Stop displaying a list of people who haven't participated
I would rather keep the information, but hide it under a link like "see who hasn't participated" or something. It's an important admin tool if you have a topic you need high engagement on.
@alanna, might be an easy fix to just hide the list in a div with a javascript link to display it - should be a 10 minute change.
While we're at it lets group the responses based on position: so I can easily see where all the problems lie with a given proposal.
What about making it an option when starting a discussion, or a group-level setting. At least one current user (Ramsey @ NZCoop) said it's very useful to see who hasn't weighed in so that he can bug them.
I would prefer to limit the options people can set to things that are really important - it would be worth asking Ramsey if the 'click here to see people who haven't voted' link would meet his needs as I suspect it would.
+1 for Rich's idea of of grouping responses by type - should be an easy win.
I like being able to see who hasn't weighed in. I'd like to break that group into those who have viewed but not voted and those who hadn't looked at all though.
Really like the grouping votes too.
I agree that feedback indicates the whole list is important to people who are convening a discussion and want to check who to follow up. We could seek feedback from Ramsey if he would find it a pain to click into that list? But I don't think I really understand the reason for taking the names off to be honest
For me it's about reducing the amount of space the proposal takes up - if people want to get the list of names who haven't participated wouldn't a 'members yet to participate' link be a preferable option?
It's probably something that should be treated separately, but if we allow anonymous voting at some point (which I think we should for proposals that concern a specific person - and probably other situations), the whole list should be hidden…
wow, anonymous vote, that is awhole other story, lets save that to talk about another time!
+1 on grouping the responses. As I mentioned on the 'edit proposal' thread, I would also suggest ordering the vote comments under the pie chart from, starting with 'block, then 'no', then 'abstain', then 'yes'. This emphasizes the nature of any dissensus around the issue which needs to be dealt with in order to find full consensus.
I agree that it's important to separate 'haven't taken a position' from 'haven't looked at the proposal'. What do people think about automatically changing the position to abstain after the first time the user has looked at the discussion after the proposal is created? I do wonder if this is best resolved culturally by encouraging people to click abstain once they have looked, unless or until they take another position?
I've had exactly the same thoughts Strypey. In the last couple weeks we've been learning about rigorous user-centric design processes, which essentially means we are prioritising features as determined by the bulk of user feedback.
These two suggestions haven't come up yet, so they're on the back burner while we sort the 'core functionality' stuff that has come up, but I'm sure they're not far off.
I don't get much value from a list of names of people who haven't participated in a proposal and suggest we get rid of it.