Loomio Subscription set at $2.00 per person per month
Loomio Subscription business model testing begins a testing phase at $2.00 per person per month as an initial price point test in the market, and as a basis to learn from.
proposal by vivien maidaborn Closed Fri 20 Jul 2012 9:16AM
Part of our proposed business model is that we will be charging groups of over 10 people a subscription fee. Market testing we have done so far show that groups who expect to pay are as likely to pay $2.00 pp as $1, which was the other nominated amount.the subscription part of our business will be important income especially early in our growth cycle creating some very needed income while we grow the other income streams.
This proposal is a starting point we will learn from. The points we will test in the market are:-
is a subscription model the best way to go?
what else do people see as good options?.
is $2 right for everyone, or is it a more loomio supporter model?
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 5 | 42 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 4 | 33 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 3 | 25 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 889 | 99 |
I am for this from a loomio perspective - but if I put my enspiral hat on I don't know if we would be willing to pay this until loomio was able to replace yammer for us.
Seems like a reasonable place to start.
Sensible starting point
More realistically viable than 1. ie we only need half as much traffic to meet our basic needs.
I think it's the wrong model, and it'll harm growth. I don't feel like I'm enough of a stakeholder in Loomio to block, otherwise I would.
I don't think pricing structure shouldn't punish large groups in a tool that crowd sources decision making.
Plenty good points either side. What's not clear is how we account for all the options and deploy and test iteratively.
Start somewhere, get feedback and observe behavior and iterate. This seems like a good place to start given what Vivian is hearing from current users.
Start somewhere, get feedback and observe behavior and iterate. This seems like a good place to start given what Vivien is hearing from current users.
rendered uncertain by good arguments from Craig & Paul
Great to hear fresh perspectives - making me want a re-think
Iteration is the name of the game, the market needs to test and drive these decisions based on our combined best thnking
I think it's important we pick a model and start somewhere so we can begin learning and iterating. Worst case scenario is we fail to decide anything and stagnate. This is the best we've come up with so far so let's try it out.
swayed by craig and paul - agree they make good arguments but am also aware we need to get move forward with something simple soon
I think a "pay what this is worth to you" with an additional plea of "we also really need money right now!" is perhaps a better fit for the time being... And no harm in suggesting a price.
See also cards.Rimu.geek.nz for an example of an online version of a system that is used in realspace meetings at Earthsong eco-suburb.
Aside from my points on the principles for free use thread, I think that this price is too high even for non free users. Additionally, I'm not even convinced that having the payment be "per person" is a good model. Don't we want to encourage large groups?
Since the product is open source, I think that there's a danger that if you charge too much early on, someone will simply setup a "free_loomio.com" and host the software for whoever wants to use it.
Have you considered some sort of "lifetime membership" model? How about groups pay $5 per person as a one off? That means the group can have that many people forever. It's a model that only works with growth, so you'd have to change it later, but people who paid would then have a motivation to see Loomio succeed, or else they had wasted their investment.
One-off $5 charge is how metafilter.com works, and they've been around since the dawn of the internet. It is a brilliant way of keeping trolls at bay.
You make some really good points craig. I just wish you'd been here for the hours of work and research we put into this already.
I just want to say I don't think per person is a good way to charge.
Loomio is built open source, the idea that lots of people can contribute small amounts of time for massive results is in my opinion the central point of the open source model and the results speak for themselves.
Loomio is like open source decision making, if you charge per head you're putting large financial pressure on the groups that are going to benefit from lots of people contributing a small amount and small financial pressure on groups that rely heavily on a small group of decision makers.
I might be missing something here but isn't this the opposite of what loomio is trying to achieve?
I like Craig Ambrose's idea of a lifetime membership model, extending on that you could have a Group fee that the group paid to give anyone registering for that specific group access to only that group.
Could even just do something like Free and Premium accounts for users and groups, where users pay for a profile pic/banner/background colour(within reason) and Premium groups with custom banners/backgrounds etc. I like this a lot more, as it offloads the price onto each user for "look and feel" rather than the group for functionality.
In summary, I don't think pricing structure shouldn't punish large groups in a tool that crowd sources decision making.
Agree with @Richard D. Bartlett that what you start with you're going to have to test and iterate on, so this isn't a completely existential issue.
To reply to the "per head disincentivizes growth" argument, avoiding that is exactly why we decided to have a bulk rate for large groups, and I still think that is sufficient.
The other thing that played into this that I think is really important, is that early adopters for this tool are willing to pay because they believe in it and want to support it. It's not your typical cost-benefit calculation based solely on the tool's current feature set. So people will pay more than they would for something else that solves similar problems.
Given this philanthropic interest in paying for use, it might make sense to have a regular rate and a "friend of Loomio" rate that is twice as much that people can pay voluntarily if they want to see Loomio flourish.
I am aware that putting up a proposal small enough to make sense here almost renders it too simple to be an effective discussion. At best this is a good test of current thinking but not such a good way of presenting a whole case and keeping the discussion flowing to new knew point of resolution.
Yesterday Jon and I had a conversation with Keong which had a very similar feel to what Christian is saying here, which is that the subscription model may only be relevant for an initial development period. Also that along side this proposal we also need to clarify the model for large groups where they either want loomio directly on their server or a customised version. We will need to iterate prices in this model and this learning will affect the subscription rate in turn.
I really appreciate peoples input here including those not closely connected in the project because it keeps driving us to find the business model that will create growth and values alignment.
Some questions that come to mind to me from reading posts below are:
what would loomio need to do to replace Yammer for Enspiral?
if individual fees are not a values aligned system (and I dont agree they they arent) what options are there that would be considered 'aligned?'
I see Group one off fee is one model - this would certainly create good growth cashflow while we build large organisation customised deals,
what else?
It seems to me the debate around these two pricing model discussions boils down to how the question has been framed. The lack of consensus indicates a process failure to me. For a number of people, this is the first time they've engaged with the question, so these proposals are both coming a bit out of context.
For instance, charging per person, charging per month, and setting the free criteria as "less than X" members are all decisions that have been made outside of this context. They may be the right decisions, but there's unlikely to be a strong consensus in this group without a comprehensive survey of the options, actively sought from experts and organically volunteered by other members.
We're all in a process of trying to figure out how to get things done in a horizontal organisation. From my experience so far, a process that I have seen to be effective is:
1) Somebody self-selects to be a 'project lead' for a given task (Vivien has clearly taken the initiative here).
2) Project lead surveys the opinions of stakeholders, experts, and anyone that happens to be passing by.
3) Project lead synthesizes those options down into an intelligible set of options and then frames a discussion/decision like so:
a) Identify a need (we need a pricing model)
b) Present options (per head, per month, free for groups <X, lifetime membership, etc etc)
c) Make a case for one of the options (we should charge $2/head/month)
In this particular example we are completing all the steps in the process, but maybe they are a bit out of order, or the communication hasn't been up to the task. I know a lot of the options have been discussed in various meetings, but I haven't seen them coherently presented for appraisal.
So to move forward, I'd like to see a comprehensive list of options, followed by an argument for a logical place to start the iterative process. (I'm volunteering to help compiling this list).
I think the main reason we are having trouble finding consensus is lack of good information sharing about all the leg work we did to get here... Agree with Richard.
After speaking with Ben tonight I would actually suggest a different approach to pricing.
Start releasing 10 users at a time from the waiting list into loomio and ask them to pay what they think it is worth - perhaps suggest $2 per person as a starting point but leave it up to them.
Keep iterating with batches of 10 users and see how people respond to different pricing suggestions - make it clear to everyone that this is just a beta process and that we will finalise our prices before going into public beta.
@joshua the problem is that loomio users don't come as individuals, they always come as parts of groups. So do you mean 10 groups at a time?
@Joshua as I was reading this thread I was thinking the exact same thing. Why not have groups pay what they think it's worth for now?
Do we have any real need to lock down the pricing right now? Because if this is more about learning and experimentation, having every group pay what they feel comfortable with seems like possibly the best way to learn.
Oh, and thanks Vivien for putting the work in to presenting these proposals and getting a dialog going!
Hi folks,
Sorry to jump in with contrary opinions on this one and then disappear of the radar (I was off sick for a day or two there). Alanna's points about all the work taken to get to this point are well taken. I don't really consider myself to be an active member of the loomio team at the moment, so I really don't think that my consensus is needed (I'll certainly never block), and I also don't think I have particularly more experience in this are than others here.
One thing I will say is that I've had disappointingly bad results with optional payment models, such as having a "sponsoring member" category with a few token extra features and extra status with some aesthetic tweaks. People just didn't seem to do it if free was so easy.
So, despite my concerns about $2 being a bit high, I don't think Jon's "pay what you need" idea will really work.
Lots of interesting points here.
I'd be interested to see some more info/data on Craig Ambrose's findings with supporting members categories.
How you invite someone to support the project will influence whether they choose to pay. Eg/ Are you selling the app to a consumer or Inviting someone to be a part of the community?
Realising time and resources is a constraint I like Joshua Vile's idea of "pay what you think it's worth", there's room to combine it with bringing users online and contact people that have registered interest offering guaranteed early access to groups (or users) who can contribute $x (per month?) as a first phase in funding.
Requires little development; I still like the idea of a star next to username for early supporters/contributors, just a little admin work. If it doesn't work out you can keep bringing users online how you were previously intending to and proceed with any other payment model, low risk/cost.
Some thoughts that might be worth considering after the initial funding phase:
Could supporters get access to a loomio group that shapes how loomio will work? I admit this could be a can of worms but I like the idea in principle as it shifts a sense of ownership onto the loomio community.
How many invites/groups does a user who supports the project get? Is there room for say a few free invites for a Paid user with limitations on free accounts? (Demonoid torrent tracker uses this model)
What a fantastic dynamic conversation, rich both for being so on topic but also for the learning in the process. Thank you everyone for commenting and also keeping coming back to it.
The business development team learnt heaps from this:-
We are doing too much work without keeping everyone up to date on it,
We can start conversations way before we have a proposal
Feeding Loomio user/ supporter comments into the validation process is really important.
We have scheduled a meeting next Tuesday with the wider Loomio group to really explore the craft of working with collective decision making a whole lot more and will feedback our learnings and outcomes from that meeting.
Regarding the business development model it is clear we are not clear yet, and that validating several approaches and bringing back findings to the whole group before narrowing down will be important. That is what we are going to do. So watch this space
Kia Kaha Vivien
Thanks for the update Vivien
@Paul re: "Could supporters get access to a loomio group that shapes how loomio will work?"
I want all users to shape the development of the tool, confining that opportunity to paying customers only is problematic for me. Part of this will be done explicitly through UX focus groups, but ideally it will be implicitly baked into the culture of the tool too.
I've attempted to summarise the options generated by this thread in the following doc. Jump in and add things if you like, or rearrange to make it more digestible.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1z2niu8MWFMHdGguZxZYO-mkQNBPX5iQau-sTKz8EOf4/edit#
@Craig, it's a shame you haven't reached your expectations with 'pay what it's worth' models. However, there's heaps of evidence these can and do work. Consider the support Loom.io got on PledgeMe. Check out the results of the Humble Indie Bundles (now up to version 5), and many examples in The Power of Open:
http://thepowerofopen.org/
I strongly believe that gift-based models (where cash can be one form of gift) are the way of the future, as advocated by Charles Eisenstein in 'Sacred Economics'. It certainly fits the values that motivated the development of Loom.io, as I understand them.
#off-topic I watched a youtube video with Charles Eisenstein where he mentions some of the ideas from that book. Seems like an amazing guy! Loved everything he had to say.
If Loomio could operate using some sort of gift economy and be a shining example of a solid case where it actually works, that would make me really really happy.
It's important to bear in mind the different phases of the business will rely on different business models. Right now, we need an income if we want to keep running the way we are. In the future, once we've gone through a few iterations and have some stability (from a huge generous user community that share the vision and/or some grants), I'd feel a lot more comfortable about making the business model more progressive.
In saying that, gift economy is the future :)
I agree with Rich, sustainability before idealism (for now).
Putting idealism aside is precisely why we now have a crisis of sustainability. My point was that gift models can and do bring in sufficient cash for financial sustainability without erecting paywalls and tollgates between the tool and the people who need it. Keep it mind also that you are in an early alpha, and that every user is currently also an unpaid tester. Imposing a fixed fee at this point means they pay twice, first with their tolerance of an unstable and functionally-limited system and their feedback to developers, than again in cash.
Hey @Strypey - absolutely agree that sidelining idealism is a major cause of many things in the world being pretty messed up right now.
This might not be clear in the previous proposal, but our thoughts with the subscription testing aren't about something that will apply to individual users in a blanket way - at the moment we're looking at testing out pricing models with particular organisations who have a budget. Specifically, we're trying to decide what to tell the Wellington Regional Council we think is a fair price for them to pay at the end of their trial period. Their trial has been under the understanding that we'll work with them to figure out a fair way of pricing.
The goal is to figure out an equitable solution that allows the Loomio project to be resource self-sufficient in the long term - we're looking for a way of distributing resources from organisations with a budget through Loomio so we can subsidise the free use of organisations that are doing great stuff in their communities but have no budget.
So the pressure we're facing is that we need some kind of starting point that we can iterate from - the intention is for this iterative process to stay really flexible, and accountable to users. We want to develop the business model with input from users, figuring out a solution that equitably serves the interests of as broad a community as possible, with a bottom line of doing as we can to aid a transformative social change towards genuine participation in decision-making at every level.
The dangers of not having enough context at the beginning of a discussion! This thread in particular has been a really valuable learning experience about the importance of facilitation and providing sufficient context/framing at the beginning of a discussion.
Please continue to keep us on our toes!
I'm still entirely stuck on my idealism here.
vivien's post on yammer this morning was I thought a really really good approach:
"A great idea that came out of the meeting this morning... this all is backed by an algorithm that sets up the price model for them.
I was excite by the idea of leaving the choice with the user." (https://www.yammer.com/loomio/#/Threads/show?threadId=196126632)
+1 for @Benjamin Knight's "The goal is to figure out an equitable solution that allows the Loomio project to be resource self-sufficient in the long term."
Sidenote: I was thinking about how payment is bundled into the code itself; longterm: in the open source side of things.
It would be really cool if when paying you could choose how your payment was distributed using the Humble Bundle model. Eg/ Option to split a subscription or payment between Loomio (Org) and Loomio (install). This makes almost no sense within the Loomio org itself, but if I was to set up an install on another server letting the users choose to distribute their payments back to the loomio project as well as pay for hosting etc seems like a solid model.
I think some of commentary here is really relevant to Loomio:
http://charleseisenstein.net/for-facebook-a-modest-proposal/
@Ben thanks for the context power-up. I think it's really important to get away from the mentality of software as product. Obviously you've got to cover your external costs, and you want to pay everyone that's putting in hours, but you don't have to have a fixed payment model for all paying user groups. I guess you want to have a benchmark, but it would have more sense to me to negotiate with each user groups as they come on board, and make the price appropriate to their means.
BTW I suggest using the Timebanks in the interim. You can let groups using Loomio for free pay in time credits, then pay developers and other workers time credits for their local time bank:
http://timebank.org.nz/
Man, we should get Charles Eisenstein on the team!
@Jon
Sorry bro, you'll have to put up with me ;)
What are you asking people to pay for here? I guess it's hosting, since people can set up their own instance of Loomio, right? I question the wisdom of even thinking about charging people who are essentially doing unpaid product testing for you at this early stage.
I think Joshua's comment is very relevant. At the moment, all I see is a FB-style comment thread, and a straw poll. Compare this to the Community Weaver software that the TimeBanks are using, a mature, well-supported codebase that they are hosting for $1/member/month.