Loomio

Remove the 'Introducing Loomio' video

Matthew Bartlett PublicSeen by 75

Remove the 'Introducing Loomio' video

proposal by Matthew Bartlett Closed Thu 13 Sep 2012 9:32AM

... from http://loomio.org/

I just re-watched it. It's really brilliant, concise & inspiring, but it says:
"Loomio is a free open-source web application..."
"Loomio is free open-source software that anyone can use."
"...so we can give it away to the world."

I want to send potential paying customers to loomio.org so they can learn about the software, but I feel the video leaves no room for the concept of 'paying customers'.

Sorry to be a dripping tap about this, but I think it's important.

Results

Benjamin Knight
Disagree

I think the video is still a good representation of the project - wouldn't want to remove unless it was being replaced with something substantially better

Joshua Vial
Agree

I agree with matthew and think we need to either re-edit the current video or pull it until we get something better up.

Paul Smith
Disagree

I think the lines that are an issue should be shouted from rooftops.

Alanna Irving
Disagree

I think we do need to make a new video - let's see what comes out of the pitching workshop this week! But until then we should keep what we have.

Aaron Thornton
Abstain

Edit it to make it fit. Less work than starting from scratch. This is a practical solution considering our current sprint phase.

Varun Adibhatla
Disagree

I strongly believe that we need to keep the "public" version free and present it accordingly. I also strongly believe that paying customers (at this stage of development) should be catered to on a case-by-case basis and offered a bespoke service.

Damian Sligo-Green
Disagree

I don't think removing the video until there is a clearer division between Loomio as a free product and Loomio as a pay-for-service has been established.

Remove the 'Introducing Loomio' video

proposal by Matthew Bartlett Closed Thu 13 Sep 2012 9:32AM

... from http://loomio.org/

I just re-watched it. It's really brilliant, concise & inspiring, but it says:
"Loomio is a free open-source web application..."
"Loomio is free open-source software that anyone can use."
"...so we can give it away to the world."

I want to send potential paying customers to loomio.org so they can learn about the software, but I feel the video leaves no room for the concept of 'paying customers'.

Sorry to be a dripping tap about this, but I think it's important.

Results

Benjamin Knight
Disagree

I think the video is still a good representation of the project - wouldn't want to remove unless it was being replaced with something substantially better

Joshua Vial
Agree

I agree with matthew and think we need to either re-edit the current video or pull it until we get something better up.

Paul Smith
Disagree

I think the lines that are an issue should be shouted from rooftops.

Alanna Irving
Disagree

I think we do need to make a new video - let's see what comes out of the pitching workshop this week! But until then we should keep what we have.

Aaron Thornton
Abstain

Edit it to make it fit. Less work than starting from scratch. This is a practical solution considering our current sprint phase.

Varun Adibhatla
Disagree

I strongly believe that we need to keep the "public" version free and present it accordingly. I also strongly believe that paying customers (at this stage of development) should be catered to on a case-by-case basis and offered a bespoke service.

Damian Sligo-Green
Disagree

I don't think removing the video until there is a clearer division between Loomio as a free product and Loomio as a pay-for-service has been established.

Matthew Bartlett

Easy replacements could be the screenshot from the How It Works page, plus a link to Ben's presentation.

Richard D. Bartlett

Problem: there's not a place you can send potential paying clients.

Solution: develop comms specifically for a paying audience.

The reason this solution hasn't been implemented yet is because it's really hard and we're figuring it out. It is going to be a very delicate job to keep the appropriate level of separation between the open source project and the sales. We haven't figured out what the separation is going to look like yet so we haven't done any comms around it. We tentatively scheduling this work to take place sometime between October 1 and the public release.

I fundamentally disagree with your suggested solution or removing the video, or that we remove 'free' from our messaging. It is free. It is always going to be free as in speech and I imagine for the majority of our users, free as in beer.

We chose those words with much thought and much deliberation.

I agree we can do better but removal doesn't feel like a forwards step.

Benjamin Knight

I think at worst the wording in the video is ambiguous, but I don't think it's misleading - and the ambiguity can easily be cleared up with some more content on the website explaining the social enterprise model. Something explicit on the website about what type of 'free' we're talking about could help - just needs a bit more context

Paul Smith

I don't see how AGPL licensed software could be considered anything but free...

Sure if you want the premium service on the loomio servers with all the bells in whistles it'll cost, but that's the case with almost all free software (even the advert driven stuff).

I love this intro video, if it was replaced with a better one that's cool but loomio is free, it is open source and you are giving it away to the world.

The FSF does actually recommend against using the words "free" and "giving away" but only because it puts emphasis on price and free is much more than that.

GPL slogan: "Free as in Freedom" (It's stickered on my PC case).

Aaron Thornton

Some simple edits can remove ambiguity of messaging. Agreed the code is free, but the product is not. We are trying to spread this virally and help the community sector thrive in doing so, but we also are trying to implement a business model to support the project which involves charging for this product. I think the words 'free open source' sits ok. But we could do well to loose the 'give it away to the world'.

Benjamin Knight

I'm all in favour of changing the script a bit to give more accurate context to the use of 'free'

Danyl Strype

I have adopted a habit of talking about "free code" rather than just "free software". Since code isn't a product, any more than words are a product, I think the meaning is clearer.

Coming up with a new name for the hosting service (Service X - powered by Loomio!) would be one way to clear up the confusion. With CoActivate.org, Ethan made a conscious decision to give the hosted version a different name from the codebase (OpenCore).

Damian Sligo-Green

Creating the right channels for public and paying customers seems like a pretty important step in communicating the publicly available Loomio as opposed to the custom integration Loomio or 'software as a Service'. Until the right messaging and accompanying Media have been created, it seems better to have a video there as opposed to none.