Loomio
Wed 24 Jan 2024 4:48PM

Proposal to participate in EU research project

ES Ed Summers @edsu Public Seen by 259

I was approached by Lozana Rossenova (TIB Hannover) about whether I would be willing to participate in a research project with Wikimedia Europe looking at peer production and democratic governance.

Lozana has an excellent track record of working productively with the Wikipedia and Wikidata communities. Her proposal involves a team at Rotterdam who support the post.lurk.org Mastodon instance. They are interested in having SocialCoop as a case study, to help develop recommendations for practices, tools and policies that foster citizen engagement in democratic governed, online communities.

Below is some summary information about the goals of the project and the type of commitment they are looking for from one or more SocialCoop members.

Before putting in a proposal for people to vote on, I thought it would be useful to start a conversation here to see what people thought about one or more SocialCoop members participating (minimally me).


Aspects we will explore

The idea of the case studies is to present a series of best practices:

1. We will look in particular at issues related to governance (in particular decision-making and your approach in community-governance), interoperability, attribution/sources (how you manage your content and how people and content is attributed), engagement (how you foster participation) and technology (which technology do you use, which media and tools, which methods).

2. We would like to know from you which difficulties, challenges, obstacles you encounter in your practice (e.g. which laws and regulatory frameworks affect you such as privacy, copyright, removal of illegal content) and how those challenges impacted your choices (i.e. if you had to design your platforms in a certain way for content moderation systems, if you had to adapt your terms of service, if you had to plan procedural mechanisms for removing content, other choices related to copyright, privacy settings and policies….).

3. We would like to discuss with you some new prototypes and tools we plan to develop within the project, related in particular to the fediverse, the Wikimedia ecosystem and decision-making tools like Loomio: if you think they can be useful and which other tools can support your work.  

Commitment requested 

We ask groups and institutions involved as case studies to:

1. Contribute to the research with an interview.

2. Review the research related to their practice to provide feedback.

3. Providing if possible some content under the CC BY-SA license which will be uploaded also on Wikimedia Commons (i.e. images of your institutions, screenshot of tools/websites, images of initiatives…) or allowing us to produce some images under the CC BY-SA license if possible.

4. If possible participating in a prototype workshop to discuss tools and methods which can be useful to support your work. 

5. If possible participating in a focus group to discuss policy recommendations for the EU and member states.

6. Receiving the project outputs and be updated about the project, to have the possibility to provide feedback.

BV

Brian Vaughan Wed 24 Jan 2024 5:12PM

As I see it, participating in this project would be a good way to advance our mission, "placing ever more of our online social lives under good cooperative governance".

ES

Ed Summers @edsu Fri 26 Jan 2024 8:28AM

@Brian Vaughan yes, the goal of the research project seemed well aligned with the goals of SocialCoop. Thanks for your feedback!

KT

Kathe TB Wed 24 Jan 2024 5:16PM

Normally I'm on the other side of these things as the researcher (although this is not my field). Do they have an IRB plan?

This is a pretty good engagement plan sketch. It looks like they are using a co-production model which is exciting. The thing to watch for here is time commitments as a community partner. But otherwise I'm really interested in engaging with this project!

ES

Ed Summers @edsu Fri 26 Jan 2024 8:26AM

@Kathe TB I was wondering about IRB as well -- thanks for raising that here. I'm glad you are interested in participating!

P

Paul030 Wed 24 Jan 2024 6:09PM

I know colleagues of Rossenova and experienced TIB Hannover to really be one of the leading institutions in Europe pushing for Open Science, peer-production and collaboration beyond silos. Therefore I'd consider this a great opportunity to get social.coop's capabilities analyzed from the outside while being able to spread our approach and synergize with other actors in the field of science and public policy. I can't say anything about our capacities, though - the proposal will certainly require individual efforts as well as reconcilement among us.

D

Dynamic Wed 24 Jan 2024 6:49PM

I'm amenable to the idea of social.coop participating. I'm curious about how we as a democratically run institution would participate in interviews, etc. Who represents us? How is that decided?

ES

Ed Summers @edsu Fri 26 Jan 2024 7:50AM

@Dynamic yes, this is a concern I had too. I was thinking that if the Proposal passes then people who are interested could volunteer to participate. If too many people are interested in volunteering (for the project organizers) then we might need to do some follow up voting?

DT

Daniel Thomas Thu 25 Jan 2024 9:33AM

Yes this all looks good and others have already made my points better than me.

NS

Nathan Schneider Thu 25 Jan 2024 9:44PM

Sounds great to me!

ES

Poll Created Fri 26 Jan 2024 9:24AM

Participate in EU Research Project Closed Thu 1 Feb 2024 8:00AM

Outcome
by Ed Summers @edsu Sat 3 Feb 2024 6:16PM

There was broad support for this proposal. Individuals who would like to participate in the research project are encouraged to reach out to Lozana Rossenova at [email protected]. This Loomio thread will be used to share any additional materials as they become available.

One issue that came up in the vote discussion is that the passing of this proposal should not set a precedent for future research projects that study social.coop. Individuals can always choose to participate in studies of the co-op, and researchers are not required to get co-op approval for studying social.coop.

Lozana Rossenova (TIB Hannover) is looking for SocialCoop volunteers to participate in an EU research project looking at understanding peer production and democratic governance. The goal of the project is to develop EU policy recommendations to ensure digital spaces have a positive impact on democratic life and limit potential threats to democracy.

If accepted this proposal will:

  1. Allow SocialCoop members to volunteer to represent SocialCoop in the project based upon their own individual time commitments. Details about how to volunteer will be shared here in Loomio.

  2. In the event that there are too many volunteers a vote will be held to determine who should represent SocialCoop in the project.

  3. Any compensation that is provided by the project will be sent to the SocialCoop OpenCollective account.

  4. Any outputs generated from the research will be shared by volunteers as links in this Loomio thread where they can be commented on by others. (added 2024-01-31)

The details are still in development but volunteers will likely participate in interviews, provide Open Access documentation related to SocialCoop, review research and other written outputs, and participate in focus groups and workshops.

Project partners include Wikimedia Europe, Hogeschool Rotterdam, Uniwersytet SWPS, Universiteit Van Amsterdam, Fundacio EURECAT, Technische Informationsbibliothek, Scuola Universitaria professionale della Svizzera Italiana, and Martel Innovate BV.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 100.0% 41 BH NS ZS K BS SJK AR TR EM N BMH C ED ES EC C RJ BV J RD
Disagree 0.0% 0  
Abstain 0.0% 0  
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 357 RG DS KF ST DM JD CZ LF WO JC JNM F J BM SH KT C DH G AM

41 of 398 people have participated (10%)

Load More