that the proposed mission statement does not include the market building/proselytising function. Also, Object (c) should be corrected to read "... employment that is satisfying...".

Great also that we have a website, but that does have errors:
- The hyphen in "co-operative" needs to be reinstated throughout, including the name. We will have no credibility if we can't spell that word correctly.
- It makes no reference to co-operative development. It's primary purpose is a platform to facilitate co-operative development, not just the creation of new co-ops.

- Its name should be "Platform 6 Development Co-operative Ltd.", as per the business plan.
- On signing up for the mailing list I got the error "Notice: Undefined index: address in wf_crm_webform_postprocess->saveContactLocation() (line 751 of /home/p6/sites/default/sites/all/modules/webform_civicrm/includes/wf_crm_webform_postprocess.inc).", but it seemed to work and I got a confirmation email.

I don't want to sound too critical - the work that people have put into these creations is so valuable - but we do need to get them right.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

Quick update as everything is moving so quickly and Graham and I have been co-ordinating by phone whilst on the road.

We have registered the domain platform6.coop
Graham has created a holding website at www.platform6.coop
We also have a currently quiet twitter account: @platform6_coop
We have an email address: info@platform6.coop
We have submitted an on-line application to Unfound – the platform support programme http://unfound.coop

We have a bare bones business plan to submit to the Unfound programme this week. The Unfound programme basically gives us access to a series of workshops with other platform co-ops and the opportunity to pitch at Congress in June.

The business plan is attached, comments welcome and nothing is set in stone - we just needed to create something for Unfound.

We have interest in involvement from various tech co-operators – see other threads.

The leap forward has been prompted by the Unfound application and an urgency around getting a bank account – people want to start giving us money.

I’ve spoken about the platform at the Ctrl Shift summit over the last few days and had significant interest, not least from Jon Hall – communications officer at Community Energy England.

We are meeting on-line – see Zoom invitation in Meetings thread.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

Re on-line meeting - poll closes today. It's currently looking like 12th April. We would have had interview for Unfound by then. @sionwhellens you have yet to respond to extended poll and additional dates.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

The poll for the on-line meeting is due to finish tomorrow, but some people have indicated that they can't do any dates and @jdaviescoates has added some dates. Even if you've already completed can you indicate your availability for the extra dates. I'll extend the poll till Monday.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

I've now upgraded this Loomio group at a big discount (£90 instead of £390) negotiated by @graham2. We can now grow and have more functionality.

Graham

Good news. I suggest that once we've resolved the issue of the cost of opening this group to a wider number of people, that we invite people from the Development Cooperative in here so that they can engage more actively.

As for converting their legal structure to support what we're going to need I guess it's a recognition that a) the DC as it stands has not delivered, and b) that they are supportive of where we're heading. If it's a shell that we can re-shape, and that works for what we want to achieve then I'm open to it.

Josef Davies-Coates

I'm a big fan of multi-stakeholder structures and it seems most/ many of the practitioners we'd like involved in this are already involved in that so could potentially work nicely (or horribly if it just means we inherit a load of issues I'm not presently aware of).

John Atherton

All in favour of re-using a perfectly good legal entity, but worth bearing in mind that DC has not been a great success so we wouldn't want this fund falling into the same trap.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

DC very interested in co-operative development fund/platform work. Possibility floated that DC could become multi-stakeholder and be the vehicle? Don't get too excited either way. What do folks think of that idea?

Graham

Good, I was going to ask you about that. Hope it goes well.

Graham

Great. Who do we talk to?

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

According to Bob Cannell, Mondragon have a large co-op development fund that they aren't using and are keen to look at using it overseas.