Loomio

Uploading a video or audio file

ultraviolet PublicSeen by 112

Hi everyone! I only heard about Loomio today so I'm totally new. Apologies if this idea/proposal is already a feature on Loomio.

It's been said before that face to face meetings give an unfair advantage to those who are the most confident at public speaking or who express themselves best through speaking.

A format like Loomio replaces this by giving the unfair advantage to those who best express themselves through writing.

A lot of people struggle to express their ideas through the written word, and find they're better at oral communication. To help undo this imbalance, I think that Loomio should allow video and audio files to be uploaded in place of a text comment - both in the discussion threads, and also right here in the discussion context section (where these words you're reading are appearing).

People could obviously still write text comments, and that would probably be the format most people use. But audio and video files should be an available option.

Loomio should allow uploading a video or audio file as an option in place of a text comment

proposal by ultraviolet Closed Sun 23 Mar 2014 3:44AM

Full description is in the context section at the top of the page.

Results

ultraviolet
Agree

This will allow people who aren't good at written communication to have an alternative way of expressing their views and ideas. It removes the unfair advantage from those who are better writers.

Loomio should allow uploading a video or audio file as an option in place of a text comment

proposal by ultraviolet Closed Sun 23 Mar 2014 3:44AM

Full description is in the context section at the top of the page.

Results

ultraviolet
Agree

This will allow people who aren't good at written communication to have an alternative way of expressing their views and ideas. It removes the unfair advantage from those who are better writers.

Alanna Irving

Hi @ultraviolet - see the little paperclip symbol below the comment box? You can use that to attach any kind of file you like :)

Alanna Irving

You can also comment in the form of a link to external content, such as a youtube video

ultraviolet

Oh damn! Well that's awesome, I'm glad to hear it! I guess I'll delete this proposal!

ultraviolet

Hm, can't seem to figure out how to delete this. Can one of the admin do it for me? Thanks :)

Alanna Irving

@ultraviolet is not the first person who missed the paperclip icon and the attachment feature because it's not very obvious. How can we make it easier to find for new users?

mix irving

good question.

at the moment there is a limit to the size of the file you can directly attach. I think it's 50 or 100 MB. but you can definitely link a youtube video

I would like to have a feature similar to facebook/ gmail where if you have pasted a link to some image or video in, then loomio detects the external thing and offers a small thumbnail of it.

in the case of youtube you would also be able to click on the video and have it play on the same page

ultraviolet

Alanna Krause

Yes, you raise an important point. It should be made more obvious to new users.

Right now the text box reads "Say something" until you click on it to write your text.

This can be changed to something like "Say something by typing or use the paperclip icon to upload an audio/video file"

Or perhaps "Type something or upload an audio/video file using the paperclip icon"

mix irving

I like your suggestion

ultraviolet

Also, I just checked and saw that when a new topic/discussion is started, there's no paperclip option to attach a file. So that should be added in.

Alina Siegfried

Thanks for your comments @ultraviolet These are good suggestions to improve the accessibilty of Loomio to all people.

Just to let you know, you can also tag people by typing an @ symbol and then starting to type their name - Loomio will guess after a few letters who you are trying to tag. That way the person who you want to specifically mention will get an email and know that you're aiming a comment towards them :)

Aaron Thornton

Video does raise an encoding issue, that can be an extra service cost. Just saying. Transloadit.com

Deleted account

I would so like to see Loomio have a button which you click which activates the camera on your device and records a video, which then uploads on to the discussion page. It would be great in terms of getting people who don't read or write well involved in group decision making.

Deleted account

I definitely think that a thumbnail/ watch video in the same window is a great idea but comment videos might get a bit out of hand?

Alanna Irving

@christaklis I hope you don't mind but I'm moving your comment here and deleting your other thread, to keep the topic in one place.

When you start a conservation and put a video it would be great to be embed and not just the link.

Chris Taklis

yes it is ok @alanna ...

Deleted account

Yes! Embed. Is there a good secure and open-source video service?