Loomio

Integrating Loomio with town hall style meetings

Danyl Strype PublicSeen by 120

Great to see Loomio mentioned in the Guardian:
http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/blog/business-attempts-consult-public-creativity

Particularly this fascinating suggestion:

>> Second, use a variety of creative means to get people's views. Why not combine a tool such as Loomio with public events to make engagement entertaining in itself?

It's now common practice at geeky conferences to project Twitter onto a screen, so everyone present can see hash-tagged comments, both from those at event and remote participants watching live streams. Would anyone be keen to try the same things with Loomio instead of Twitter? How could this work in practice?

Alanna Irving

I'd like to see this happen. It's come up a few times... We'd need to right situation where a group of people at a conference actually wanted to make decisions together.

Robert Guthrie

I've been having a small vision in my head recently, involving people in the same geographic location meeting on loomio.

In one vision:
A user starts a Loomio discussion, they make it open to the public, and create a tiny loomio url.. like loom.io/wellington-town-hall They then write the url on a wall and people start discussing online.

In the next vision.

Loomio asks people if they want to share their geographic location. You just opt into this and suddenly public discussions can be placed on a map. Someone could just mention 'join the loomio for this location' and people could join instantly from a location aware homepage.

Danyl Strype

Just saw this animated presentation, 'The Innovation of Loneliness', which talks about the way online interaction can increase loneliness by substituting quantity of connections for quality of conversations:
http://vimeo.com/70534716

FB wants you to spend more time on their site, where they can find ways to monetize your social connections. In contrast, Loomio wants to facilitate real democracy, which arguably requires real, in-person relationships. Are there ways that Loomio - an online tool - can encourage and facilitate in-person gatherings?

Richard D. Bartlett

@robertguthrie I love that vision when the location is something like a shared working space, or a community garden, or a general assembly, or a park...

Danyl Strype

I also really like @robertguthrie 's idea of Loomio discussions/ groups which are open to anyone within a given street/ block/ neighbourhood/ town/ city/whatever, with a short url which can be promoted offline in that area. New neighbourhood/ municipal/ regional groupings could form organically that way, leading to the organisation of face-to-face assemblies.

vivien maidaborn

yes I am regularly asked about Loomio for synchronise connection, the more we can build to incorporate that as an option the better I would say

Danyl Strype

I could add that in my experience it's more likely to work the other way around; if a public meeting or general assembly which somehow includes a Loomio discussion/ group (or actively promotes a link to one), that Loomio tool has a good chance of being used for follow-up, ongoing discussion, and one way of organising or promoting future face-to-face assemblies.

Alanna Irving

I agree - meetings and events are great for bringing people together initially and sparking conversations, but Loomio is great for working together on an ongoing basis and delivering outcomes.

Tim Rayner

Love this idea. We're imagining something similar, using Loomio in the context of open-invite collaborative design workshops. The challenge presented to running a successful open-invite co-design w/shop is alignment. If there's no preexisting values alignment, there's no shared orientation, and it's impossible to co-design something that is important and meaningful to all participants.

Does anyone have a use case for rapidly creating a sense of alignment in a disparate group to prepare them for codesign work?

Alanna Irving

@silviazuur @vivienmaidaborn @chelsearobinson might have some interesting thoughts

Deleted account

For my organisation, we have meetings every two months to discuss proposals. There is some discussion online beforehand, but there is little engagement with it because it isn't very accessible. We need to improve this.

I'd love to see a way for us to use loomio at these meetings to highlight the key points of the online discussion before we start discussing in person (and possibly using Loomio to take minutes?)

We have a projector going always and everyone had a laptop too. Could there be an alternative "live discussion" view of Loomio proposals? Perhaps with the proposal brief and just highlighting a single comment OR the comment that was being added live?

brainstorming

Alanna Irving

Good ideas @dean - live updating is something we're definitely going to have at some point (not exactly sure when).

However, it sounds like there might be ways to use existing Loomio functionality to help your use case right now. In my experience, using Loomio between meetings has helped groups I am a part of spend our precious face-time much more productively. If you discuss the agenda points on Loomio before each meeting, a lot of the key pieces of information and the crux of any disagreement will be brought to the surface, putting you in a good position to make the final decision at the meeting.

Or, in many groups I am a part of it works the other way too - at the meeting we hash out the context and have discussion deepening everyone's understanding of the issue, then we make the final decision on Loomio. This means the decision and positions are very clear and there is an automatic archive created.

Deleted account

Thanks @alanna! I definitely want to use Loomio to bring disagreements to the surface re. proposals. TBH it is all happening on Facebook at the moment because our website doesn't have the functionality, this is flawed because discussion is happening in social pockets and not in the whole group. Loomio would be the perfect solution. I think I'll try to make my own install to show it off.

I think our main meeting will always be the key decision making body, but for easy issues with good discussion online we could just ratify a decision made with Loomio?

Alanna Irving

Yes @dean we do that a lot in different groups I am in - we make the decision on Loomio and ratify at meetings. This is often required officially for things like boards of directors, where the legal statutes have no caught up with the digital age :)

Jochen Walter

I think that in my personnel environment there are still a lot of people engaged in social or environmental activities and groups without a lot of smartphones and laptops. The vision of a life with more of this is not mine. But I like the vision of using Loomio in between the meetings for deeper and well structured and well informed discussions and having meetings where people have time to know each other, to link to each other and become aware of personnel problems and circumstances of each other. This will be more social media than fb and so on. We still need real meetings, deep connections.