Loomio

Multi-option decisions

Richard Grevers PublicSeen by 182

While Loomio is a brilliant tool, it is entirely focused on binary decision making. Yes or No, Option A or Option B. However, real life often throws up situations where you have options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, and it can be hard to fairly whittle these down to a binary decision.
Therefore I would love to see Loomio implement a multi-candidate voting process, which groups could either use as an early indicative poll or as a final decision.
I would suggest building on the work of openSTV.org, but simplifying - e.g. only Instant Runoff method.

Greg Cassel

STV/IRV is a powerful tool. I believe that the core Loomio team is adding a somewhat comparable function with the 'Ideas' feature: https://www.loomio.org/d/5Lxbd4Rs/ideas-proto-proposals

The Ideas feature doesn't ask individuals to rank ideas by order of preference. This is less precise than STV. I think that that's a deliberate choice, but it would be better for a more knowledgeable person to chime in.

I don't think of consensus process as Option A or Option B, but rather, Option A or Not Option A. In other words, nothing changes (from current practices) unless there is a collective agreement for a change or addition to occur. This can, if desired, be used to amend or to rescind any previous action.

STV by contrast, can't create consensus in and of itself. I love it as an alternative to single-choice voting for candidates, but it can create a tyranny of the majority or of the biggest minority.

In theory, an organic process of developing a strong proposal ('Decision') and then amending it either before or AFTER it passes/fails can cover all of the ideas which would come up with Options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, but without forcing anyone to accept decisions which they don't agree with.

Deleted account

Hi @richardgrevers, we have discussed this feature at length in this group. The card for the ideas feature that @gregorycassel has linked to contains links to the relevant discussions.

Ricardo Araújo

Great ideia. There is also the chance of having delegative voting?

Em 29/11/2014 03:22, "Richard Grevers (Loomio)" escreveu:

Richard Grevers started a discussion in Loomio Community:

Multi-option decisions

While Loomio is a brilliant tool, it is entirely focused on binary decision making. Yes or No, Option A or Option B. However, real life often throws up situations where you have options A,B.C.D.E,F, and G, and it can be hard to fairly whittle these down to a binary decision.

Therefore I would love to see Loomio implement a multi-candidate voting process, which groups could either use as an early indicative poll or as a final decision.

I would suggest building on the work of openSTV.org, but simplifying - e.g. only Instant Runoff method.

—

Reply to this email directly or view it on Loomio.

Change your email preferences to unsubscribe from Loomio emails.