~~ Loomio Community: The Wall ~~
This is a place for anyone to share stuff with the Loomio Community that doesn't really deserve its own discussion. You can post links to videos or blog posts, rants, etc.
Think of it as the "high volume, low priority" area within the Loomio Community.
There's an interesting public group 'Build a Hybrid [Resource Based Economy] Now' bubbling away here at the moment.
I've been reflecting on that fact that I have got into a bad habit of using @mentions to turn group conversation into one-on-one debates. Sometimes direct responses are appropriate, but they're not the same as third person @mentions (@so-and-so put it nicely when they said…), and they do tend to crank up the heat in a discussion when they turn it into verbal ping-pong between two people, in person, and online.
Perhaps there should be a different character for direct responses? Or maybe it's just something I need to be aware of, and try to avoid misusing @mentions?
@strypey yeah, I hear you. We've been talking about building a direct "reply-to-this-comment" feature, which would hopefully resolve the issue you're talking about. Then at-mentions can go back to being more about mentioning people, instead of about replying to them directly.
Thanks Jon, that sounds like a good feature. Have you considered the idea of making direct replies private, along the lines of what I suggest here, and only group replies visible to everyone?
https://www.loomio.org/discussions/6416
Just coz I think it's good when the method for making public and private comments are clearly separate, and accessed by a different part of the UI, to avoid FB-style public/private confusion.
BTW Good to see I'm not the only person using @mentions for direct responses ;-)
Hey @annaguenther and @chelsearobinson, this is the talk I mentioned the other day about business as a social movement - some interesting ideas you might not expect from a 110-year-old hearing aid company :)
"... about 20 organizations have come to Morning Star to learn more. And how many have then gone back and revamped their own operations to be more like what Drucker urged and the company has implemented?
Paul Green Jr., who helps run the Self-Management Institute that Morning Star launched to share its experiences, shakes his head. “To the best of my knowledge, zero of them have done anything meaningful,” he says..."
I don't know morning star, it seems to be something quite close to the holacracy spirit, am I right?
I think for company the change is not only blocked from the side of the huge salaries, even low salaries may actually think that the system in which they are since so long time is not so bad. Problem of cognitive dissonance...
14 Ways to Contribute to Open Source without Being a Programming Genius or a Rock Star:
http://blog.smartbear.com/programming/14-ways-to-contribute-to-open-source-without-being-a-programming-genius-or-a-rock-star/
This is All Your App IS: A Collection of Tiny Details:
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2012/05/this-is-all-your-app-is-a-collection-of-tiny-details.html
Uses an automated cat feeder as an example of user-driven development and iteration. Priceless!
A great article about engagement and why it is so important. Also some great data about the difference in outcomes for a company with enagagement compared to those without.
Would Be Nice
An edit button for comments and proposals (only for the person who created it)
Multi-stakeholder co-ops sound pretty great! Seems ideal for Loomio in the long-run.
Our friends at Sensorica seem to be using Loomio to develop their 'open value network'
https://plus.google.com/communities/107417561773024707336 [ctrl f: 'loomio']. Interesting content here
@tiberiusbrastavice
Oh wow... @rebekawhale just posted this on Yammer with the comment "Life before Loomio". Painful!!
From the Economist... Processing power: The internet helps politicians listen better to their electors. If they want to
TRANQUIL and picturesque, Friesland in northern Germany might seem an unlikely spot for an experiment in digital politics. Its population is ageing, its broadband patchy. Yet for five months local people have developed and submitted recommendations to their councillors using a website called LiquidFeedback, best known as the policy-setting platform favoured by the Pirate party, a tech-loving outfit that has won seats in four regional parliaments. Some citizens have voted for the council to stop publishing the location of speed cameras (on the ground that this helps drivers avoid them); others demand more say in how schools spend their money. Sönke Klug of the local council says he gets telephone calls every week, from big cities and small towns, asking for advice.
But...
Consultations are one thing. Acting on the results is another. Tiago Peixoto, an expert on government innovation, worries that poorly planned participatory exercises could risk creating “a new generation of disillusioned citizens”. In Iceland in 2011 the citizen council elected to write the country’s new constitution adopted an open approach that included releasing drafts online and inviting advice and criticism through social media. Voters approved its work in a referendum in October, but lawmakers have still to ratify the document. An election on April 27th will prolong the wrangling.
I'm still keen to follow up at some point on building some “open source” resources around creating and running democratic businesses. Discovered this via a permaculture contact and thought it might be of interest:
http://www.governancealive.com/
See also Introduction to Dynamic Governance:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyWRrK_JEoM#t=11
This article is amazing, and provides and in-depth analysis of all the reasons Loomio is not and will never be a voting app. Looking at both voting in representative democracies and online voting sites like Reddit, we can see that they simply serve to reinforce structural oppression and reflect the desires of the majority and the privileged.
@simontegg @richarddbartlett @matthewbartlett
What makes a group smart? Turns out it's less to do with super intelligent individuals, and more to do with social perceptiveness, taking turns speaking, and women. Go figure. :-)
How can we make the Loomio Community smarter?
ha! "More women were correlated with a more intelligent group. Interestingly, this last result is not just a diversity result. It’s not just saying that you need groups with some men and some women. It looks like that it’s a more or less linear trend. That is, more women are better all the way up to all women."
They go on to say it comes down to social perceptiveness and other skills which I would call "facilitation" and "holding space" - these are skills women are socialized a lot more to have in our society often times. I am really keen on us recognizing and improving our group's skills in these areas (more than we already have). I certainly don't believe it's an inherent issue of sex and that men can be very socially perceptive, of course. It's just a skill that requires practice and conscious attention.
The videos from UX Design Day are up now. The talks I found most helpful were Ruth Brown from Trademe, about A/B testing; and Philip Fierlinger from Xero, about their design process.
@jonlemmon @matthewbartlett @alannakrause Perhaps 'How do we make Loomio Community smarter" reaches the "deserves its own discussion" threshold.
One challenge with the 'Loomio Community' in its online sense is, there's no way to blend into the background and be visible for all to see, at the same time (ooh, you got any more G.K Chesterton for us, @matthewbartlett ? This is right up his alley).
In a real room, you can get a felt sense for 'presencing' and 'absencing' (in Theory U terms), without necessarily doing or saying anything. You can practice non-interference.
Online, I can't participate without drawing attention to myself. And I have no clue who is present or absent, literally or figuratively.
Agree that could be a useful discussion on its own, @johngraham. At present when I want to 'participate without participating' I do it by liking comments in a discussion I'm otherwise silent in. Loomio of the future is likely to include the concepts of 'following' a discussion (not requiring commenting or liking), and a display of 'who's in the room' (like the attached).
Funny, last night I just re-listened to that portion of A Miscellany of Men that I guess you must have read. (listened on Librivox, if you're interested)
@matthewbartlett Woooow nice......I was going to turn around and say, okay I can't yet do all those things online - if Loomio can help me learn, then great.
No I haven't read much Chesterton in the original, just a little Father Brown (a postman got away with murder because he was 'hidden in plain sight'). Thanks for the links.
Mockup looks great, and I imagine the new 'discussion-centric' focus will help me a lot.
By the way, that (potentially annoying) thing I did by starting a new thread Re: that discussion in the Design group which I'm not in ? That would have been solved if I could have 'liked' your comment in that thread without having to join the group.
Or of course I could have 'practiced non-interference' more.
Merry Christmas!
Here's a really interesting wiki put together by the group Gentils Virus (google translated from the French): http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwiki.gentilsvirus.org%2Findex.php%2FLoomio
Includes technical info on using Loomio + info on GV's own cultural layer on top of Loomio.
Interesting writeup on meditation and technology... What a combo! Is everyone looking after their mental health as much as their physical health?
https://medium.com/mindfulness-and-meditation/301ad5a76bd6
Interesting move by reddit.
They're going to donate 10% of all ad revenue to non-profits
http://www.redditblog.com/2014/02/decimating-our-ads-revenue.html
How French High Theory and Dr. Seuss can help explain Silicon Valley’s Gender Blindspots
Whatever the way forward, it’s not “we’re outsiders, basically” therefore we couldn’t possibly be exclusionary. And diversity in newsroom or in the development team is not just a feel-good, but a functional need as well. Fiascos such as Google Buzz in which they did not realize the extend of the backlash they’d endure by making people’s email contacts visible to each other, or Grantland’s infamous story in which they could not figure out what was offensive about hounding and outing a trans individual (they didn’t have a single one to look over the story) are some recent examples in which diversity among decision makers would have really helped bring much-needed different viewpoints to the table.
I just finished reading 'Maverick!' by Ricardo Semler, of Brazilian manufacturing company Semco, and I highly recommend it. It's an amusing and inspiring write-up of the companies many experiments with workplace democracy, motivated by Semler's fundamental belief that workers need to be treated as adults, whose ideas and initiatives are just as useful to the company as the labour they perform.
One of my favourite practices is that new hires are interviewed by the workers who will be their subordinates, as well as their superiors, and nobody is hired without full approval by both.
For those who don’t have time to read a book right now, here’s a 20 minute 2007 interview with Ricardo Semler by ABC:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxeosFrLFH8
…and a 14 minute 2005 doco about Semco called ‘The Caring Capitalist’, made by Journeyman Pictures:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gG3HPX0D2mU
Yesterday Loomio spoke with Colleen from PlaceSpeak in Vancouver, today she introduced us to David Bartlett exPremier of Tasmania, and his Ted Talk on how the crowd is changing democracy and the importance of free open internet space.
is is worth a watch
Fantastically thoughtful article about the democratic spirit and practice at Occupy Wall St by one Benjamin Barber:
http://logosjournal.com/2011/fall_barber/
The pope, keen on co-ops: http://coopgeek.wordpress.com/2014/04/09/the-co-op-pope/
' remember — I was a teenager — I was 18 years old: it was 1954, and I heard my father speak on Christian cooperativism and from that moment I developed an enthusiasm for it, I saw that it was the way. It is precisely the road to equality, not to homogenity, but to equality in difference. Even economically it goes slowly. I remember that reflection my father gave: it goes forward slowly, but it is sure.'
very interesting blog from discourse on how they manage free
http://blog.discourse.org/2014/02/discourse-installs-for-non-profit-and-education/
Long post from Dave Pollard: Systems Thinking and Complexity 101 Relevant to organisational change @vivienmaidaborn @chelsearobinson
I just watched The Internet's Own Boy: The Story of Aaron Swartz http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3268458/
It's a great movie (though sad ending of course), filled with many names connected to Loomio!
OK, rookie question: why are discussions displayed with the oldest comments first, or at least with an option to display in order of oldest/most recent?
@sionwhellens you can read the entire history of that story in the chronology thread.
Another probably rookie question: some of our members report that Loomio did not register their vote, I had the same issue (can't work out what I did differently when it went through). Any pointers? Browser issue?
Hey @sionwhellens not sure what's going on there... @hannahsalmon is going to look into it.
Hi @sionwhellens, if possible would you mind providing a little more information about the problem you experienced? Did the users you are referring to definitely click the submit button? Navigating away before clicking submit will not record the selected answer. Any details you could provide will make it easier to get to the root of the problem :)
I'll check with others, but my recollection is that I clicked on something like 'register your vote' and nothing happened. I think I had to refresh a couple of times before it responded.
Hi @hannahsalmon, here's the feedback: "i clicked on the voting buttons twice (vote early vote often) but nothing happened on the ipad. i will try agin on a PC and see if that works." My own problem also happened on an iPad.
Safari for iPad?
@hannahsalmon this is a known bug on iOS - would you be interested in taking a look?
Hi @sionwhellens, we're looking into this now. Thanks for the heads up :)
@simon @matthewbartlett have you seen https://pol.is/ ?
Hey everybody.
I'm interested in getting in touch with people from (or living in) Denmark, that are interested in politics and Loomio. I'm involved in a new political party and we're working on how to use Loomio as part of our policy development process.
We're setting up our own instance of Loomio (could be a way to also test some new features and give feedback to the Loomio community)
Want to hear more?
Drop me an e-mail: mads.ringblom@alternativet.dk
@ronanmchugh, @nicolaswormser, @jordifaxedas ?
Hey folks here's some clips from a talk I gave yesterday: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1I78I6l1nzI
One thing that didn't make it to camera was my extended disclaimer about how my personal views don't necessarily represent the views of the Loomio project generally ;)