Loomio

User data security and privacy

Jon Lemmon PublicSeen by 84

Here it comes!!! User data security and privacy is obviously going to become a massive concern for us as we scale.

Up until now, it hasn't been a big issue. However, now with the metrics crew getting started, there are some things for us to consider.

Right now, the metrics crew is using a mixture of data exported from Google Analytics (pretty much anonymous data not tied to specific users) in conjunction with data exported from the Loomio database.

The data we're exporting from Loomio at the moment is also fairly anonymous. We're exporting what events happen on Loomio. So thinks like, "User 74 commented on discussion 163". We aren't exporting the contents of the comments or the name of the user, so, at the moment, it seems like pretty trivial information that we're looking at. It's also just being looked at by a small analytics team (who then condense the information down into graphs for us to look at).

However, going forward I think we're going to need some stricter policies in terms of how we handle our data. One idea I have is: all of the data that we make available to ourselves, we make available to the public (with a few exceptions for information that we'll need to know from an administrative perspective, like the number of members/discussions a private group has). This could be a good way of making sure that we're not looking at data that the public wouldn't feel comfortable about us looking at.

Thoughts?

Alanna Irving

We need a privacy policy written up...

Paul Smith

What Alanna said, a privacy policy is essential for people to trust the application and Loomio team. I really liked Trello's privacy/data policy ( https://trello.com/privacy ).

My thoughts privacy wise, would be to:

  • Have an option for users and groups to opt out of metrics with a small disclaimer saying it's just to improve the app and a link to the privacy policy.

  • Make sure the collected data is anonymous, it's pretty easy to just md5 or sha sum the ID's to obscure them enough.

  • Give users a button to export their personal data, it's a nice to have feature that ensures users feel like they own their data.

I wouldn't want to make all the data we use public because I think it would discourage some users and make more people want to opt out, but it would be cool to list exactly what it is we're basing metrics off and why.

Alanna Irving

To me this isn't just about collecting metrics, either, it's about Loomio promising not to give personal data to 3rd parties, not to make public groups that started as private without permission, etc.

Matthew Bartlett

@Paul, what about dropping that first option (opt out of metrics), and advise people concerned about that to host their own edition of Loomio?

Jon Lemmon

Hey all,

The new email service that our severs are using require a privacy policy before we can start using the feature that will increase our email deliverability rates (and stop our emails from going to spam).

So basically, I think we should quickly sort out a temporary privacy policy that we can use just to sort out the stuff with this email service, and then work further to fine-tune the policy to our particular needs.

Maybe we should have a quick jam on this at the upcoming Enspiral retreat and try to get something temporary sorted out?

Benjamin Knight

Modeling something on Bucky's privacy policy sounds great to me

Jon Lemmon

Sweet. Let's try to bang this out tomorrow at the office and then put up a proposal.

Jon Lemmon

Hey guys... just a friendly reminder: our Loomio notification emails will keep getting filtered out and going to spam until we've sorted this out.

Matthew Bartlett

Hey @Jon — was that message posted to the right discussion?

Jon Lemmon

Yes. See the comment I posted a few comments back. Our email service requires a link to our privacy policy before we can start using the features to "white-label" our emails sent from the site, which will significantly increase our deliverability (i.e. decrease the chances of our email going to the spam box).

Benjamin Knight

I'll try to find time to make some progress on this in the next few days. Is anyone keen to collaborate on it?

Jon Lemmon

I'd be happy to. We'll probably want some people from the metrics team as well so that they still feel confident that we'll be collecting the data they need to do their work.

Simon Tegg

I'll be in Monday through to 3pm. Meetings 9.30 -10.30 and 11-12

Benjamin Knight

Sorry Simon, missed this til now - would Thursday at 9am work for you?