Loomio

User email addresses are publicly visible at the moment

Jon Lemmon PublicSeen by 32

Jon Lemmon

Hey all, we've got a slight issue. The Loomio Alpha Users group currently is displaying publicly a lot of people's email addresses.

http://loom.io/groups/31

How should we deal with this?

Basically, the reason so many people's emails are showing up is because they've been invited to Loomio but haven't actually logged in and specified a name for themselves.

It seems like a bit of a privacy issue though. One thing we could do is hide any email addresses from the group page that have an "@" character in them for now. It's pretty hacky though, and it could lead to confusion (e.g. "I added this person to the group, but they aren't showing up on the group members list")

Does anyone have any thoughts about this?

Joshua Vial

Hide all users who haven't accepted and just say x users are invited

Joshua Vial

I'd actually disable the member list on the alpha group - maybe a flag on the group model for displaying user list or some other mechanism. The list doesn't add anything to the group and is just noise

Jon Lemmon

Sounds good. I can just make it a flag in the database, but not make it a visible option on creating groups (since most users probably won't need this functionality right now).

Richard D. Bartlett

I agree with Jon. I wonder if this needs to become a proposal that we all can weigh in on, or if Jon is empowered by the group to just go ahead and implement his own solution.

Alanna Irving

Jon, please create a proposal if you think your solution is ready

Jon Lemmon

I sort of feel like creating a proposal might be redundant since it's already immediately clear what the decision is going to be?

I'm just aware that there's a fine line to walk between having distinct process and making things too formal/bureaucratic.

Joshua Vial

Agree with jon, I'd just go and do it - highlights the need to be able to mark a discussion as closed though