Loomio

"Pinning" Discussions

Tracey Ambrose PublicSeen by 107

There have been several cases of discussion threads on Loomio that aren't simply a one or two week thing, but need to be found and updated at random intervals, but "out of sight, out of mind" can happen around them. I was wondering about an interest in group admin's being able to "pin" a thread to the top of the group or subgroups discussion list?

This could be something like a groups policy discussion, announcement of new members etc.

Joop Kiefte (LaPingvino)

I think that the new following-system could have the potential to solve this already. Maybe check if this covers all cases?

Robert Guthrie

@joopkieftelapingvi Pinning is different again to following. Where pinning attaches the discussion to the top of your dashboard. We'd never automatically pin a discussion for you. And you would probably only have a few disucssions pinned.

Whereas you'll be following a discussion anytime you participate with it. And it could be the case that you're following a lot of discussions, even ones that have not had any activity for a long time.

Joop Kiefte (LaPingvino)

True, however there is already a way to see all followed read conversations, so pinning basically becomes a way to filter out when you follow too much. Maybe instead/with pinning there should be a kind of priority system? Because sometimes a thread is important, but can take such a long time that having it pinned works contrary to what you want the pinning to do? Maybe have pinning split in following, priority and show-when? or is that too complicated/unnecessary?

Robert Guthrie

I think the essence of pinning is that it is very simple. Pin something you need to come back to shortly, for whatever reason, unpin when you're done.

Alanna Irving

There are two features here, for two different users:

  • users want to pin something to the top of their dashboard. this only affects their individual view. personally i think it makes sense to use starring for this, and have it be another filter alongside 'unread' and 'following'

  • coordinators want to pin discussions to the top of a group page. this affects every member of the group. this is like 'stickying' a thread in a traditional discussion forum, and it's a basic feature any moderator will appreciate.

Robert Guthrie

Beautiful clarity Alanna! Thank you.

So stars are personal, on the dashboard. Pins are shared, and on the group
page.

Tracey Ambrose

It's the later of @alanna's points that I was wanting