Loomio

Feature Request: When you put a motion forward, you agree

Craig Lambie PublicSeen by 57

When you put a motion / decision forward for a group to decide upon, you obviously agree.
It is an unnecessary step for the motion author to have to agree to it to. Also an unnecessary activity in the feed...?

Remove the need for the author to "agree" to a proposal

proposal by Craig Lambie Closed Fri 18 Oct 2013 1:25AM

Outcome
by Craig Lambie

Wow, thanks for the comments..... I personally don't ever not agree with what I write, but I rarely write something for someone else.

Results

Alanna Irving
Disagree

I have voted on my own proposals many times. Also I have raised proposals I don't want to share my opinion on right away.

Tracey Ambrose
Disagree

I often put up proposals on behalf of others or the group which I don't necessarily agree with.

Vote removed

Raphaël Jadot
Disagree

The one making a proposal doesn't necessary want to agree or even participate to it.

goob
Disagree

Not so. There have been a number of proposals in our community which have been started to take a straw poll on an proposition when the person who started the proposal didn't agree with the proposition. There's no need to limit ourselves in this way.

Chris Taklis
Disagree

no, you can also be the creator but you don't agree with the proposal.

Phill Coxon
Disagree

I have created proposals that I don't vote on immediately because I don't want to introduce bias before participants have a chance to engage. I have also created proposals on behalf of a group that I disagreed with and voted no on.

Ricardo Araújo
Disagree

I disagre because it depends how proposals are made.
"Minors can drink alcool"-My intent is to disagre
"Minors are prohibited to drink alccol"-My intent is to agree

It's the same proposal but said diferent ways, so...Better to leave it how it is

max noble
Block

Im blocking because everyone else did...peer pressure

Richard Grevers

Not necessarily. In the group I'm part of, I'm outside the actual decision making body, and I often create proposals which are phrased to not show my opinion on them (and then do not state a position) in order to get a true sense of how the others react.

Anna Guenther

I sense a screen shot moment.

Alanna Irving

Hey @craiglambie just wanted to say that even though most people voted "no" I am glad you raised this proposal and I think it was really valuable! We've highlighted some of the interesting ways people use Loomio.