Domain renewal - Proposals
Hi all,
In the light of what happened overnight (for those in the EU, at least!) I'd like to evaluate whether it makes sense for us to either:
- set up a recurring payment to renew the domain
- reserve it for N years right away
Domain renewal
poll by Michele Kipiel Closed Sat 5 May 2018 12:02PM
Looks like a recurring payment is the preferred option among the Finance WG members
Feel free to add pros and cons to your answers!
Results
| Results | Option | % of points | Voters | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Set up a recurring payment | 83 | 5 | ||||
| Reserve the domain for N years | 17 | 1 | ||||
| Not voted | 4 |
I'd say set up a recurring payment, though if we formalize our structure, that might change.
For the time being. We do need to sort out the basic organizational/legal status question. Why not form a coop where the coop laws are best suited to this project?
Oh wow, this is good to know. (We could have done this through IoO.coop as well.) I'm fine with setting up a faircoin wallet and using that as an alternative membership/payment system. But I do think we should ensure that Start.coop is controlling its own domain registration.
That's important to know. Presumably it means legally FairCoop is responsible for the domain?
Also, for the pollers to be fully informed, I think we should know the price for reserving the domain for N years. Is it N x 71.5 EUR, or cheaper? And then I suppose there's the cost in FairCoin.
It is my understanding that an organization committed to the 7 cooperative principals is is eligible to get a .coop domain. Was there actually an attempt to register social.coop directly? If not maybe we could start there and transfer ownership of the domain initially to the founding admins until such a time when social.coop solidifies it's legal status.
As social.coop is now associated with IoO in some way having them register would be a secondary choice. The FairCoop arrangement seems overly complicated.
@ntnsndr can you give us some insight around this? Thanks!
IoO is not itself a co-op and was able to register directly, on the basis of being democratic and of supporting the co-op movement. I'm sure social.coop could obtain approval on its own steam. I can help with that; I'm friendly with the people behind domains.coop.
"Looks like a recurring payment is the preferred option among the Finance WG members" - true, but what about the domain name registration issue? It seems like there are a couple of options on the table: FairCoop, IoO, Social.coop on its own steam...?
Yes, this decision does feel like a prerequisite. As out IoO rep, @mattnoyes would you be able to get a sense of what doing it through them would look like?
Having done registrations before through IoO, I can attest it doesn't require much other than us vouching. But I bet we could do it on our own too.
I would say until we settle on an actual cooperative structure -- we are getting close -- we should not do it on our own. It seems important to preserve the integrity of the domain name. Or am I just being pedantic?
I would argue that Social.coop
already does have a very cooperative structure, as articulated in
our bylaws. It will surely change, but I see no way in which the
current form does not constitute a cooperative enterprise—even
more so, in fact, than IoO.
Fair enough, I have no interest in arguing against social.coop's cooperative character. So, who can put this in motion?
I have asked @enric2 to change the "administrative contact" of the domain, which at least will give us full admin rights in Gandi's dashboard, and allow us to renew it ourselves next time.
Here's the complication: the domain was registered by Enric through FairCoop's Gandi account to get around the .coop NIC requirements (they wanted us to first be a registered coop). He has now renewed it for one year at 71.50 EUR.
Enric has proposed that we setup a FairCoin wallet to accept membership contributions, which we then use to pay for the domain name using FairCoin (to begin with).
We could also try getting Enric to change the domain's technical and administrative contacts to one of us, so we can handle future renewals internally.