Loomio

Workshop about Active Transparency

Alanna Irving PublicSeen by 47

I would like us to get together sometime soon and talk about Transparency to fulfill our commitment to this core value, bot internally and externally.

>Transparency
>Our community of users and contributors must be confident that we’re doing what we say we are.

>We’re committed to remaining open and accountable to our community by sharing information about our internal decision-making, social impact results and finances. Communicating this information effectively is an ongoing challenge that we look forward to undertaking with our community.

This is informed by the conversation Nicholas started about what should be private, thinking about how to share what the metrics team, the business team, and the code team are up to, making public our features and organizational roadmap accesible, and being transparent about our finances and legal structure.

When might this take place? Who should be in the workshop?

Mitar

Do you have privacy policy? What about data collected through example Google Analytics and other similar things you can collect?

In general in open access view is not enough to say that you will share. Because this can mean sharing on demand. Much better is if you proactively share. If governments would proactively share public data... and not just on requests...

Richard D. Bartlett

The primary roadblock to more transparency right now is just resourcing. Personally it is high on my list of priorities. My immediate focus is on internal communications: gathering the information that contributors need to be empowered to participate fully. Most of this material will be made public (with exceptions where it would compromise individuals' privacy).

That will make it transparent, but not necessarily accessible. To be accessible, it needs to be edited, contextualised and presented in a digestible format.

For an example, you can see the very beginnings of that work in the code side of things: @johnirving and I spent some time on the wiki this past week. It turned out be a huge amount of work just to document one small part of the project.

In particular, I'm looking forward to finding some time to do an update from the co-op, to introduce ourselves to the community and present the work we've done around legal and financial structures. This information is currently lying around the place but I wouldn't call it 'transparent' until it is presented in a format that the average person can engage with.

Benjamin Knight

I'd say accessibility of information is a prerequisite for genuine transparency - and absolutely agree it's high priority!

I'm feeling good that we're actively working on this already (though we still have a long way to go), and I'm confident that over the next few months we can develop an accessible framework for publicly delivering clear information as a matter of course

mix irving

I've used the wiki we coauthored twice already, once to introduce our process to a grow programmer, once to remind myself.
This sort of usefulness might transfer to organisational documentation as well....

Nicolas Wormser

@alannakrause

"You own your data. If you ever want to stop using Loomio, you will be able to download your data - ask our team and we will extract the data for you."

Does this mean I have to request to close my Loomio account to access this information? Facebook does better in that regard… Sarcastically I would say "Wow, these guys are really cool, they let me get a copy of all the stuff I didn't mean to share when I want to leave. And even better, this will stay on the website forever, even once I'm gone!".

So I think we should allow to extract all the contributions we've made anytime, so does Facebook, Google+ and others… Also, when closing an account, we should be very specific about what will be deleted and what data would stay here by default. Maybe we should even facilitate how one might browse all the contributions they've made and help them to remove all the things they don't want to leave behind them.

Other interesting point: If I "own" my data I should be able to do whatever I like with it. This mean I should be able to completely remove it from any archive, make sure it's not being used by any algorithm (statistics etc…) and it's not retrievable by Loomio in any way. Stating the user "owns" their data is a really strong statement that should be backed with all the details of what this ownership means in terms of control over their data.

Also I think this verb (to own) also has very specific implications in law, that we want to make sure we consider and abide by if we don't want to face unexpected repercussions…

mix irving

If removing your comments from a thread is to destructive, is it acceptable to scramble a users name and avatar? This might be a reversible process by giving them a unscramble key.
I think individual right to delete is too much

Alanna Irving

Are people up for a workshop on this soon? This week? According to people's calendar's Thursday morning looks clear.

Not sure who needs to be there, but in the interest of opening a wider invitation tagging some people in....

@benjaminknight @vivienmaidaborn @simontegg @robertguthrie @richarddbartlett @jonlemmon @matthewbartlett @johnirving @hannahsalmon

Benjamin Knight

Great points @nicolaswormser - I'd echo @alannakrause's comment about that draft privacy policy being a work in progress - kind of an aspirational document in many ways right now, but it's very much what we're working towards in the coming months. This is why we're not yet linking to it from the site or making it very public (the irony!).

Is working on data privacy potentially something that you'd be interested in as part of your internship Nicolas? Sounds like you have an understanding of legalities that would be really useful!

@alannakrause , thanks heaps for getting the ball rolling on the active transparency workshop - Thursday morning is likely to be pretty hectic for me and @vivienmaidaborn, so I was wondering if Friday afternoon might work. Would 2pm or 3pm suit people? Alternatively, a time early next week?

Alanna Irving

Friday afternoon works for me

Richard D. Bartlett

I don't have a clear idea of where this workshops fits in relation to our other priorities.

Alanna Irving

@richarddbartlett some recent ways it's come up have been:

  • we're going to need to provide good information to our new board
  • we want to sort out our community groups and their privacy settings (as nicholas started a thread on)
  • we are going to start accepting large amounts of money soon and we'll need to make it transparent how we're using it
  • we need better ways of communicating what happens in the co-op members group (in person and on loomio) back to the wider group
  • the metrics team is coming out with some sweet data and graphs. do we publish them?

There are lots more areas where it's relavant I am sure...

Benjamin Knight

It feels like this has lots of overlap with our online organisational structure, which we need to set up properly before we can really start building up the Loomio Community as an accessible place for information relevant to the whole community

Alanna Irving

Sounds like things are a bit pressed this week so let's aim for next week instead. I'll send everyone a calendar invite for Wednesday afternoon. I don't think everyone needs to be there, so self-select in if you're interested in the topic.

Alanna Irving

This has been scheduled for 2pm 20/3

Alanna Irving

Reminder this is today at 2

Alanna Irving

@richarddbartlett do you have notes?

Alanna Irving

Hahahah pretty ironic if we don't do a good job reporting on our transparency workshop!

Richard D. Bartlett

I didn't really take good notes sorry. Main outtake for me was that we've got a clearer idea about how to use the Loomio Community subgroups, something like this:

  • Contributors - daily standup reports, all hands meeting reports, internal comms, etc
  • Contributors (private) - internal comms e.g. about clients
  • Co-op Members (private) - decisions about co-op membership, board membership, etc
  • Code - technical discussions
  • Code (private) - security related info
  • Features - accessible discussions, one for each feature
  • Help - support community

This list is likely to expand to include, e.g.,

  • Loomio en Español
  • Advisors
  • Board

As a default, everything is private, and decisions are made in the widest possible group. Occasionally there will information or decisions that are not appropriate to share with the widest circle, so they will be held in private areas. Private groups will regularly report back to the public groups to stay accountable.

All transparency efforts are of course dependent on resourcing - personally I'm committed to putting as much energy as I can into reporting but I'm pretty stretched right now.

Alanna Irving

Other outcomes: we will be shutting down yammer and moving completely on Loomio, and we're going to start doing a monthly Loomio news report as soon as preference shares is done.

Richard D. Bartlett

Haha oops I said by default everything is private, but of course I meant everything is public :P