Multi-option decisions
While Loomio is a brilliant tool, it is entirely focused on binary decision making. Yes or No, Option A or Option B. However, real life often throws up situations where you have options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, and it can be hard to fairly whittle these down to a binary decision.
Therefore I would love to see Loomio implement a multi-candidate voting process, which groups could either use as an early indicative poll or as a final decision.
I would suggest building on the work of openSTV.org, but simplifying - e.g. only Instant Runoff method.
Hi @richardgrevers, we have discussed this feature at length in this group. The card for the ideas feature that @gregorycassel has linked to contains links to the relevant discussions.
Great ideia. There is also the chance of having delegative voting?
Em 29/11/2014 03:22, "Richard Grevers (Loomio)" escreveu:
Richard Grevers started a discussion in Loomio Community:
Multi-option decisions
While Loomio is a brilliant tool, it is entirely focused on binary decision making. Yes or No, Option A or Option B. However, real life often throws up situations where you have options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, and it can be hard to fairly whittle these down to a binary decision.
Therefore I would love to see Loomio implement a multi-candidate voting process, which groups could either use as an early indicative poll or as a final decision.
I would suggest building on the work of openSTV.org, but simplifying - e.g. only Instant Runoff method.
—
Reply to this email directly or view it on Loomio.
Change your email preferences to unsubscribe from Loomio emails.
STV/IRV is a powerful tool. I believe that the core Loomio team is adding a somewhat comparable function with the 'Ideas' feature: https://www.loomio.org/d/5Lxbd4Rs/ideas-proto-proposals
The Ideas feature doesn't ask individuals to rank ideas by order of preference. This is less precise than STV. I think that that's a deliberate choice, but it would be better for a more knowledgeable person to chime in.
I don't think of consensus process as Option A or Option B, but rather, Option A or Not Option A. In other words, nothing changes (from current practices) unless there is a collective agreement for a change or addition to occur. This can, if desired, be used to amend or to rescind any previous action.
STV by contrast, can't create consensus in and of itself. I love it as an alternative to single-choice voting for candidates, but it can create a tyranny of the majority or of the biggest minority.
In theory, an organic process of developing a strong proposal ('Decision') and then amending it either before or AFTER it passes/fails can cover all of the ideas which would come up with Options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, but without forcing anyone to accept decisions which they don't agree with.