uses of communication tools within Loomio community
Can anyone describe to me the type of communication that yammer is used for, as opposed to email?
And I'm really unclear who can see the posts on yammer? Is it effectively like FB unless you select different privacy settings?
Well maybe it would be interesting to incorporate a mumble client for voice and chat communication.http://mumble.sourceforge.net/ . Mumble is used heavily by PIRATE parties all over the world and an essential tool used by 15M/Indignados movements in Spain.
I like Simons description and find we are doing more and more in Loomio. Yammer has lost focus for me because I cant keep up with everything and have prioritised Loomio.
Yammer used to be important for us before Loomio's features were developed. Now, it's still good for general discussion. But important stuff is on Loomio. Email is good for limited audience communication but we generally open discussions up as much as possible. I still find yammer useful for communication that does not require a decision/action/response like "hey look at this cool article" etc. If we started putting all that on Loomio it would be too noisy.
So, in conclusion, we're kind of just making it up as we go (as usual).
Thanks everyone. So if I wanted to write a message to the core Loomio community (and I know defining that is tricky too) that was in relation to a potential client but which I wanted to keep confidential for privacy reasons, should I just use email?
Yep @sophiejerram at this point for anything confidential I would go with email.
Hi everyone, as a a community involved in creating collaborative community communications I would think that using all form of communication would be wise in terms of experiencing trends across multiple forms of media. @alannakrause I think making it up as you go is the perfect tactic, providing every on is still gaining learning.
I reckon we could ditch Yammer and email and use just Loomio if it were easy to control the audience at a per-discussion level.
As a first step, I'm thinking for public groups, we'd just need an option on the New Discussion form that allows you to make that discussion private to only group members. How hard would that be @jonlemmon?
Currently Loomio is organised around static groups of people, but I have a hunch it will evolve to be more dynamic in future. I'm imagining the New Discussion form to have a field that asks "Who would you like to have this discussion with?" that would take any combination of individuals and groups, e.g. "sophie@jerram.com, Loomio Developers, Loomio Interns"
I would miss Yammer's chat functionality a bit.
@joehopkirk one of the more important aspects of loomio when it was first proposed to me was that it was going to free me up. (it's a bit like how whitewear household goods were supposed to provide us with more leisure). I want less time online, not more. So I personally only want one clear channel for the group of people I am working with the most.
@richarddbartlett I don't agree with you because for me Yammer and Loomio don't serve the same purpose at all. I see Loomio as a software that helps me to make decisions with peers I know, or people who belong to a community I also belong to. Yammer for me is more of a network designed to make new connections and share random stuff without having to think "humm… What should we decide on this".
In other words, I quite like to have a place where I can keep it totally informal and share anything I like. I use Loomio to speak about important discussions about my community, and I like that it has this specific purpose.
I guess my perception could evolve with the app though…
@nicolaswormser I think we could probably still keep Loomio as "the place to go for making decisions", while still also having an area within Loomio for sharing random stuff. In fact... I'm going to try this right now:
I use yammer for posting images and things that some specific people might be interested in (I @mention them), but also other random browsers might find useful.
If strong privacy is required and only a few specific people will be interested I use email.
Wall features like yammer are useful because they don't clutter your inbox with low-probability-of-value material but still allow you to opt-into the org's 'stream-of-consciousness'.
Yammer is private to that org. Within yammer you can have groups that anyone can browse into, and will appear in their stream if they are a member. You can also have groups that private to their members and invite-only.
We are using yammer less and less, and I sometimes hear chatter about a wall feature for loomio...